advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Apr 09, 2009 -- Retired bank exec's strange tale of being an ID theft victim

The story of Margot Somerville is a true cautionary tale about identity theft. Clark originally read about this 64 year old's story in The San Francisco Chronicle and was floored by the unbelievable details.

Today, Somerville was a guest on the show and gave a firsthand account of what happened to her.

Before we begin, it's important to note that Somerville spent 25 years with Wells Fargo and retired as a vice president at the financial giant. Yet it was the very bank she was so loyal to that accused her of masterminding a check fraud scheme.

In June 2006, Somerville's wallet was stolen in San Francisco and she promptly filed a police report. She practically forgot about the whole episode until the following November. It was then that she went online to pay some bills and noticed $20,000 missing from her bank account.

After reporting the suspicious activity, she was asked by police to take a number of handwriting tests and lie detector tests over the course of several months. Much of the testing took place in Denver, where at least part of the missing money was withdrawn from her account by crooks.

But while Somerville thought she was helping police build a case and catch the criminals, they were really building evidence against her.

She still didn't have her money back 6 months after the initial $20,000 went missing.

Then in April 2007, Somerville was arrested at her Walnut Creek, Calif., home and spent the night in jail. She was charged with 19 counts of ID theft because Colorado authorities believed she was in fact an ID theft ringleader and not a victim.

The case was ultimately thrown out of court in November 2008. But Somerville says it was only dismissed because the police couldn't get enough evidence to pin it on her; they still believe to this day they had the right woman.

So what's the takeaway here for you? Somerville sees a twofold lesson.

First, always file a police report no matter how simple you think the crime may be. It always helps to have documentation.

The second lesson is a bit more surprising. Somerville told Clark that she learned the drawbacks of being too cooperative. Had she not been so willing when it came to taking multiple handwriting and lie detector tests, the police may have pursued another line of inquiry and none of this would have ever happened.

By the way, Somerville did eventually get her $20,000 back after much grief.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • What do you do if
    What do you do if there is an old and i mean 7-8 year old id theft issue where you reported it to all three major credit agencies had your credit frozen. But did not file a police report. Now a collection agency is coming back to collect. And they ignored clarke's drop dead letter? Now they want a copy of a police report or a notarized affidavit from FTC website.

    Going to send them the drop dead letter again. But what is my risk? Is it too late to get a police report?
  • Follow MEDICAL ID THEFT
    And by the way, my charges were eventually dismissed as well, but of course, we don't live in a country that says innocent until proven guilty and means it. I have been told repeatedly that you cant be in jail for a long time unless you are convicted. I am constantly having to prove to potential landlords etc that I am not lying, paying out of pocket for background checks etc. Wake Up America! Ignorance is a dangerous thing. Trust me. I learned the hard way.
  • Medical ID Theft
    I spent 9 months of 2008 incarcerated, accused of prescription fraud and drug trafficking because my roommates stole my insurance info and my pharmacy info and used it to byy narcotics. I had a clean record, and am so far removed the any criminal profile it is absolutely absurd.
    THIS HAS RUINED MY CREDIT, MY CREDIBILITY ETC. A NIGHTMARE!!! And not once during this investigation did it occur to anyone that this was ID theft. THe police were convinced I was in on this because the people who did it claim so, and because I lived with them so that means I knew what was going on.
    I believe my case is definitely indicative of a growing trend.
  • ID theft
    Article should be corrected to read "you CAN be TOO cooperative" Police often use the, we are just trying to get a few facts straight line as part of their investigation of YOU as possible perpetrator. Be very, very careful in police interview and by all means have an Attorney accompany you at ALL times.
  • Identity theft
    Check with your financial institution. almost all require a police report to be able to file a claim for loss.
  • It splashes on everyone
    Another example of why any contact with our so-called "Criminal Justice System" is a net loss for the average honest citizen in this country. Yes, the poor woman got her $20K back, but how much did she have to pay attorneys to rid herself of the grief inflicted by the police?
  • dont talk to cops
    Youtube "dont talk to cops". This lady was her own worst enemy. I have two lawyers in the family, they say the same thing, " you can never help yourself by talking to the police".
  • One MUST be proactive to avoid ID theft!
    I commiserate with this lady. This shouldn't happen to a DOG. More advice for the audience, if you didn't already cover it, Clark:

    * Be proactive! Freeze all three major credit reporting agencies to stop ID thieves cold. The small amount of inconvienence is worth the trouble, and I sleep pretty well at night knowing my profiles are frozen-solid.

    * Don't carry unneeded items in your wallet or purse, especially checkbooks, SS cards, medical cards, unneeded credit cards, etc. I knew a guy who's wallet was stolen and his fake VISA ended up being used 17 times in less than one hour to buy up $1300-worth of goodies, and the bank did nothing to compensate him. Thieves can easily write a check these days if they also have your ID, and sadly, most merchants don't even check for that anymore.

    * I disagree with Clark about summoning police. They don't differentiate between perp and victim. If you are proactive, you won't have to bother with police anyway. If you do decide to file a police report, keep in mind that YOU are also a suspect and anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law.

    * Consider doing away with paper checks altogether. Use Cash American Money or a credit card instead when you shop. Paper checks are a disaster waiting to happen. And leave ATM cards at home unless you plan to use it that day.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement