advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Aug 27, 2009 -- Peer-to-peer lenders like Prosper make a comeback

Peer-to-peer lending is re-emerging in the marketplace after a rough patch. This is a great way for people to lend to each other online without bank interference.

Prosper.com was one of the earliest P2P lenders to gain traction. But they didn't initially screen their borrowers well enough and a lot of loans went bust as a result. Then the government stymied them briefly over a misunderstanding about securities.

But now Prosper is back in action with a relatively low default rate of 5% among borrowers, according to Barron's. This service and its competitors are now putting people through their paces to weed out the baddies. The company claims 850,000 members and just a little under $200 million in loans underwriting at this date.

Lending Club has a 3% default rate, meanwhile, and turns down 90% of potential borrowers in an effort to cull the herd and find the most credit worthy.

That, of course, begs the question: Who would anyone go the P2P route if you're credit worthy? Generally, you can get a better deal with a P2P lender vs. a bank. Yet it's roughly equivalent to the kind of deal you'd get at a credit union.

For you as a lender, P2P lending allows you to slice up your money to limit risk. So if you want to put $1,000 in the game, you lend $100 here, $200 there and on and on.

The returns you might get as a lender can be enticing. Prosper claims the average lender earns 7% on their money, net after expenses and charge-offs. But those who are really into this virtual underwriting boast that they can make a 12% return.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • lending Club
    So far so good with the Lending club. The key is to lend as little ($25) as possible to as many people as possible in case of any defaults.
  • See true data at Lendingstats.com or ericscc.com
    Obviously Howard did not try P2P lending himself. If he had, he would have seen that the quality of information about the borrowers is low and that the default rate is high. Simply screen people out by credit scores does not guarantee reliable borrowers. If you look at the top 20 lenders by money on ericss.com, you'll see that 17 out of 20 have LOST money and one out of the 20 only gained 0.39% ROI.
  • re: bankruptcy
    Prosper is the best setup out there with ease of use and screening the borrowers.

    As far as bankruptcy, you own the note. The loan is under your name not theirs. If they went bankrupt the servicing center would still disburse the funds. The service center is independent and a prosper or lending club bankruptcy would not affect them.

    And believe me...it'll be "sold" to another company before they go bankrupt.
  • um..... why does it have to be 7% why not 8% or something else gosh.....
  • bankrupcy
    what happens if Prosper or Lending Club go bankrupt? what happens to your money? if you don't know, read the prospectus! if you still decide to lend, don't cry foul if disaster strikes you. you have been forewarned.
  • If you only knew
    Annette,
    If you only knew what banks REALLY charge interest from, you would be far more upset.

    Do NOT do a google search for "Money as Debt" and watch the first link that appears. The video is called "Money as Debt".

    You'll look at your mortgage payment in an entirely new way!
  • the lenders and borrowers
    what do they say about " too good to be true" saying!!
  • Right!
    I have 13 loans on Prosper with 3 charge offs, but I lent at high enough rates to still earn over 12% which is what the risk calculator on Prosper told me I could expect. But residents in NC can no longer lend. WHY??
  • Social Lending
    I tried social lending and I don't know how they get a 3% default rate because 1/2 of the loans I made have been charged off. (Small amounts)
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement