advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Sep 21, 2009 -- Nurse-in-a-box facilities get positive review in new study

Clark has been a longtime fan of nurse-in-a-box facilities. These facilities are typically located in pharmacies, discount stores or supermarkets, and they offer the services of a nurse practitioner who administers basic medical care.

Customers love these kinds of "store within a store" operations because they're open 7 days a week for extended hours. They also offer a cheaper alternative to the emergency room.

But what's the quality of care you actually receive at a nurse-in-a-box facility?

The September issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine published a study with the following surprising results:

"Overall costs of care for episodes initiated at retail clinics were substantially lower than those of matched episodes initiated at physician offices, urgent care centers and emergency departments. ($110 vs. $166, $156, and $570, respectively)"

And this conclusion statement:

"Retail clinics provide less costly treatment than physician offices or urgent care centers for 3 common illnesses, with no apparent adverse effect on quality of care or delivery of preventive care."

That last phrase -- "with no apparent adverse effect on quality of care or delivery of preventive care" -- says it all.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • Seeing a nurse practitioner is a great option. They typically provide a lot more education about wellness, illness, medication, and general health. My NP considers all aspects of our lives and how it affects our health.
  • Enough Already
    Let's just move to a single-payer system already so everyone can get quality care. Pretty soon we're going to have the "payday" version of health care centers in this country, or something like a "quick stop" convenience health care store at the corner or in a strip mall right next to liquor stores and pawn shops. Just sad. Richest country in the world, wealthy enough to fight meaningless wars and bailout the rich, yet we still have a flawed health care system that almost ranks as bad as our education system worldwide.
  • AMA? What's that?
    I'm pretty sure the AMA is out of touch with most doctors these days. They did some good work in the past, but those days appear to be over.

    I don't have anything against these clinics other than to say the obvious: Don't go to them for major issues. If you feel your medical situation is relatively simple and minor then don't waste your time and money in ER or the GP's office. If you feel it's more complicated, then go to a doctor or at least an NP/PA with direct physician supervision.
  • Why not in public schools
    I'd love to see these opened up in public schools to offer free health care to any child under 18. It would relieve a large burden from ER's, provide basic medical care to all kids in the US under 18, and provide a ton of jobs. Now that is healthcare reform!
  • Nurse in a box
    There are some bad doctors out there and the AMA should stand for the American Mofia Association.
    I'm seeing my NP tomorrow and she is very good.
    The guy who removes my moles ect. is a NP. Also very good.
    Unfortunately there is a lot of hype about doctors.
  • Nurse in a Box
    I was in a Walgreens shopping once and just stopped by the Nurse in a Box, just to see what they take care of, just minor stuff, which is good to take the load off emergency rooms.
  • NOT IN PORTLAND, OR
    Rite Aid tried it in Portland, Or. They payed so bad the turnover was too high.
    All are gone in Oregon
  • Nurse In a Box
    We have a NP that runs a small clinic in our town. I take my family to see her for everything. She listens, tests, and diagnoses better than ANY GP we've seen in a while. She will answer an after hours page within minutes with a kind and caring spirit. Look out GP's there's a new kid in town and she's doing it better than you!
  • Nurse in a box
    as long as they keep it american nurses we will be o.k. Unlike those urgent care centers that won't even hire nurses because they can't afford it. Instead they hire overseas unlicenced unregulated tech's ! You should always demand an american trained nurse Rn or LPN! Don't let anyone else TOUCH you!
  • NURSE IN A BOX
    My wife was out of town on business. Late in the evening she was not feeling too well and could think of no place to get help. After talking to her on the phone, she went to Walgreens to buy medication, only to find their version of a walk in clinic. After a brief discussion with the NP, she gave a sample, was diagnosed and received proper medication, all within 2 hrs. It was fast, VERY helpful and insurance covered all but $20 of the visit.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement