advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Aug 28, 2009 -- Modern clean diesels, hybrids offer great payback

People often wonder what the payback on fuel-efficient vehicles is like. A few years ago, it would have been hard to find a true payback. But that math has changed significantly. More often than not, a hybrid or diesel will save you -- even though you spend more upfront.

A new IntelliChoice report finds that the most economically efficient vehicle is a clean diesel -- the VW Jetta TDI. Over a 5-year cycle, it's more than $6,000 cheaper to own this than a gas engine -- even though the diesel costs $2,000 more upfront.

Other top vehicles include the GMC Sierra 1500 crew cab hybrid 2WD, the Prius and other vehicles like Chevy Silverado 1500 crew cab hybrid 2WD.

One that is an absolute bomb as a diesel and should be avoided is the Lexus LS 600 H. Over the first five years, you lose almost $25,000 vs. the gas engine version.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • gas saving
    there are several old cars that got good milage, the 1980,s vw rabbit pickup, diesel gets 50mpg and the 1980,s jetta diesel gets 40-50mpg, mine gets 48mpg. i had 2 sprints and a metro they get 40+mpg, my 1956 metropaliton roadster got over 40. if you want good milage, look at some of the older cars, they get better milage than the new hybreds!!
  • RTFA
    Obviously, the negative commenters are here to satisfy their opinion - and ignorance at the same time.

    Read the article Clark linked to in the piece. Read the results from people like J.D.Powers.

    Read something people. Stop listening to Fox Noise.
  • Empty words
    The article uses no proof to substantiate its author's opinion. It still does not make sense to buy an overpriced and unreliable VWs vs. other small gas-driven cars. Wishful thinking, that's what this is.
  • calculate total cost/total mile
    I get frustrated with these types of articles throwing around cost savings between car types. There are too many things to consider… initial cost of car, fuel cost and maintenance cost (oil, tires, and breaks…tune-ups.) All these things could be captured if the data was presented terms of total cost (all of the above) divided by total miles driven. (Cost/mile). For a fair comparison you could run the calculation at 25K, 50K, 75K…200K. Graph the total cost on the y-axis and the total miles on the x-axis. You will see in any case the more you drive the car the less expensive it gets on a cost/mile basis. In the process it will be clear to compare the difference car types and see which cars have the lowest cost/mile after the least amount of miles driven.
  • re: diesel hybrid
    Diesel hybrids are on the way.

    http://www.hybridcars.com/related-technologies/diesel-hybrid-dreams.html
  • diesel hybrid
    Ok, so why don't they make a diesel hybrid. It sounds like that combonation would give the best MPG. Also diesel used to be cheaper then gasoline but over the past years it's gotten higher priced. So who decided to price diesel higher then gasoline?

    Yeah, make a diesel\cooking oil hybrid. That is my solution to energy problem. It's your free no charge.
  • RE: VW Jetta TDI Owner
    Move to the south- we dont have snow here. My VW's are awesome and I have had no complaints!

    PS- I have been bragging about them for years and now people are actually listening!!
  • VW Jetta TDI Owner
    Ok I have been driving the VW Jetta TDI for the past 2.5 years and I have averaged 47 MPG as most of my driving is on the highway it does a great job for fuel economy but it absolutely sucks in the snow VW needs to redesign it so it has a larger undercarriage clearance, more power to pull you through snow, and a tow hook in the front if you get stuck.
  • more battery info
    http://consumerguideauto.howstuffworks.com/hybrid-batteries-none-the-worse-for-wear-cga.htm
  • Re: long term reliability
    The Prius has been around since 1997. There are a lot of SUVs on the road that have not been in production that long. But, you have a valid point you are making.

    We have been manufacturing nickel-metal hydride batteries since 1989. So, it isn't new tech by any stretch. It is also easier to recycle NiMH batteries since they don't contain cadmium (unlike NiCad batteries). They are very reliable - hence why Toyota uses them. Li-io batteries are a different technology but we have proven their usefulness in laptops and cell phones. It is new technology to build large li-ion batteries so that is something a bet evolutionary but not revolutionary in battery design.

    Yet, I think at least with Toyota they have proven track record. The Toyota Camry uses the same technology as the Prius. The Nissan Altima Hybrid licenses hybrid tech from Toyota. I can't comment on the Honda, Ford or Chevy technology but these electric systems are not all new and electric motors are very reliable. Even nuclear subs and air craft carriers uses electric turbines. They are very efficient.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Prius
  • long term reliability
    How do you know you will save? Some of these hybrids haven't been around that long.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement