advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Oct 21, 2009 -- American Cancer Society raising questions about screenings

The Wall Street Journal reports that the American Cancer Society questions the relative value of screening for breast and prostate cancer, which are the two most common types of cancer.

However, Clark wants to caution you not to get the wrong message from this new development. Screenings are valuable, but it's what you do with the information that's even more important.

Clark, for example, discovered that he has early stage prostate cancer. Yet he has around a 46 percent chance of never needing any treatment for his particular disease profile. But when he tells people he hasn't had treatment, they freak out. So often in our culture, diagnosis equals treatment. But it's not done that way all over the world, particularly in Europe.

There is some basic wisdom Clark can share that doesn't change:

• Get tested.
• Don't panic.
• Read medical journals so you can be the manager of your own health.
• Act -- don't react -- based on what you find.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

Add your comment

Security Image * Please enter the code shown at left
what's this?

What others are saying

  • screenings
    Iam a busy small town doc. We really do not know how to predict the behavior of a lot of these early stage cancers. I just talk over the options alot with patients. This takes a while and my waits are long. My brother had prostate cancer and I'm watching my situation closely. Thanks for your approach to a tough decision. Good luck and love your show.
  • Mammograms
    Mammograms. I am real tired of the medical profession beating women over the head for annual mammogram testing. When I make an appointment to see a doctor for something, I don’t want to be beaten over the head with long winded re-hearsed pitches about getting a mammogram!

    What really gets me is they “push making a mammogram appointment” for you right then and there! I didn’t come in to talk about “mammograms” I came in to talk about other serious medical conditions!

    The public needs to know. That the beast cancer bunch, has big name movie stars behind there campaigns. That the machines donated to the MRI departments are funded only if the medical establishment pushes mammograms. In other words for each mammogram they perform $$$$ into the cash register of the HMO.

    Furthermore, the “breast cancer awareness bunch” seems to change the criteria for “women needing mammograms” when the pool of victims seems to run low. Each decade they have changed the criteria! First it was if your family has a history of, then it was women over 50, then it was anyone of a certain age and gender!

    The medical industry needs to put the same energy into the real medical threat in this country-obesity! Patients should be sent to a weight scale and BMI test, and given prescriptions for weight loss, with a real program, medications, and actual diet and exercise plans!

    Too many women have had their breasts needlessly cut off………
  • Screening
    What is most troubling about the WSJ article is the inference that if you are screened and found to have an innocuous cancer, your physician will treat you anyway.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement