advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Nov 09, 2009 -- The right way to cash out your 401(k)

The average worker no longer spends a lifetime with a single employer. That raises a dilemma when you do leave a job: What to do with your 401(k)?

New estimates from Hewitt Associates, a human resources consulting firm, suggest that 46 percent of people spend their 401(k) when they move on from an employer. Of course, you always have the option to just leave it with the old employer's plan or roll it over to your new employer's plan.

If you do choose to cash out your 401(k), know that you'll typically get hit with taxes and penalties that can eat up some 40 percent of your money.

For example, if you take a 401(k) with $10,000 in it and cash it out, you get a tax bill for 20 percent upfront. Then when you file your tax return the following year, you get hit with another 20 percent in taxes and penalties.

That means your $10,000 becomes more like $6,000 and you have zero saved for retirement. Very bad math.

Remember, cashing out an old 401(k) should only be a last resort when you exhaust all other sources of money to live on.

But if you need to get at that money, the smart way is to have it rolled over to an IRA and only draw what you need to live. That way you can reduce the tax and penalties you'll face.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • over 55, separated from emp, no penalty withdrawal
    My CPA said that there is a rule that says you can withdraw your 401(K) if you are over 55 and have 'separated' from your employer without taking the penalty hit. He said there is a formula: they plug in the total in your account and your life expectency, and you get a fixed amount you will get every month until you die or run out of money. Any leftovers will of course go to your beneficiaries. I haven't had a chance to get more info from him; has any one heard of this? Thanks..
  • early withdrawal
    Someone advised me if you haven't worked for sometime you can withdraw your 401k without penalty. Has anyone else heard about this? I'm 56 turning 57 in a few months
  • 401k withdrawal at 59.5 & over
    I am 61 yrs of age & need to make a withdrawal from my 401k to pay off a couple of bills because I am operating in the negative monthly when paying my bills vs my income from my full time job. I would like to withdraw about 20 thousand to pay off bills & do so work on my home. Is there a grant I can apply for from the gov't for homeowners?
    I have been putting off withdrawing from my 401K because I don't want to make the wrong decision. Is there any way to avoid paying taxes - I know I can withdraw w/o paying a penalty because of being over 59.5. Please help me make the right decision. I always pay my bills & on time - my credit score has been around 7.50 - have not cked it in a couple of yrs. thanks for your help and prompt response. mine is a "before tax"
  • Roll over your 401K
    Try a Vangard no load fund. I like Vwelx. No freakin sales load and a .29 expense ratio. Dude, you can't get much better than that.
  • Prudential and getting a clue
    Don't abuse people! There's no such thing as an after-tax 401k. So you're not so sharp. Yes - roll into a regular IRA with just about ANY BROKER and avoid ANY INSURANCE COMPANY (TIAA is OK but avoid all the others as they bundle in way too much expense). I'm pretty happy with TD Waterhouse as a broker. If you're not too knowledgeable, use Fidelity or Vanguard and buy one of their worldwide mutual funds (Vanguard charges lower fees)
  • rolling a 401k
    Get it out of the Prudential 401k and into a rollover ira. You didn't say if it's pre or post tax money. If tax deferred go to rollover ira. If after tax go into a roth. The 401k plan limits your choices and costs you big time. Who do you think pays the Prudential plan administrator fees? The only reason to keep a ripoff 401k is if a deal too good to be true or if you need the protection from creditors ERISA provides to the 401k. COME on PEOPLE, GET A CLUE. You have your whole life to study this information. WE as a nation are doomed. Please, please GET A CLUE! What the heck do you people do with all your time? Obviously not managing you personal affairs. We will lose our nation. This is my home too. I have nowhere else to go. Ever traveled overseas. Care to move there permanently? Not.
  • Penalty
    You can say it 3 times and still get it wrong Debra. The 20% is WITHHOLDING (in anticipation of tax) then there is a 10% PENALTY as well.
  • Penalty
    It is a 10% early distribution penalty not 20%
  • What I did
    My 401k was with Vanguard. After I went back to school I just called them up and had them convert it into an IRA. Why don't you call up Prudential and see if they'll do the same?
  • converting a 401K
    I got laid off and now I need to convert my 401K into an IRA or Roth IRA. With out legally binding yourself can you tell me exactly were to put my account. It is a Prudential 401K and about $15,000.00 if that matters.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement