advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Dec 03, 2008 -- Just say no to an automaker bailout

The automakers are in the midst of their begathon appeal to Congress and the president. While political talk show hosts have been all over this story, Clark wants to discuss it from an economic perspective.

GM sales are down some 40%, Chrysler is down some 50% and Ford is down around 30%. The American people have spoken -- day after day, purchase after purchase -- and said they don't want the products the Big 3 are making.

This is not, however, a diatribe about the American worker. It's really general management that has failed. Case in point: There was a GM plant in Fremont, California, that was just about the worst plant since the days of the Yugo. Toyota took the plant over; hired back the exact same workers who were employed there under GM; and it went from worst to first within 2 years. Again, there's nothing wrong with the American worker; it's management that's at fault.

Now we have the Big 3 coming to us and begging to get them out of their management failures. GM says it could fail in a matter of weeks. They're trying to create a sudden sense of urgency.

Capitalism allows you to file for bankruptcy, reorganize in Chapter 11 and try to make a go of it again. That's how the system should work. It should not entail us being told to empty our wallets because the Big 3 didn't make cars that we wanted to buy.

In capitalism, if a business is allowed to fail, the marketplace allows other more efficient businesses to survive. We pervert the system by bailing out manufacturers who have inefficiencies. Of course, the Big 3 will cloak themselves in the American flag during their begathon, but what they're really looking to do is put capitalism in a straightjacket.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • Automaker Bailout
    I absolutely agree with Clark on the automaker's bailout. Clark's statement that “We pervert the system” is exactly what is happening.

    The big 3 automakers have been greedy and not used much foresight in planning for change as other manufacturers have. When our family purchased a new auto two years ago, we researched using the fueleconomy.gov website. There were a handful of the big 3 manufactures models that offered decent fuel efficiency, but the emissions rating was far higher than the foreign manufactured models. Our intention was to reduce our fuel cost, but the low emission rating was what sold us on a Honda.

    I do feel for the older retirees of these companies whose retirement planning during their working years consisted of a pension plan instead of today's 401Ks. I am not certain what a failure will mean for these folks.
  • Automaker Bailout
    I feel slightly sorry for the employees of the firms that a manufacturer's failure will impact, (only slightly because of their inflated salary and benefit schedule) however, I am full agreement with Clark on this one. The automakers haven't produced the products that America wants or needs and they should suffer the consequences for it.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement