advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Feb 18, 2009 -- Obama announces his housing rescue plan

CLARKONOMICS: Pres. Obama announced his housing rescue plan today and Clark wants to give you an overview of it.

• People with mortgages that have become unaffordable would be allowed to file a petition to have their monthly payments reduced to roughly one-third of their household income. Essentially, they could be allowed to stay in their homes at a big discount -- a very controversial move.

• People who are current on their mortgages but could not qualify for a refinance because they lacked equity may have the chance to refi going forward through Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Look for a forthcoming briefing from Clark once more details about this part of the plan become available.

• In the most controversial move of all, Congress could pass a statute to give bankruptcy court judges the right to do cramdowns. Cramdowns are common in commercial real estate. In this scenario, they would be used to reduce the mortgage of someone who is upside down in their home to reflect the property's current market value.

All of these points obviously raise strong questions of moral hazard. Yet on the other hand, many economists believe that the nation's financial institutions will not stabilize until the housing market stabilizes.

Maybe that's true…but Clark thinks the real problem in housing is that we have too much of it! Supply and demand still have yet to meet up through natural population growth. Simple demographics must do the job of eventually soaking up the excess supply of houses.



Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

Add your comment

Security Image * Please enter the code shown at left
what's this?

What others are saying

  • what to do
    mother and father bought a house with cash, they owe 80,000 on their old home.
    they want to know what they can do to keep their new home from getting tagged.
  • Mortgage Bailout
    Come on Clark. I know you are a conservative but you of all people should be behind helping the homeowners, many who were swindled.
  • The Lord
    We'll pray for you.
  • Get the Lord back in focus? HaHaaa
    He left a long time ago and is not coming back.
  • Wall Street to blame as well!!!
    Mtg Brokers as well as banks kept lending under those ridiculous guidelines because Wall Street was willing to bundle and sell these mortgages. And the Wall St Brokers who sold this bundled money made a mint as the yields were incredibly high.

    Why were the yields so high?? Because the debtor had to refinance after the initial teaser rate wore off to a new teaser rate loan. Which ment more up front fees, points, etc which kept the yields very high.

    What a complete joke!!!! Those Wall St Brokers knew without a doubt this would not last but kept selling the packaged loans as good money. Complete Bulls****. They knew it and are as much if not more to blame than anyone else.

    Biker
  • Mortgage Bailout
    I did not vote for any of the senators nor did I vote for Obama. They, the spoiled and irresponsible people of this country, wanted "CHANGE", well... your getting it... In the shorts.
  • Lenders to blame....
    Why do people not understand the root source of this problem comes from the lenders? THEY knew they were making risky loans putting YOUR home value at risk. Why aren't people mad at the lenders? They gambled home values would keep going up and they bet YOUR home on it! OR mortgage brokers just made their commission or quick buck and bailed leaving us all with the clean up. I call it the strip mining of the middle class. The rich get richer....demonstrated by the bail out money given to lenders....jeez, could they BE more arrogant? We need to unite and hold the irresponsible LENDERS accountable for this mess. The fact they gambled your home value should be enough to make us really angry.
  • Bailing Out The Pigs
    What a pathetic state of affairs. The vast majority of these mortgage bailouts are those who should never have signed in the first place. Where's the accountability? Thanks to Obama and Congress, we'll never find it. I fear for my children.
  • housing excess
    Supply and demand will not meet up through natural population growth unless people are willing to have more than two kids. Unfortunately, the majority of the people who are having lots of kids are living in government housing and passing that lifestyle on to their kids.
  • Housing Rescue Plan
    Of course we have too many houses, but if we don't stop the bleeding we'll have a lot more.
  • Bailout
    As a retired realtor I know that a lot of my clients refinanced every year and pulled out thousands of dollars. If they are upside down now, they still came out ahead.
  • Bailout
    People like me who are fulfilling our obligations are paying for those who don't. My mortgage is current - I also drive a nine year old car and watch a twelve year old TV (when I have the time). I would love to buy a nice new boat but don't have the cash right now.

    Meanwhile, as a Realtor, I go to list short sales because the owners can't pay their mortgage. All the owners DO have brand new cars, 60" TV's, new boats, RV's and other toys.

    This plan, like all of his other plans, is bad news. Once again we reward failure and punish success, thereby increasing failure and ensuring no success.

    And President Obama wants me to foot the bill for this. BULL$#!T!
  • housing stimulus
    President Obama was talking about giving home buyers during a one-year period a $15,000 gift to stimulate the home buying process. What happened to that?
  • Housing Mkt
    I have a Question
    How does making a bank reduce the value of a mogtgage,reduce the payments, and reduce the intrest rate help the the banks and the over all economy?? As I see it it just makes the whole thing last longer. Get real.
  • Fantastic, punish the wise and reward the stupid
    Fantastic, I shopped for a house in 2007 and decided I couldn't afford it. So, I kept on renting my apartment.

    Now, people that also couldn't afford homes but were dumb enough to buy one with an adjustable rate mortgage that would, by it's very definition, jump to a much higher payment in 3 to 5 years are getting my tax dollars to pay for their bad decision.

    God forbid they have to move into an apartment and sell, at a loss, to someone that didn't make stupid decisions.

    To all of you that got an ARM that you knew you couldn't afford: GET OUT OF MY HOUSE!
  • Government help is nonsense!!
    Our government is the most useless entity in our entire county. I feel bad when someone loses their job and has to move, but you know what? That is life. If you can't afford your home then you should move. I will be laid off later this year, and will have to find another job to pay for my home. If for some reason I can't make enough money then I will move. Wake up people, have some pride in yourself and take care of yourself and your family. Stop looking to our inept government to pay your way. Boy, does our country need to get the Lord back as its focus instead of more and more fancy STUFF!!
  • This extends the bubble
    -This extends the real estate bubble.
    -People who say "I'll lose my house" are wrong: the BANK owns the house, not you.
    -Any government that is powerful enough to hand out money is powerful enough to seize it back.
  • Housing Rescue Plan
    My husband was laid off 8-08. His income 65,000. He's now getting 330 a wk
    unemployment benefits. We bought our home in 05 & put down 87K. We now owe
    approx 190k & not yet behind on payments
    because we maxed out credit cards to keep from falling behind. We are in our
    late 50's & adopted our 3 grandkids in
    07. I pray this plan can help our family from losing our home.
  • Reply to uconn
    Uconn I have sympathy for your situation and I do think that in certain situations people deserve help.But I do think that government intervention that helps a few now at the expense of us all later is a bad idea.People should hope for the best and always plan for the worst.Take your lumps,regroup and then come back.
  • Housing
    Clark, I saw you on CNN and I think you need to read the plan. I understand the plan refinancing a loan as follows: (1) lender brings down interest rate to 38% of income, (2) the plan will match dollar-for-dollar reduction in interest rate to 31% of income. However, it doesn't appear that you, or anyone on television, is adding this small "note" that immediately follows these two items in the plan: Note: Lenders can also bring down monthly payments to these affordability targets through reducing the amount of mortgage principal. The initiative will provide a partial share of the costs of this principal reduction...
  • reply to Mike in Oregon
    You comment is not valid. I lost my job after 28 years do to downsizing! I cannot meet my mortgage now with 1 income. My house still has equity dispite the current market. This bill will hopefully help me stay in my home. This is the first time I have been scared out of my mind. Unless you are in my situation, your comment is thoughtless and inconsiderate of us 'responsible individuals'.
  • Hmmm
    And you never questioned anything Bush did??????????????????? Pleeaaassse.

    Who put the final stamp on TARP 1 anyhow?? Where did that money go specifically?

    Both parties have an interest in keeping power. Sadly, your man and his party are no different.

    Biker
  • Biker's Comment
    Reading your post, I was quite envious. Kudos! I am currently unemployed, though I, too am a saver, and can last quite a while.

    What was disturbing is this statement:

    "I voted for Obama but I can't help but wonder if they should have taken more time to put the bailout package together."

    Stop wondering. It is "generational theft," to quote the person you should have voted for. In less than 4 years you have a chance to rectify the situation.

    Remember:

    Carter is to Reagan, as Obama is to ?
  • I say government should not intervene.People say that the foreclosures are effecting there home values and that is why we need to bailout the houses.If we let the market take care of itself the prices of the foreclosed houses will drop and people will buy them and this will correct itself without the need for the responsible to bailout the irresponsible.
  • Gov't should stay out!!!
    As someone who didnt pull the trigger from 1998-2003 when housing was lower and then wisely stayed out during the great corrupt/greed-filled/fraudulent housing & mortgage bubble I strongly resent the gov't getting involved in any way and not letting the market reset itself.

    This market is WAY TOO HIGH and helping out the morons who helped drive up is only going to prolong the market from bottoming out and keep qualified buyers like myself out of the market even longer.

    In addition, I also had people telling me how the market was never going to stop going up. I laughed in their faces and told them go look at a chart. It always go up and down. Little did I know what was in store but its going down now. hehehe

    Now, Ive saved my money for years and years and while I live in an expensive area I will suffer again when Im required to put 20% down and not get the sweet deal given to all the morons who never shouldve gotten a mortgage in the 1st place.

    This isnt the function of gov't. We have many corrupt and clueless politicians spending money like crazy and its something that shouldnt even be within their powers.
  • Rescue plan
    Well, let me start by saying I'm in the 90% crowd. I bought back in 1991. Bought a nice home in a nice area but much less than I qualified for. Refinanced once to change the rate from 9% to 4.75%. Took no money out & took a 15 yr loan.

    I'm now in the 200K+ per yr income. I live w/in my means. Yes, my home is well maintained, very nice but I made sure I live w/in my means. Drive a Ford Focus, etc, etc.

    I own several rental properties that I paid extra on the loans and paid them off. I also have a 401K.

    I did my best to make good financial decisions. Have I lost a lot of money in equities in the properties I own. You bet, probably more than 500K in equities. Did I lose my butt in my 401K. Yep, 50% down, at last check!! Maybe more now and I'm not happy about it but it is what it is.

    I'm trying to figure out why I need to help others who didn't handle their finances the proper way. Why am I now asked to help someone who refinanced, took money out and purchased a 50k auto. And don't tell me people didn't do this. This was the NORM!!

    I'm not sure what the solution is as I'm not an economist nor do I even have a College degree. I just don't understand how those of us who lived w/in our means are now required to help those who didn't. And I can't help but think there is something else we're not being told when someone who has paid 22 years on a mtg will now possibly lose their home. Are you sure you didn't take any money out??? Your loan balance should be much lower now and you should be paying mostly principle!!

    You think there is any money in that bailout plan for the 500K in equities I lost and the 50% decrease in my 401K??

    I voted for Obama but I can't help but wonder if they should have taken more time to put the bailout package together.

    Biker
  • Rescue Plan
    Clark,

    You really went out on a limb with that analysis.

    Sorry for the sarcasm, but you didn't tell us if it will fail or work. Good reporting, terrible analysis.
  • Bailout
    I am sick to death of people getting a free ride. The market place should be allowed to correct itself. Americans need to learn to save for what they want and not charge items just because they can. What kind of message is this sending to our children? I have been living below my means for years and have always saved money because no one knows what lies ahead. This should be a wake up call for irresponsible people, but instead it's taxpayers money to the rescue . What wrong with people living in apartments until they can get back on their feet?
  • I agree
    What poor are you rewarding? Those that homes that have now foreclosed and caused your property value and mine go go down. This occurred due to greed by a lot of folks..it's garbage to blame the poor since these folks have been taken advantage of to the point that's offensive and sickening.This trash of helping the poor has been spouted by Talk Show Host for months,but what about those bankers, and mortgage companies that plundered the system through scams legalized cons,and lies,I think you're angry at the wrong folks. - END QUOTE

    Totally agree. I earn less than $50k a year and when I bought my first house in 2000, (I had an 800+ FICO score). They qualified me for a loan of around $345K --- WHAT??? I said NO WAY and bought a house for $160K. No, it is not my dream house but things have changed and I have a BRAIN and didn't choose to live beyond my means. That's COMMON SENSE PEOPLE! I shouldn't have to bail anyone else.

    We are the people that need a break, but we won't get one. Watch and see who will pay for our TARP et al.
  • Renters
    My wife and I have been renting the last five years because we couldn't afford a mortgage. People at my work gave me a hard time for not jumping into the housing market like they did. "Real estate only increases in value." Now we still can't afford a house and yet I will be helping other people pay their mortgages with B.O.'s housing rescue plan.
  • Grand children
    It is not us that will pay for the bad decisions of today in the morgage market. It will be our grandchildren. They will learn about it first in history class. Then they will spend their life fixing this nightmare called "The Spending Package". It sure is upsetting to be a responsible american.
  • Clark's right
    He is oh so right - its the SUPPLY - there shouldn't be a new house built in this country for a LONG time - there should be disincentives for builders
  • To: Gary Ohio @ 02/19/09 06:58:15 PM -- I still haven't read anything in your post as to why I should be responsible for your mortgage.

    You are 22yrs into a 30yr mortgage? Whatever the 'issue' is, since it is 'no fault of your own' why can't you work it out with the bank or sell the home and move into something you can afford?

    Again, why are you my financial responsibility? Do you want to pay for me or the guy on the other side of the country?
  • This is crazy
    I just came through the worst patch of road in my entire life. I was laid off from a very good job at the end of 2007. I had just moved into a new home that was 2X the cost of my previous. I had a traditional loan that was competitive. I still have my home after being without work for over a year now. I have just started a new job at almost half my old salary and am still able to pay my mortgage. How did I get through this?
    1. We did not buy a home that was outside of our ability to pay, like these people who are now in trouble.
    2. We did not buy or lease a new car to pretend like we had money like I am sure many of these people did.
    3. I called upon every resource I had to honor my debts while still being out of work even though I was upside down on my house just like these people.
    4. I went through all of my savings from over 10 years of playing it safe. I am still here. Battered and bruised, but not a self entitled ingrate like these people.
    5. I hold myself responsible for my debts and my situation. Why can't YOU?

    After all this, you are telling me that I should have saved my 401k and my savings and let the bank take the hit so that my life would have been easier while placing a burden on society?

    This is what is wrong with this county. Take some responsibility people!!
  • Batten Down the Hatches
    Well, it looks to me like the American people are getting exactly what they deserve "CHANGE". We've gotten change all right and a president who spends more time making speeches and traveling all over the U.S. rather than taking care of business in D.C.

    How much do you suppose all those trips are costing taxpayers? Has anyone counted the number of times he has flown out of D.C. within the last 4 weeks? (Heaven help us, it has ONLY been four weeks!!!!)

    As for me, I am seriously thinking about retiring two years early from my teaching job. Fortunately, I have always been tighter than bark on a tree with money (tighter than Clark, even).
    Sooooooo, I figure if I go ahead and retire that will be A LOT LESS IN TAXES I HAVE TO PAY!!! Since taxpayers are getting robbed anyway, why give them more of my hard earned pension?????

    Or, I could refuse to pay taxes at ALL, like so many of the presidents "friends", and see if I could become Secretary of Treasury as a second career.
  • RE:still don't get the whole 'underwater' reasoning.
    Too many people have looked at houses as an investment more so than shelter, that is why they are walking away. They must feel it is the right decision from a business standpoint. Business owners do it all the time and use the bankruptcy code as protection.
  • Obama's housing plan
    For some of you that can afford your mortgages I'm happy. But just think if you find yourself in a situation to where you can't afford your mortgage. The stimulus package/mortgage plan is not a Republican plan. It is a Democratic plan for all to save our country. Even though people find themselves in an upside down mortgage it does not mean that they did this just to be homeless. When you have Philadelphia lenders (as in Philadelphia lawyers) that got us in this mess it takes a good Illinois senator to get us out. We have been in our mortgage 22 years while the bank and ceo's have profitted from all our interest. Now we are possibly facing foreclosure thru no fault of our own. We as Americans need to pull together because if we don't we will be worse off than the 1930's depression. Moral of the story is don't count your chickens before they hatch because you may find yourself in the same situation as millions of other people, due to no fault of their own.
  • I still don't get the whole 'underwater' reasoning.

    I keep hearing people underwater are just walking away from their mortgage, why?

    If you take a mortgage for 300K, and your payment is 2K/month. 5yrs later your house is only worth 275K, your payment is still 2K a month, so why is it okay to walk away?

    If the same home was worth 325K 5yrs later, people wouldn't be walking away, but the monthly payment is still the same.

    I don't understand this reasoning.
  • To: Gee @ 02/18/09 06:18:11 PM -- what 'evil' mortgage bank forced anyone to sign anything?

    To: Lera @ 02/18/09 10:53:36 -- why is this my responsibility? I didn't sign up with XYZ bank for a 10K HELOC/loan (whatever it was) with ARM, you did, you deal with it. I have my own mortgage to pay, why am I being forced to be responsible for yours???????????

    To everyone who wants bailed out by the govt -- the 'payers' fuse is only so long, there is going to come a tipping point where the responsible just stop, in spite of their own fate, I don't know what that breaking point is, but it will come.
  • who is to blame???
    I will tell you since I have an insight in this industry..back in 2007 to early 2008 one particular bank was doing loans most lenders could not and would not touch. Credit scores as low as 520 with NO PMI and interests rates in the low 5's. Real Estate Agents and builders were pushing buyers on this bank (big bank-three letters) because they could get ANYONE approved.
    ...and guess what, they started foreclosing because they had no regard for their credit even in the beginning..doing these risky loans with borrowers who had bad credit was just a way to make their production look larger and show "profit" so their CEO's could receive enormous bonuses.
    I am fed up with the way the industry has gone and this bank was doing something they knew was not right...how can you give a loan to someone who couldn't pay their cable bill? does it take a brain surgeon to figure that one out?
    Now, look where we are. The job market is so bad that even those that took care of their credit, paid their bills on time and saved 6 months payments can't keep their home because they lost their job.
    Until the housing market improves, nothing will change...not even $700+ BILLION!!!! Question is, how do you really fix it...hint let the bank with the initialls (that also spell a SNAKE!)fall flat on their face!!
  • Housing plan
    It is time for everyone to stop for a minute and think about what our big egos make us do just because we are
    Americans, and we deserve anything we want, even when later on we are in deep
    problem. We need to be more responsible
    and put the feet on the ground and not to take things for granted (Because I am America?). The problem makers have to pay for it, the other have to look for ways to HELP and not to start running or crying like babies.
  • Rife with Hazards
    So basically we are going to let the mortgage brokers who got us into this mess handle the so-called solution? I cna't wait to see what new fraudulent schemes they come up with!
  • "Upside down" mortgages
    Just because your home is worth less than its purchase price is no reason to walk away. Anyone who has financed a new car knows that they are upside down for a while. If you are upside down on your home it just means it will take a bit longer to have equity. I'm sick of the crybabies who are so morally bankrupt that they would walk away from their home for this reason. Your bad purchase decision is no reason to make the rest of us clean up your mess.
  • rescue plan
    I am in the 90 % that can afford my mortgage. What is in it for me. A few extra $ in my pocket. Not even enough to buy a pizza!!!!!!!!! I did not vote for HIM!!!!!!!!!!
  • Housing Plan
    People, if you bought a house and now you not afford the monthly payments, maybe you should not have bought it in the first place. Why should I (taxpayer) help you pay for something you cannot afford? Why should I bail you out for your bad investment in real estate? Are you willing to bail me out of my bad investment in buying Bank of America common stock? I doubt it.

    Maybe we should all stop paying for our mortgages, and see what Obama will do then.
  • mortgages
    My adj. mortgage maxed out last Nov. now I can't affort it because I've lost my job, I'm 65 and will be going on SS soon..my wife is 63 and is lower middle income.
    My mtge company finally, argeed to modification..( I had to deliberately ( almost ) get late on my payments. They began working and indicated that I would get a five year adj. with 4 3/4 % interest..pay. from 1285. monthly, to 810.00 decision to be made 2/18/09..rec'd by mail, an offer of 6.4% 30 year, 965.00 monthly...decision to be made 2/28/09..and at the same time, refusing to give me the original deal..I asked for something in between..say 5.75% for 30 years..about $850.00 monthly...they indicated that the orginal offer now was not on the table anymore..and nothing is negotiable anymore...take it or leave it...the people I'm dealing with are all in India...can't get anyone from this country to deal with..always a different person when I can get through to anyone..I have lost all confidence in this company but its to late to change..
  • RE: Housing Plan
    Sir, i kindly disagree with your statement. I am of the belief that the homeowner ultimately can say no...and this is what they should have done. I think we all have been in situations with the scum of the mortgage business, but realized what was a good deal and what was not..
  • Honesty does not pay
    The sad reality of this mess is that if you bought a home within your means and saved money to survive for 6-9 months like adults should you will get nothing ouyt of the deal but higher taxes. The higher taxes will be used to pay for the mistakes of the non-responsible adult homeowner. I think it is extremely unfair. What you do for 1 you do for all.....
  • Scam
    I foresee a new scam on the horizon with appraisals being low-balled to give the bailed out homeowner’s mortgage reset at a lower market value. I still want to know who gets the profit if the house value goes back up.
  • What lender would want to lend money when a judge could modify the mortgage contract? I'm willing to bet if this goes through you won't be able to get a mortgage in markets where house prices are falling.
  • the next bubble will be
    First came the dot.com bubble, then the housing bubble, next will be the government misspending bubble when the ignorant officials try to borrow their way out of debt and spend more money on their "wastetulus" project than anyone can ever reasonably pay back. The result will be stagflation all over again- but this time its gonna stay a while!
  • What I heard was that payments would be (re)set to equate to `1/3rd of income. That can be done (to an extent - by manipulating the interest rate and term) without necessarily having to adjust the principal. If the principal balance is lowered, ideally whoever is taking the hit (i.e. the gov't or lender) should benefit before the bailed-out homeowner. However, it's important to keep the homeowner in the game (give incentive to not walk-away from a bad loan). At the very least, the amount of the principal adjustment should create a reduction in basis and a tax event at sale (& not an exempted, tax deferred or long-term capital gain as are normally permissible - primary residence).

    Someones' a little sensitive. There was no mention of rewarding the poor. They wrote about "poor behavior".
  • Obama's New Housing Plan
    Finally I feel like someone is really making a difference. We bought our home 6 years ago with 20% down at 6.5% interest with a reasonable price tag. I thought I was doing everything right. Our mortgage got sold to a sub prime lender right after I refinanced and took out 10k in equity with an adjustable rate that begins adjusting April 1st. I've never been late but my husband lost his job and got another but at a much, much lower salary. We can't refi because we are upside down, can't modify because we aren't late. I really feel like Obama is really looking at making sure people in my situation are not over looked and are saved from the heartaches that thousands have been through.
  • Future Equity
    If the principal is set lower to the current market value, who gets the benefit of the increased equity if the house escalates in price? It should be the government (U.S. tax payer), not the bailed-out property owner.
  • Housing Plan
    What poor are you rewarding? Those that homes that have now foreclosed and caused your property value and mine go go down. This occurred due to greed by a lot of folks..it's garbage to blame the poor since these folks have been taken advantage of to the point that's offensive and sickening.This trash of helping the poor has been spouted by Talk Show Host for months,but what about those bankers, and mortgqage companies that plundered the system through scams legalized cons,and lies,I think you're angry at the wrong folks.
  • Obama housing plan
    Why are we rewarding poor behavior? I put 20% down on my house, by saving for years.Where's the benefit for the 90% of homeowners making their mortgage payments?
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement