advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Jan 21, 2010 -- Barnes & Noble tries out college textbook rental

Barnes & Noble is experimenting with college textbook rental as part of a pilot program being rolled out on several dozen campuses across the country.

The bookseller is taking a cue from sites like Chegg.com that have pioneered textbook rental and saved students and parents more than $100,000 in the process. If Barnes & Noble's program does well, it will create strong competition for Chegg.

Several years ago, Clark went on the air talking about how it's a racket when professors get paid by publishers to revise their textbooks annually and push the updated editions in course syllabi.

He heard from an angry science professor arguing that educators would be shortchanging their students if they didn't update -- because the field of science evolves so rapidly. That may be true at the graduate level, but not at the undergraduate level.

Most undergrads are just trying to decide what they want to do for a career. To make underclassmen buy an updated textbook every year is ridiculous. University presidents should enforce longer cycles on textbook updates from their professors. Except for rare instances like biotech, there can't be that many changes to rook students with new course material every single year!

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • renting books
    I went to Central Missouri State University in Warrensburg for my masters and rented books in 1969. Why is this such a NEW concept? Yes, I know it is a money maker for higher education!
    In addition, I taught Health Education at Radford University in Virginia for 32 years and the last 6-8 years I taught, (retired in 12/022) I identified websites for students to read for class discussion/information w/o requiring a textbook to be purchased.
    Yes, it made more work for me, but staying informed is what my students deserve. With all the new/changing health information, I found textbooks are not up to date from the time they are printed.
    I know most, if not all college profs in their courses could do what I did.
  • Buying and selling textbooks
    I purchase my textbooks online using campusbooks.com to find the lowest prices. After I finish the class, I sell my books on half.com. I carefully calculate the shipping charges and commission to make sure I break even on my books. Some semesters I even make a little profit! I think it's a great way to "rent" textbooks for free!
  • Renting Books
    Cheaper than renting books is buying them online from alibris.com Great prices! New books and used books. The only down side is that it may take up to ten days for the books to arrive in the mail although you can pay more for fast delivery - however most students know what classes they will be taking with pleanty of time to order books through the mail. I get all my books through alibris.com for half to one tenth the price our university bookstore sells them for!

    Try it. You'll like it!!
    http://www.alibris.com
  • Cheaper than Chegg?
    If you don't mind going through the small hassle that is buying and selling online you can get your text books on half.com used and sell them when you're done. My books end up costing tens of dollars, not hundreds.
  • Chegg and textbooks
    FIrst, most publishers do new editions every four years.
    Second, if they use a code to do homework, the cost of buying the code and the rental may be more than a new text.
    Third, Chegg's rental is a few months, if a student uses a book more than one term, cheaper to buy the book.
    Fourth, a better solution is to buy the book directly from the publisher. they will save lots of money!
  • Cheap Purchases
    I purchased through Abebooks.com this semester and saved a fortune. This is a clearinghouse for individual sellers. Ex - I got a used book that sold at the bookstore for $84 for only $20 at Abebooks. You do have to be careful with the sellers on this site. All the books from the various sellers arrived quickly, but one called "Motor City Books" took forever and had terrible customer service.
  • chegg
    I used Chegg once but never again. They sent two of the same book I ordered and none of a second book. Had a terrible time getting any response from customer service. Finally got the situation rectified but it took a very long time. I have since found that it is much cheaper to buy used textbooks online at half.com and then resell them the same way. You can almost get all your money back that way!
  • text books
    My daughter just saved 500.00 on her books through Chegg. The best part was they were all delivered to her apartment.
  • They are great
    I've been using them for my sons textbooks the last two semesters and they have saved me hundreds of dollars already. After reading about the savings on kindle, I may have to give that a try.
  • Textbook Rental
    Yay! Its about time. The textbook publishers are making a killing, I say bring on the competition!
  • kindle
    Except for science books, most humanities books are on the Kindle and are much cheaper. The Kindle pays itself off in one semester.
  • Some professors are great!
    My average book cost is $200 and change each semester thanks to Amazon.com, Half.com, and Chegg.com. I weigh whether to buy or rent based on cost. Most of the professors at Lee University stretch out edition usage past the publisher's desired time period. For instance, many textbooks I HAVE to buy used since they are no longer in print because they are an edition back from the publisher. Great deal for me! Not all schools are trying to rip students off.
  • new ttextbook editions
    The push for new editions is driven by publishers, not professors. Professors much prefer to keep the same edition as long as possible because it is so much extra work to assign new homework problems, cover new topics , etc. Also, my experience has been that editions turn over every three years, not every year. I am not sure where Clark got his information on this topic.
  • International editions
    I posted this on Facebook, but I figured I would repeat it here.

    I have had very good results buying "international student edition" textbooks from Malaysia through eBay (from sellers with very high ratings). They are typically delivered through UPS or DHL in 3 or 4 days and usually cost about $50 each, inclusive of shipping. It's the exact same text and color print as the US version, only in a paperback. Apparently this is perfectly legal as a result of a Supreme Court decision.

    The only problem I have encountered is that two of my books this semester have 32 additional pages at the beginning of the book, throwing off the page numbers. I just have to add 32 to everything the instructors assign.

    On the other hand, I spent $220 on books that would have cost me about $500 used. I'm in a technical financial field, so I want to keep my books as references, at least for a few years. Renting just won't work for me. I also hate underlining and highlighting in used books, because other students seem to highlight all the wrong stuff.
  • The college book Racket
    I hope Barnes/Noble and others
    adopt this program.

    The cost of a new book is ridiculous on college campuses. My daughter had to buy a paper back book with required student access code attached.

    Cost was 103.00

    Amazon had it for 51.00 without student access code.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement