advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Sep 28, 2009 -- Negotiating credit card debt down yourself

Debt-settlement firms promise they can negotiate your credit card debt down to just pennies on the dollar. But are they true to their word?

Too often that promise is an illusion. You usually pay an upfront fee to the debt-settlement firm, plus a monthly retainer. Their strategy is to get you to stop paying on your bills. They typically have you take the money you would have paid on monthly minimums and stash it in a savings account.

The basic idea is to make the credit card companies so desperate that they'll settle with you. The reality, however, is that you just wind up damaging your credit.

Did you know that you can negotiate down your debt by yourself? Begin by figuring out what you owe and what you can afford to pay. Then call up your various creditors and say, "My total debt is X number of dollars and I can afford to pay you X amount every month."

Set a condition that all of your creditors must agree to your terms in writing or no one gets anything at all. And don't give them access to your checking account! You'll want to pay them directly to safeguard your funds.

It's important to know that this approach will foul up your credit and you'll get a tax bill from the IRS for each settlement. If you owe $10,000 to one creditor and they take $2,000, then the $8,000 that's written off is considered taxable income for you.

The power you have lies in the fact that credit card companies are scared you'll go bankrupt and then they get zero. More than a million people are expected to file bankruptcy in 2009. That means creditors that wouldn't deal with you before now probably will.

Finally, there is another option. You can use NFCC.org to pay off your debt over time in a negotiated settlement. Those who are particularly burdened may qualify for a hardship debt-management plan (DMP) through the above link.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • walk in your shoe
    Obviously you don't have credit cards or you are ignorant to the extremely high interest rates charged which run up ones credit. You don't owe an extra 18% -200%interest on charges. Therefore one cannot "pay it because you owe it". As far as jailing deadbeat, remember that how Britain did your ancestors, let's not travel back in time. Obviously those bank received "bail outs" and there CEO Billions of our tax dollars can afford to write off credit debit. After all these lenders have already receive 3x times the debit in interest; and some continue to receive high interest payments. Greed is only reason that customers are not allowed to receive lower interest rates. If the banks lower all payments as well as interest rates and the economy will rise.
  • I honestly can't believe the attitudes of people.
    I have always been very frugal, I have had to this most of my life in order to have what I consider a decent living, most would consider poor. I have never been late on anything in my life of borrowing money, and these people on here that want to preach about morals, and intergrity and just pay cash. They call you a deadbeat? I just want to cry. I have been single now for over 8 years with serious medical issues, and I work everyday with them. I can not afford to be out of work due to my honesty intergrity and bills get paid before anything else. But now with this economy the credit cards I have been paying double on to get paid off, the interest rates have changed over night, and that means I may for once in my life not be able to pay them off. You may say well why didn't you pay cash or not use them? Well sometimes you don't have that option if the next option is homeless or paying your bills or taking care of something that is an emergency as I have done. But now the way it looks I don't even know if I want to come to Clark's site anymore. If we are going to argue Bush or Obama, Deadbeats, cash or nothing. Good people have bad things happen in their life and those that wish the ones that have this happen jail or worse. I pity I hope you never find yourself alone with no family, and only you to defend for yourself and pay your bills as I pay mine. I will find elsewhere with more positive people to see me through keeping my "perfect" credit and paying my bills "perfectly" every month, and now am worried I will not be able to with what credit card companys are doing. I am not a spender of out to eat, clothes, etc. These where true emergencies which I have been responsbile and paid, but why does that mean that the ones that carry a balance have to be punished by those credit card companies and those who did not pay or had to file bankruptcy. I hope this is not what our society has came to as individuals, but I am so afraid it has become one for self and self only.
  • Walk in your shoes?
    Why is it that someone saying "you should walk in my shoes before you judge" is seen as a valid argument.
    Was it me that ran up your credit card balance? Was it me that made poor choices? Is it me that is now looking for a way out--other than paying what you legally and morally owe?
    I don't need to walk in anyone's shoes to be able to judge their actions. You ran up debts that you agreed to pay. You now owe those debts no matter what the credit card company does or doesn't do. You life situation has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with your obligation to pay back what you were given.
    How can anyone with a hint of moral fiber think they can justify getting out of a debt they incurred because they don't like what the bank is or isn't doing? You owe it, you pay it.
  • Credit Card Debt & Disability=^..^=
    I have an outstanding amount (a very nominal fee, believe me) on a credit card from some years back and they are still bugging me about it.
    My attitude is this: The credit cards are blatantly ripping us off with their high interest rates and finding ANY excuse to raise the interest on them that my feathers are not ruffled in the LEAST when they call me to collect.
    I DO NOT and NEVER HAVE sweated it when a collector calls me. I have caller ID and my tactic is to just not answer the phone when they call or on those few ocassions when I DO answer and they ask me if I'd like to do anything to remedy the situation I just tell them no and hang up. The bottom line ls that I'm on Disability. What can they do to me? Put a lien on my house or car? I have neither. I'm not woried about my credit in the long run because being on Disability I'm not planning on making large purchases. They can't sue me either. The debt I have is not even for $1500! Being on Disability I can't pay it off. I'm not worried. Believe me, folks, the credit card companies are not going to go under for $1500! Thy are making money hand over fist and they KNOW that they are ripping us off. They don't need my money.
    The next time a collector calls you ask yourself, "What can they REALLY do to me?" I have found that the majority of those who ask themselves that question can answer this way: "Absolutely NOTHING."
    I'm not recommending being irresponsible, but, when you DO have an outstanding bill stop getting yourself all worked up over it and think logically about it. They are not gods. They'd like you to believe that they are.
  • vacation clubs
    Jeff,
    typically "vacation clubs" are not a good investment.. they should not be considered an investment in any way shape or form. they are much like a timeshare.. if you get one cheap and use it they have value to you and your family..

    if you try to buy one to resale, because the salesperson told you they will be worth more in the future, you will loose out..

    just check such places as tug2.net (clark recommended site) and redweek.com to see how much they are really selling for.. also on ebay you can find a lot of distress sales on good timeshare..

    heard a person today on dave ramsey show had bought a timeshare and put on credit card.. man that was dumb..
  • vacation club
    Clarke, tell me do you like of think that vacation clubs are a good investment/
  • Banks feed off of all taxpayers....
    I do not feel one bit sorry for the banks not getting paid for their credit card loans. The banks have been feeding off of taxpayers for decades. Everytime a bank is bailed out it is a handout by the government. Does the banks customers who are paying fees and taxes get to see one time of their tax donation to the scum bankers? I think you all know the answer.
  • Deadbeats
    The people who claim that credit card debt is due to medical bills are merely shilling for the left wing loons in our society.
    What happened was they did not pay their medical bills because they spent their money on other non essential things. Easting out etc.
    A deadbeat is a deadbeat. Period.
    Those who borrow anything at any time should always have a repayment plan that will repay the debt.
    Many people just take advantage of the system and moan and complain and cause the rest of us to have to pick up the tab. I say just jail the deadbeats.
  • debt collection
    Some credit card company called my wife the day after her payment was due, charged her a late fee, and was rude to boot. I told her just to not answer the phone, but she did not listen. This is why I have caller ID, to pick and choose the calls I accept. And if you call ME two or three times in one day you might get your feelings hurt.
    Just tell them to kick rocks! Life is too short to worry about the B.S.
  • CC companies
    Until you have walked in someone else's shoes dont pass judgement
  • Some of you have obviously never tried to deal with cc companies
    I have been trying, without success, to work out deals with my cc companies, who insist on an amount that I cannot afford and want access to my checking account. I am currently on unemployment and have enough to pay mortgage and utilities, but not much else. I never expected in my wildest dreams to be laid off from my job of 11 years, so please do not judge until you have been a similar situation.
  • Don't ignore your mail
    I work in a courthouse and see hundreds of people, who haven't paid their bills, having judgments entered against them, without even showing up in court. And before you call them deadbeat, know that a lot of their expenses are medical bills.
  • judgments
    when you have a judgment placed in error against you from the clerk of court and you have already contact the lawyer of the collector thats sue you and they wont accept the payments you can afford to pay them what else can you do.
  • don't borrow Give me a break!
    not all of us were overextended before these CC companies started raising rates, and actually many of us were paying off more than double the monthly payments before hand, but when they took rates to sometimes 25% higher!! it did put many in a terrible fix, particularly to those who had circumstances beyond their control for large emergencies

    so don't preach your "don't borrow" and "give me a break" to everyone in one blanket statement
  • Not ALL Deadbeats
    I just got off the phone with a client whose son has been diagnosed with a degenerative disease and has to be fed his meals, the father has been out of work for 6 months, and they have accumulated $56k in CC debt paying for treatments. Sometimes stuff just happens...don't over generalize. If you want to make a difference, find someone like this guy and give them some money.
  • don't borrow
    i have zero sympathy for people who borrow money with little to no valid plan to pay it back. I also have zero sympathy for banks or credit card companies loaning money to such deadbeats.
    the answer to "not pay higher interest rates or fees for those who are irresponsible" is to simply not borrow money.
    sure it takes disipline. If you have a home and mortgage, work to pay it down. If you can't pay cash for a car, buy a cheaper car. Use credit cards as convience cards by paying off the balances each month which means you have to be disiplined in your spending. Build a cash reserve for emergencies and seasonal type expenses.
    You say you can't? Then either stop whining or get a second, third or fourth job. give up the i-phone, leased car, and all the other fancy trappings. stay out of the malls. Need I go on?
  • Responsible consumers who have spent reasonably within their means should not have to fund the irresponsible actions and excesses of those who haven't. If you spent it, you should pay for it. Period.
  • Give me a break!
    With everyone angry over the lack of accountability in Washington, where is the anger over DEADBEATS in the private sector? Where is the anger in having to pay several points above and beyond on loans to make up for others who choose not to repay theirs? What has happened to personal responsibility, integrity, honesty and financial independence in this country? Why should every financial institution in America have to write off DEADBEATS who threaten to file for bankruptcy? Americans have become totally brain-dead when it comes to financial responsibility, and THAT makes ME angry.
  • 1099 income
    If you have negative net worth, you are insolvent. To the extent the debt relieved does not exceed your total level of insolvency, the 1099 debt relief is not taxable. See a qualified tax person for details. You will have to attach a statement to your tax return outlining your total level of insolvency, but that should not be difficult to do.
    Remember, you define your insolvency by the difference between the fair market value of all your assets minus all your debt. Don't forget houses and vehicles (and their debt) and student loans, all credit cards and any outstanding loans owed to anyone.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement