advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Nov 17, 2009 -- Ground beef recall results after plant stopped E. coli testing

More than 500,000 pounds of ground beef was recalled late last month after two people died and estimated 500 were sickened by an E. coli outbreak, according to The New York Times.

The tainted beef came from a meat-packer in Ashville, N.Y. that reportedly stopped testing for E. coli two years ago at the request of beef suppliers. Surprisingly, E. coli testing is not required the Department of Agriculture. It's only recommended sans any legal enforcements for not doing it.

The recall has prompted Trader Joe's to stop sourcing its meat from the affected plant. The grocer also now wants its other suppliers to test all ground beef for the deadly bacteria.

Costco Wholesale is the only large national retailer that mandates E. Coli testing. Perhaps Costco can do so because it uses its own grinding facilities.

Too often it seems like the Department of Agriculture feels its responsibility is to protect processing plants and beef suppliers, not the American consumer.

Clark is an unabashed free-marketer, but he knows that there need to be some referees in place for capitalism to work optimally. The marketplace suffers when there's no cop on the beat. Consumers need to feel confident that the feds are on the case to make sure their food is safe.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • Most of the comments here are perposterous and way out of line. You have no clue. The REAL issue is integrity of these companies, and NOT weather or not the govt has a hand in the matter or not, or the 'free market system. Holland is very socialist and they test all meat for ecoli. Socialism owrks there, but it would never work here because most people in the country are too greedy. Yes I am for a free market system and a registered republican. People in Holland can eat all their meat shahimi style ( raw ), even the bacon.

    Get a grip people and lets try to be , how how shall I say this, more reasonable? Sometimes I wonder where you all went to school. I conclude that thinking for yourself is not taught in most schools these days.
  • Ground meat
    Don't like overcooked hamburger...grind your own. a 50-50 mix of chuck and sirloin scraps can be ground with a few pulses in your food processor.
  • Government is Causing the Ecoli Problem
    This is a classic case of unintended consequences by the government. Since they're involved in virtually all aspects of our lives, the vast majority of US citizens just presume they require Ecoli testing and their food is safe.

    We actually would have Ecoli testing on all beef if the useless and wasteful FDA didn't exist. Know why? Because the free market would rush in to fill the demand for beef that is certified to be free from Ecoli.

    We don't need anywhere near this much government. The free market would take care of things like this, in an efficient manner, if the government would get the hell out of our lives.
  • Food Supply Safety: Addendum
    Per CDC guidelines: Remember that achieving a brown color when cooking hamburgers does not guarantee that E. coli bacteria have been killed. This is especially true for patties that have been frozen. Verifying a core temperature of at least 160 degrees Fahrenheit for at least 15 seconds is trustworthy. Small, disposable meat thermometers are available to check this: a small investment compared to the medical expense (and grief) of one infected family member.

    Sorry, vegans, but you are also at risk of E. coli infection. Again, the CDC: Be sure to clean and sanitize all imported and domestic fruits or vegetables. All can be carriers of disease. If possible, fruits should be skinned, or at least vigorously scrubbed and/or washed. Vegetables (and of course meat) should be cooked to a core temperature of at least 160 degrees Fahrenheit for at least 15 seconds. If not cooked, fruits and vegetables should be washed to remove any dirt or other material, and then soaked in chlorinated water (1 teaspoon of household bleach in one quart of water, soaked for at least 15 minutes). They can then be rinsed in clean water to remove the chlorine taste. This will remove most, but not all, bacteria. In the case of leafy vegetables, bacteria may not be limited to the leaf’s surface, but can actually reside within the minute circulatory system of the individual vegetable leaves.
  • Tainted meat
    A simple solution is to thoroughly cook your ground meat. Even if it's tainted with E. Coli, once fully cooked it is safe to eat. What's so difficult to understand about that?

    Yes, there should be some safeguards in place. But that doesn't relieve us from taking simple and reasonable steps to ensure our own safety. We are not sheep.
  • This is insane!
    What on Earth are the people thinking that say the "government" shouldn't be testing food for public safety? Sometimes it's obvious this show airs right before Hannity, isn't it?

    On a second note, why did the poster feel the need to put quotation marks around government? Did he mean it sarcastically?
  • E coli testing
    If you cook your ground beef thoroughly, you don't have to worry about it. More government regulation is not the answer--government cannot protect us from every little thing that comes down the pike. Be knowledgeable and protect yourself.
  • Costco
    God bless Costco for looking out for us! More the reason to shop there plus the lower cost of meat. Go Costco! We love you!
  • General Food Supply Safety
    @Drew: I can understand why you suggest that people shop only at Costco or Trader Joe’s re their E.coli testing programs, but most people can't. Their U.S. locations are limited, and the cost to either become a Costco member or shop at TJ's is unaffordable to many, especially now.

    @Emorgan and GatorFan: I’m all for free enterprise, but I think the U.S. Government has to assume more responsibility for the safety of the food supply to better protect consumers. Hello, it doesn’t all originate in the U.S. anymore. Are you planning to fly around the world to “take responsibility for (your) own survival”? Good luck with that.

    There are numerous bipartisan bills before Congress that are asking for more food processing inspections, public notification of food recalls (presently none are required!) and so on; all are stuck in committee. I suggest visitingt Consumers Union’s notinmyfood.org site for information and ways to tell your U.S. senators and congresspersons that ytou want more food supply safety protections.
  • Ah, I see...
    So am I correct, therefore, in presuming that those who advocate that the "Government" should not be involved in testing for e. coli or any other food safety issue are capable of determining for themselves the safety of every food product they consume?

    I myself do not have a portable e coli testing lab nor a farm of my own on which to grow my own untainted meat, and I *suspect* that there might be a few other folks out there like me. Do you pure free-market folks have any alternative suggestions to government testing that would still prevent companies from selling tainted meat?

    If your answer is free market economics, I would suggest that for markets to function as the sole means of consumer protection, the consumer must be fully informed (or able to be so) about alternatives and risks. Thus, if you do believe in shifting the full responsibility for this sort of thing to the consumer, how then will you ensure that these consumers are, in fact, *able* to learn this requisite information if they choose. Our current, highly complex system of food distribution hides the history and origin of food products at every stage, and it is only due to that big, bad government intervention you decry that we can avail ourselves of the modest information we have at present about such products. Without labeling requirements, there would be little for the consumer to do but eat and pray...and no criminal recourse, only civil, for those whose lives were adversely affected by the negligence of a food provider.

    Just some thoughts...
  • e-coli
    Your are absolutely right GatorFan. The government is in our lives WAAAAY too much as it is. We should take responsiblity for our own survival.
  • E coli beef
    Roderick, why do you look to government to solve this problem? We're falling prey to our own thought processes that government is the fix for all our ills.
  • E COLI BEEF
    I TKINK THATS A DAMN SHAME; YOU WOULD THINK THE GOVERMENT WOULD DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS.
  • Meat eaters get e-coli cause of animal kharma?
    Humans have been eating MEAT for thousands of years! You can get E-Coli from cashews, green onions and even LETTUCE! I Suppose eating anything would be "bad Kharma!" Grow up and keep your opinions to yourself!
  • If you kill animals (or contribute to senseless slaughter) then eat them and die it is called Karma. Stop eating meat, live longer and don't worry about this stuff.
  • Free market
    It looks like the free market is working. Costco and Trader Joes are requiring ecoli testing without gov't intervention. If the public feels strongly about this issue, they will only shop at those 2 stores, and then all the rest will have to follow suit. If the public doesn't care about this, they will continue to buy meat from elsewhere. What about carbon monoxide and beef?
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement