advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Jan 09, 2009 -- Save up to $600 annually by dropping landline, going cell only

Looking for an easy way to reduce your monthly budget in 2009? Consider dropping your landline and going cell phone only. About 1 in 5 Americans have disconnected their home phone, while an additional 13% say they have a home phone that they never use. That's about one-third of all Americans who are cell phone only or very near to it.

Whenever Clark discusses this issue, he hears from those people who say, "Well, what do I do after a natural disaster when my cell phone doesn't work?"

The consumer champion recalls doing medievac work down in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. There were no working cell phones. However, the cable operator was still working. Vonage saved the day for many people who would have been otherwise cut off. Today, many emergency personnel even have satellite phones in the event of an emergency.

Can you go cell phone only -- with a VoIP service like Skype as a backup -- and get rid of your home phone?

Another common objection to dropping the landline is that people say they need it for their burglar alarm system. But professional burglars will simply cut the phone line before going in. That's why security consultants routinely recommend wireless monitoring instead.

Remember, the typical local phone bill is between $30 and $50 each month. That could be $360 or $600 back in your pocket annually if you make the jump.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • Consumers deserve the option to choose a landline
    I wholeheartedly support maintaining a landline for all residential homes. Unfortunately, it is a losing battle in Florida and the legislature is not on the side of consumers. I see it as a safety issue. Apparently, the legislature and governor view it as an issue to be decided by the telecommunications industry. For another take on this, visit http://www.tboblogs.com/index.php/thinkoutloud/comments/no-dial-tone/ and http://www.telecompetitor.com/att-stresses-need-for-wireline-home-phone/
  • repair my majickjack
    my majickjack doesn't work it just write broken stokage Idon't know what to do help me please
  • Cell Phone charging when power is out.
    If you need to charge your cell phone when power is out, you have several choices:a power converter in your car,a backup power batter, or a quick visit to a friend that has power (call ahead before your cell phone dies).
  • Alarm Systems
    If you live in a moderate size community, using a cellular device in an alarm system as the only means of communication with a monitoring service is fairly reliable. Service drops are rare and usually only last for seconds when they do occur. As an extra precaution, have an exterior horn and strobe light installed, preferably at least 12 feet above ground level. Bad guys don't want all the attention.
  • considering going landline free
    i am considering go landline free and keeping att for the dsl and keeping my cingular cell through att does and know about the service through att w/dsl and cell service though att happy or not?
  • Ooma
    I highly recommend Ooma!! I tried Vonage and Majic jack. I haven't tried Vonage, but I did use magic jack and the call quality on Ooma is MUCH better. It may or may not work with faxes, depending on your internet connection speed and quality but I think they are working on a solution for that. Ooma has 911 service and they may be able to transfer your existing land line phone number to the Ooma service depending on which phone company you use. I opted not to pay for their premium service, the basic free service does all I need and includes caller ID and voice mail.
  • Boost Mobile
    Just switched to Boost Mobile Unlimited two weeks ago and am, so far, very happy with the service. So much so that I added a line for my wife also. Am now looking to get the bare minimum service from my land line provider (AT&T) or drop it altogether if I can't get a reasonable rate. I also have Magicjack as a backup. so I probably won't need a land line for long. Just fed up with monopolies. Going to all free TV is next. Satalite and cable can go fly a kite.
  • landline
    my telephone Co. is Windstream. I'm currently paying $70 a month for DSL & land line service. I'd like to change telephone providers, & switch to Vonage, but Windstream won't let Vonage let me keep the # we've had for 22 yrs. also, they won't let me keep the DSL w/o keeping a land line, which I believe is totally unscrupulous. How does one deal with the audacity of the former Ma Bells?"
  • Dock-N-Talk
    Has any one used this device and can speak to it's quality. My wife and I are considering dropping our landline and using cell only but only if we can dock our cells and "use" them on our home phones.

    Thanks
  • fax machines
    i use my fax occasionally and want to know if i drop my landline, can i use the fax though magicjack or another voip?
  • Landline...dont miss it!
    I got rid of my landline almost 3 years ago! It was a little uncomfortable doing so, but it was psychological. I live in a rural area with no cable or dsl, and use www.hughes.net as my ISP. They provide 2-way satellite interenet access. It's a little expensive up front for the equipment, but well worth it.

    Also recommend that you program the local emerg/fire numbers into your cell phone.
  • Skype vs Vonage
    I totally agree with the people who have said that MagicJack is terrible. After my bad experience with it I did a lot of research on VoIP services. This was the best article on the subject I read . . .

    http://tech.spotcoolstuff.com/internet-telephone/magicjack-skype-vonage

    . . . and after that decided to go with Skype and a beefed up cell plan. Hope that helps.
  • Landline vs. Cell
    I was cell only for 1.5 years and switched back to landline to save money. Monthly bill cellphone only was $126. This is AT&T 700 mins call pack with 4 phones on it. Monthly bill with Verizon landline is $60 plus including long distance and $22 a month for tracfones to be used on a limited basis. I liked the convenience of the cell phones but save more with my new setup. Hooking those lines up to my dish receivers took $10 more bucks off that monthly bill as well. One benefit is now the tv shows us who's calling which I think is pretty convenient
  • ooma
    I've had the ooma system for a couple of weeks now and have been really happy with the service. I run ooma with BellSouth FastAccess DSL and the call quality is great! I haven't tried Vonage or other voip offerings, but I really recommend ooma to anyone who is looking to ditch their landline. I got mine for $209.99, but have since seen it priced lower.
  • internet and phone service
    You cannot use a traditional fax machine with voip phone service. Also, MagicJack did not work at all with my Mac using the Tiger OS X operating system.
  • INTERNET AND CABLE SERVICE
    HOW DO I GET INTERNET AND FAX SERVICE IF I DROP MY LANDLINE? THANK YOU,
    SANDY CARROLL
  • No Naked DSL Available
    I keep trying to determine how to dump the landline. Cable Internet provides no cost savings (and I don't need the temptation of worthless cable TV sucking up my time). AT&T states DSL is not available in my area -- though my neighbors and I have had it for 5 years. They want us to buy U-Verse -- which has no Naked DSL so it costs more than cable would. I'm ready to try a wireless broadland service, but the costs are still too high. Uuugghhh.
  • ooma
    I just dropped Comcast Digital Voice for ooma. NO MORE PHONE BILLS. Although, the equipment costs around $229.
    It works with my alarm system. It has E-911 support. It works with DirecTV. I can send faxes and it has advanced features that no one else currently offer. But to get all of ooma's features you have to subscribe to the premium service for $99/year.
    The only risk is that they stay in business.
    It has worked flawlessly for nearly 2 weeks with perfect voice quality. I highly recommend ooma.com
    Enjoy!
  • To Dropping landline:
    You said, "Without a landline, I wouldn't be able to provide this comment on my computer because I rely on DSL, which requires a landline service."

    Ask your phone company about NAKED DSL. If you are with ATT they have to offer it you as a condition of one of their mergers.
  • Dropping landline
    Without a landline, I wouldn't be able to provide this comment on my computer because I rely on DSL, which requires a landline service. No cable TV, either, so no broadband. I'll keep my landline and make the best of it.
  • Landline pros n cons
    I have a landline cause of my alarm system and satellite reciever. I can wirless alarm backup, but its not 100% realiable and I have to spend around $1,000 to get installed + monthly fee for it on top of regular monitoring. I don't have $1,000 upfront to pay for the wireless monitoring system. Sure after 40 months of not having a landline I can pay for it. But what do I do about alarm protection in the meantime? My insurance co. raises my rates once i drop my alarm sys.
  • Our landline is a necessary evil
    Unfortunately, we are in a dead cell phone area.... no one can "hear us now" and there is no cable only DSL in our vicinity which is why we are stuck with a landline at a loss of that $600 per year savings!
  • We are stuck with Landline
    Everyone forgets those of us who are stuck with landlines for dialup service because there is no cable or DSL out in the sticks where we live. Wireless I've tried is slower then a landline.
  • Magic Jack
    I have tried Magic Jack twice with terrible results. I have high speed internet and canno imagine what the problem is. Very bad customer service. I sent the first one back but decided to keep the second one.
  • Cell phone quality
    I don't know what service y'all are using, but I have Verizon, and have no call quality issues, granted, we live in Marietta,(Atlanta suburb) but the service is great!, I still have landline, but I'm going to ditch it,as my burglar alarm has wireless backup! Just need to figure out how to do faxes!
  • Cell Phones
    Problems w/ having cell only:
    You lose it
    It's stolen
    Breaks
    Battery dies
    Need it in a hurry but can't find it right away.
    Cell towers go down
    toll free #'s, calling from home still take up minutes on cell (unless of course you have unlimited talk time ..but that's a lot more expensive)

    Advice: Retain bare-bones service, and I mean bare bones. No caller id, forwarding, etc. etc.long distance packages, etc. AM paying around $24 / month total.
  • Cell Phones
    Cell phones do not always work outside of big cities - my friends who have them are always complaining when they don't have enough bars to place a call. Land lines almost always work.
  • Landline + cell + VOIP for $21 a month?
    I'm paying $21 a month for land line, VOIP and cell phone service:
    land line: Qwest measured service ($16/mo)
    VOIP: Magic Jack ($1.67/mo)
    cell: Page Plus prepaid ($3.33/mo)

    Incoming calls on the land line are free; we use the Magic Jack for outgoing calls. Also, we live near a state border, and calls to/from the other state are toll calls. My Magic Jack number is local in the other state and forwards incoming calls to my land line. Now, friends and relatives across the border can call us for free.
  • RE: No working cell phones
    I believe I read something where the State of Florida is in the process of putting generators at cell phone towers to keep cell phones working after a disaster such as a hurricane.
  • Land lines.
    I live in FL. Cell phones need towers to send a signal. With my land line I had no problems. Remember 9/11? Cell phones went down
  • Can someone answer my 'landline' question
    I have Directv and Fast access DSL. I pay $79.00/month with AT/T. Can I get rid of my landline and still use Directv services? I am aware of being able to have Dsl by itself. Also, without a landline I'll need to up my minutes with T-mobile. Taking all that into account, will I still be saving money? It's the bundeled savings that I'm not sure about...any comments or suggestions?
  • Cell Service
    Do all companies offer VoIP with Skype backup.
    Thanks, Ralph (ralphwimberly@yahoo.com)
  • Burglar Alarm Systems
    Most burglar alarm systems depend on landline to notify local police department if there is an intrusion. Any suggestions? Otherwise I'm stuck
  • Who needs a landline? Answer
    I also live in Central Florida and relied on my road runner and cable from Bright House for FIVE years. All you need is one period such as we had where we were without service for 10 days to realize that a land line still has value. Yes, Bright House came fairly quickly considering it was a weekend, but they could not fix the problem and said they had to get a specialist in. The specialist came and said the problem was not in our system but farther out on the grid. Altogether it took 10 days to find the problem and fix it. In my 50+ years of having telephone service, I've never been without a phone that long.
  • Drop land line
    Way not so. I have a cell phone. Though reception in my area has improved in the past two years, I would hardly trust all my calls to it. I have to walk around outside to get a reasonably clear line. Worse, for five years I've had a cable phone. It seemed like a good alternative to the land line. It dialed 911 OK. It came with unlimited long distance. However, whenever the power went out, so did the cable service and hence the phone. And power outages are common in Central Florida. When there was a lightening strike in our area, it took 10 days for us to get phone service again. That was the longest we'd been without service, and unfortunately it came at a time when my husband, who teaches online, had to submit grades. We had to take the laptop to a coffee shop for him to get his grades in on time. In order to have phone service and be able to call 911 should I need to do so, I got a land line again. They installed it the next day, so now I have both a cable line (which eventually came back on) and the land line. I am not happy about it since the land line costs more than the cable phone even without the long distance option (I can do that mostly on my cell phoe), but I will not trust the safety of my house to anything but a land line for the forseeable future.
  • Magic Jack
    I use Magic Jack. I costs $19.99 a year with unlimited local and long distance. I do have sometimes severe problems with the quality. I believe it is because I have 2.4 Mghz phones and they need to be 5.8 Mghz and above. T-Mobile also offers a plan for $10.00 per month and they say theirs will not work with 2.4 Mghz. They suggest 5.8 and above.

    Regarding the fax, if you use Magic Jack, you might be able to plug in your fax to the Magic Jack adapter when you are needing to use the fax. If you use your fax all the time, I would even suggest purchasing 2 separate lines on 2 separate computers so one could be dedicated to the fax. At $19.99 per year, that isn't bad.

    I know I save over $400 per year using Magic Jack.
  • Would like to drop L.L.
    I live in Wisc. and have Verizon phone and dsl. It has to be through them. We pay about $40 a month for dsl. Think thats too high. We just need dsl and no land line. Can anyone tell me how I can do just that? Everything has to go through Verizon now.
  • dropping land line but keep internet
    It is possible to drop your landline, but keep your internet service if you have roadrunner or DSL through the cable company. The only time that you need the phone line is if you are using dial up internet. I get the lowest cable package and lowest roadrunner package for combined total of $35.00 a month.
  • phone land line
    i tried this, but i needed my fax machine too? any ideas..
  • Emergency cell phone charging
    "I would like to know what one does when the power is out and you can't charge your phone for days?"

    Turn on the car (outside of the garage!) and use that as a power source or buy a hand crank charger. We have hand crank radio, flashlight and cell phone chargers in our emergency kit.
  • drop the landline
    We have done this we pay $30 a year for unlimited US and Canada. We talk almost every day to people in Canada and Korea. For Free.We use the voicemail and call out features of Skype to stretch our cell phone minutes. We do not miss our landline at all.
  • I love land lines
    I'm no luddite, but still I have to say cell phones are only good for calls less than 1 minute when you're not at home. The quality stinks with all of them. Whatever happened to quality like advertised in Sprint's old "Pin Drop" commercials? I love my landlines with a good quality cordless attached. And I switched to pay by the minute from Virgin Wireless for those "I'm here, where are you" calls to my wife.
  • Cell Phones Verses Land Line Phones
    I would like to know what one does when the power is out and you can't charge your phone for days? I would very much like to drop my landline but right now I am in a contract for another year. What do you suggest?
  • land line
    i am sorry but clark is misleading a lot of people about the land line. as cell companies charge you for so many different items that land line doesn't. i have several friends who have lost thier phone so have no way of communicate for some time plus then the cell company charges for a new phone. also if you order something and asked to to be notified and if they do and you are out of minutes you get charged for the call. and previous person is right thier is a lot of proof now about cell phones causing cancer and other health risk plus thier are so many accidents because of people on phone so are paying higher insurance/ plus people are so incondierat with the cell they have kept waiting line a lot times while the finish thier call.
  • clarity of voice on cell phones
    Is there something that can be done to reduce the amount of distortion that occurs with some cell phones and certain voices? I wear hearing aids which help me a lot, but I save most of my phone calls especially to certain people, until I can get home to a more clear and natural sounding phone.
  • Long term safety of cell phones?
    This is in response to Dawn's comment about cell phone safety. Cell phone's have been around for over 20 years and there hasn't been a single problem reported. I think it's safe to say they're safe.
  • Who needs a landline?
    I haven't had a landline in over 4 years and haven't missed it a bit. Before I dropped my landline I had a $35/mo local bill and usually about $10 in long distance charges. By the way, I live in central Florida and was here for the Cat. 3 Charlie storm. We were without power for nearly a week but I never had a problem with cell phone reception--but I did have to use the car charger.

    Let's see, $45 x 12 months in a year x 4.5 years = $2,430. Yeah, I think I made the right call. Especially when you think about the cell phone, I would've had to pay that bill anyway. It's 100% found money.
  • Dropping Land Line Concerns...
    Dawn, cordless phones emit just as much RF as cell phones, often in the same general frequency range. So if you're scared of tumors, ditch the cordless and go back to the old corded phone!

    Any digital cell phone is safer and more secure than even the best cordless phones, so I would rather people call their banks over a cell than a cordless phone.

    I'm hesitant to drop a landline because of the burglar alarm (wireless monitoring is extra $$$) and also we have satellite, with three boxes. Although they haven't "dialed home" in ages, if they do and there's no phone the TV service will get cut off. I know from experience, it's a game of chance.

    If I could be assured the cable co's phone thing would work with the satellite boxes, I'd drop the landline and get cable internet and phone only.

    And no, I won't give up satellite, I'm addicted to those 70+ HD channels!
  • Safety of long time use of cell phone
    My only concern is that the verdict is still out about the safety of long time use of cell phones. Saving $30/month to "possible" ill effects of cell use I think should be seriously weighed.
  • dropping land line
    how safe is a cell phone when u are doing bankin or other sensitive transactions over the air. can someone with a listening device outside your home get
    this sensitive info. my bank advises even if u use a
    cordless phone some one using a baby monitor with 2.5 mgz can here your sensitive info. would
    like to know if you conversations over the air is
    secure.
  • Getting rid of home phone
    What alternative does one have when their land line phone is the only method of receiving Internet Service?
  • ATT Landline vs cell
    Just called ATT with my concerns of wanting to lower my bill and/or remove land line. They lowered my bill by $24 while leaving land line with all my perks like voice mail & long distance, plus DSL (they increased my speed for free), & I keep my cell. This will at least save $240/yr.
  • Land line, I'm keeping it
    My land line runs me $15 a month on average. I also have a tracfone that runs me $20 every 3 months. I hate talking on the phone at all and seldom use either one. I'd be more inclined to drop the tracfone if I didn't have an elderly mom and didn't babysit with 2 grandnephews (they have no home phone).
  • tax on landline
    Landline costs me about $35. and taxes are about $15. I complained to my state representative that the cost of a landline telephone is prohibitive in part because of taxes. No response from representative yet.
  • Land Line
    I can't drop my Land Line because I also us it for the internet. I don't use Comcast because if I lost power then Comcast would be useless, no power to the box until power would came back on.
  • Land Line
    How do you get your number in a phone book? I am on call a lot and need to be found.
  • Little known emergency landline fact...
    You can plug a phone in to any wall jack, in any home, and dial 911. You do not have to have phone service in order to reach emergency services via a land line. Just drop the service and keep a phone plugged in, if that is your reason for throwing away $600 a year.

    This is also applicable to cell phones! Any cell phone, with active service or not, will dial 911!
  • cell/landlines
    What if the power goes out..there goes your computer connection...and cell phone batteries need charging...how long do you need to run your car to charge it? People came to our house with their cell phones because of our geneator. Still we have a landline.
  • Land line
    After reading several of the comments, I find that I, too, have the same concern about dropping the land lind - I have high speed DSL and it runs off the land line. When that problem can be solved, I could drop the land line and save myself $80 a month.

    At first glance, it appears to be a very good idea, but it doesn't solve the complications that go with it.
  • land line to cell phone
    We switched our home land line to a ATT family line for $10.00 a month fee- free long distance- same phone number- in family texting- all the service of our cell phones-- home line works for 911 calls only --- IT works great-- go on a trip the home phone can go with you no need to give your private cell # out to everybody THANKS CLARK
  • majickJack
    Just dropped my land line and went with majicJack. Got the dry loop DSL with Verizon. Love it so far, when I get a bad connection, I just call back. Got a Panasonic cordless phone system with a base unit that hhas a handset and 2 remote handsets w/chargers for $100. Put the base at the computer and the other 2 where we want phones. Very happy so far . . .
  • dropping land line
    I need my land line for fax. I don't know if faxing could be done with a cell phone.
  • landline
    A landline is more reliable....better audio quality....I prefer them..but I have a $10 per month Kajeet cell phone for emergencies, it is 10 cents per minute. I used 18 minutes last year My Time Warner cable phone is $30 a month, free calls anytime..no limit, no time limits... to all points in the USA and Canada.
  • Land Line
    After Katrina my land line was dead for 3 months. My cell was hit and miss for about 3 weeks and then was solid. I cannot speak for other storms, but this is my experience.
  • High speed DSL
    How can you run a high speed DSL without
    the use of a land line. heiq@bellsouth.net is currently costing me around $45 dollors monthly.
  • Land Line Phone
    Although we still have landline service bundled with our cable service, we did disconnect the landline at out vacation home. That's a savings of $400 a year for a service we don't need.
  • land lines
    An additional fifty dollars a month for a land line to stay in touch with friends and family seems like a small price to pay. Had I cancelled my land line, I would not have received several calls the past year from people who tracked me through a 30 year old phone number.
  • Keeping my land line -- hurricane supply
    After Hurricane Andrew, our land line was the only thing working. After Jeanne and Francis, the cell phone service was horrid and the land line solid throughout. At work, we were using the analog fax machine line to make calls. Just like tarps, bottled water, flood insurance, etc, we keep a land line as a hurricane supply. Basic service is under $20 a month.
  • Dropping land line
    I have vonage ,Majic jack and cell phone.If I could port my Vonage line to majic jack I would and save the $32 I pay Vonage $24.95 plus all the taxes we pay $50 for two line cell phone plan for 1000 min. I cauld never just have cells due to my wife and her mother would use 10000 min a month and have a cell bill of $500 majicjack works most of the time due to all my family and friends have our home # I'm stuck till I can port to majic jack
  • cell phone vs land line
    My phone is expensive, but need it for fax, internet, and home alarm. I don't see how plug Magic Jack into computer instead of having a land line when need land line to connect to internet.
  • Land vs. Cell
    I need my fax both to send & receive. I also need phone to update Direct TV. I haven't seen a cell phone plan with unlimited incoming or outgoing calls locally. I was extremely displeased with t-mobile so I use Virgin Mobile as a prepaid service & it would cost an arm & a leg to make & receive phone calls.
  • no land line
    Unfortunatley, we live in an area that is dead to cell phones....about a 1,000 ft. area that has no cell service. We walk the neighbourhood to get service....so if I cancel my land-line - there's no service on either phone! what to do?
  • MagicJack
    Folks, MagicJack and other VoIP solutions like Skype and Vontage only work reliably IF your upload link is greater than 256 Kbps AND you get a router with QoS in both directions. This is especially true if you have multiple PCs connecting over your home router. The D-Link DIR-655 is one of the few routers that offer QoS in both directions. It's not for the novice to setup, but works great when configured to give the VoIP ports priority on your home network.
  • Dropping Your Land Line
    I have AT&T land line. I dropped the call line and now only have Broadband Fast Access service for my computer. I cut my monthly bill in half. The magic word to have this done is called "dry loop". I have no idea what this means but when I called AT&T and requested it it was done immediately.
  • Rural location concerns
    I live in a rural location. Only Verizon Wireless is available and the signal is practically non-existent at home. I have tried MagicJack but had problems and spent hours with tech support to fix and my internet connection was not the best so it did not work properly (they do have a 911 feature where you can report the location of your phone). I use Skype - bought my own number and now pay $2.95 for unlimited calls to US and Canada. Quality much improved over the past year. One day a fiber optic line went down in the area (or was cut) and all cell service, 911 service, and DSL internet went out. Only the land line local calling would work.
  • MagicJack
    Works great! I love it and I'm saving SOOOOO much money. Tracfone for emergencies and a back up! Called 911 yesterday, they had my address - everything was just fine!

    Nice job Tracfone... Nice Job MagicJack!
  • Dropping land line
    The alarm system issue adds significant costs. My company said the radio backup needed is $465 and then they charge an additional $10/month monitoring on top of what I already pay. That is just not worth when factoring in the other comments about 911 not knowing where you are calling from on a cell phone.
  • home alarm
    How will it dial out in case of an amergency?
  • Save up to $600 annually by dropping landline, going cell only
    It is a good idea. However, how about agencies, such as banks, that require one to fillout a home phone number?
  • cell phone only no land line
    bad idea to drop your land line phone because of several thing one is bad signal in lot of locations and two is not everyone can use the phone in your home if they do not have it with them
  • Drop your landline
    I would not recommend this if you live in one the hurricane prone states. Most likely your landline will be your only means of communications after one of these killers passes through.

    Clark is wrong on this one.

    R/TheSwabbie30
  • Keeping My Land Line
    What I am trying to figure out is how to get a better price on my land line, basically for local calls and caller ID. I work at home on a company computer so can't install devices or software for my private use.
  • What about 911?
    What if you could not speak to tell the 911 operator where you lived? If you used your landline, there would be no need to have this fear. Does Magic Jack and Vonage address this issue?
  • 100 DOLLARS FOR 5 YEARS HOME PHONE SERVICE
    go to : magicjack.com ( unlimited local AND USA long distance calling ) THROUGH YOUR HOME COMPUTER !!!
  • VOIP , MagicJack, etc. no FAX
    I do not have landline since last 6 month. The only problem I've seen so far is I CANNOT USE FAX. I have Magic Jack and it works great for regular call, but, will not work for FAX.

    Does anyone have any solutions?
  • Landline phone
    I dropped our landline phone company: but bought the Magic Jack to use with high speed internet. Have just a trac phone for emergencies in car. The Magic Jack costs under $40 for the jack and 1 yr and then you can buy 5 yrs service for $59.95. It includes calls to anywhere in USA and Canada for FREE.Low rates to other countries. Can also be used overseas to call back home.
  • if it was all about money, then yes, drop landline
    If it was only about $, it is a good idea. But clark likes to ignore health at expense of saving $. People, start educating yourself to the harmful effects of wireless phones. There is compelling scientific data linking cancers to wireless cellphones. Of course, it will not be published and is dismissed by the major wireless companies. Go the bookstore and start reading the deception.
  • Keeping land line
    I tried an experiment to see if I could ditch my land line and save money. My monthly cost for said land line is $34.60 (inc. all taxes). I started to log the land line calls. Aftr only 5 days, I realized I'd have to increase my cell phone program that would ultimately cost me more than the land line cost so there would be no savings for me-just more expense!
  • Land Lines
    My AT&T cell phone doesn't get a signal at my home. I had planned to disconnect my home phone once I moved, but can't because of this. However, I did cut down my home line to the bare bones---$17.00/mo + taxes & fees (approx $10). This saved some.
  • Landlines
    I live in Arizona and pay only $12 plus taxes for basic phone, plus 5 cents on long distance - local calls free. Monthly, with tax is $20, yearly $240. One Suite (join online) is also great for calls worldwide, and local long distance - join online and prepay at onesuite.com. Here we have buried lines and locked boxes with covered conduit lines , so that is good as well from a security aspect.
  • Cell Phone versus Land Line
    I've still got dialup!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Cell phone only
    I dropped my land line phone that we had had since 1942 in about 1999 when they started charging the number portability fee and have just used my cell or skype, I have saved several thousand dollars over the years.I am very happy with the extra calls from the land line.
  • I Don't Plan on Going Cell Only
    I won't be getting rid of my land line while cell phone calls are still so spotty. It's frustrating sometimes talking to people on their cells; my land line ALWAYS sounds good.
  • magicjack
    just got one 3 days and unable to get dial tone and help beyond the 2 'CLICK HERE" posted! And as one comment stated;"no phone# to call for help" a real "bummer".
  • Don't drop landline
    As a single living alone, I have twice had occasion to call during emergency situation, one furnace fire, one choking and unable to breathe. I was able to get to phone punch 911 and gasp Can't breath into phone but was unable to do more verbally, for the fire I simply said furnace fire. In both cases the emergency crews arrived momentarily and saved the day. Rather than dropping the landline where your address displays automatically, switch to their minimum plan. In my area its a basic fee under $10 with $4.00 allowance for local calls at .07 each. Use a cell for other calls if needed, but think of the landline as a cheap insurance policy in times of emergency.
  • Cell calls are NOT easily listened to
    For Paul: I'm afraid your facts are not correct. Cell phone calls are digital. One must have very specialized and expensive equipment to listen to cell phone calls.
  • Drop Kicked
    I'm trying out Magic Jack. So far it works for faxes and phone calls but I plan on returning it soon. The next test will be ooma. I want to see if that works better. Cost $200 but I don't need it hooked to a computer and no annual fee. Hey they both have "Free 30 day trail period". Will see.
  • Landline needed for dial-up
    We are rural and cable and dsl are not available; satellite is far too costly. Our bill averages $22.50 monthly and we don't pay for long distance - we use our cells. Sure would love to dump the landline though!!
  • land line vs cell
    For Bill: just a thought but you can drop your land line to just a voice mail box (about $14/month) you won't have a phone that rings but if you get into the habit of checking it regularly, it saves in the long run. I use it for my business line, switched to a majicjack and keep the bus line as a voicemail box in cyber world.
    Good luck
  • VOIP and Cell only for years
    We live in hurricane alley and haven't had a land line in 5 years. We are VOIP and cell phones only. We're with Teleblend (ever since the Sun Rocket debacle) and have had only minor issues in the beginning...definitely not enough to warrant paying more than $15.99 a month for home phone service. We also have ADT home security with a wireless system, and are very happy. I wouldn't go back to paying $50 or more a month for what I have for $15.99!
  • majicjack
    I installed a magic jack and even went as far as purchasing additional equipment (40.00) that was suppose to provide phone service. I called their tech line time and time again, and no matter what I tried, it didn't work. I was told to do the same procedure everytime I called. The techs were not adequately trained to resolve the problem. Plus, the problem was a hardware problem that needed to be resolved before magic jack put their product on the market. My only recourse was to request a refund, which was done in a reasonable time frame, and to return the extra part to Radio Shack for a refund, that was suppose to make magic jack work. It was a BIG hassle and a waste of time. I did not just plug it in and have service. I would not recommend magic jack to anyone at this time. If they finally get the bugs out and can prove to me that it will work on my pc, I'd try it again. The idea is good, but the equipment and the repair/tech department need additional training and they need to learn to speak English. Not just enough to repeat what I already try to do with the magic jack.
  • Land Lines Are Stupid !!!
    I got tired of all the solicitor phone calls. They would not stop calling for people who used to live in our house 5 years ago. So I dropped our land line, switched from DSL to Cable High Speed, hooked up DirectTV and now I am saving alot of money by just having a cell phone. The so called "land line" phone companies days are numbered for sure, just wait until the GPS blackberry cell phone hit the streets. Take control of your money now and make the switch.
  • Land lines vs Cells
    How do I keep my number while giving up the phone? I would like it permanently forwarded to my cell phone. Havn't found a way to do that yet
  • emergencies
    I have two teenage daughters. I keep my landline just in case there is an emergency and my daughters have not charged their cell phones. The $360 I pay per year is worth the peace of mind.
  • magicJack
    I had Vonage a few years ago and then went with Sunrocket. When that went out of business I bought a magicJack and have been perfectly happy with it. It works just as good as Vonage and the defunct Sunrocket. If you have a good internet setup at your home the magicJack will work great!
  • Overseas Calls
    Use Penny Talk from a cell phone or better still use Skype from your computer. Skype allows you to talk and see (optional) for FREE!
  • Security
    People can easily "listen in" on cell phone calls as a hobby. Not so much on landlines.
  • landline
    I have my computer hooked up to my landline. How do I disconnect.
  • drop land line, keep DSL
    If you are served by AT&T, you now have the option to drop your landline & pay just for DSL
  • What about not being listed in Directory Assistance?
    With cell only you cannot be located by directory assistance. If someone lost/forgot your cell number they'd have no way of calling, right?
  • Drop Land Line; Add cell phone
    I appreciate Clark's help in saving us money but Clark fails to mention some important information when he criticizes the local phone company. The local phone company that provides land line service is required to provide service even if you live 10 miles down a pig path. Cell phone companies and cable companies are not. Also, these other companies are not scrutinized by the local regulatory agencies regarding their service. When a storm comes and you lose cell phone, cable, satellite and landline service, see which one comes back up first if you notice your landline down down at all. Local landline providers are required to maintain battery back up systems. Just wanted to point out some of the issues local phone companies have to deal with that othere "competitors" do not.
  • dropping land line
    In my case I dropped my land line when
    I got my Vonage. This has worked out since My phone co. has a stand alone High Speed Internet enabling me to have
    my Vonage and HS internet for a combined
    $45.00 plus tax. I have every idea that
    I could come out even further ahead if I dropped Vonage and substituted Magic Jack. Please comment re the latter option if it has worked out for you.
    Fred
  • Land Line
    To drop my landline I'd have to add more minutes to my cell phone. The cost of adding more minutes would be more than the cost of my cell phone and land line together. My cell phone plan is $39.99 for 1000 anytime minutes with ATT. (No nights & weekends). Don't understand Clark's reasoning. Makes no sense in ALL CASES.
  • cell vs landline
    I have two landlines in my home....they are more private and safer than cell....but I do have a tracphone for emergencies out on the road.... my monthly fees are much lower than those with comparable features that I have (dsl , etc.) and because I work for a telephone company , I will kepp my landlines...that is until the telephone companies force you out of owning it...
  • Magic Jack
    I just sent my Magic Jack back to Jack....I tried it at home for 3 weeks and the phone reception was spotty and not consistent.....sometimes it was great, but most of the time there was an awful noise within the lines and I could not justify the poor quality. The VALUE was not there even though it was cheap. I'll try something else, but save your money and leave magic jack alone......
  • Comment on losing DSL
    No, Clifford, even tho it took lots of time and energy, I dropped my home line, ported that number to my cell phone, and had AT&T give me a new phone number for DSL (must have to report DSL problems). AT&T charges $5 a month for that DSL phone line. I figure I'm saving just under $500/year to drop home line. Happy to save the $ and to know AT&T is losing out. On my mom's phone, her bill would go UP if I did away with Long Distance and Voicemail (so-called bundling) that she does not need! Who ever heard of anyone charging you MORE for LESS services? They are alienating themselves from their cash cow. Do it - so your phone is upstairs when you're downstairs - that's what voicemail is for. Use the speaker on your cell phone for more than one person talking. And surely you don't answer your phone every time - Caller ID works great. Clark's on target here.
  • Drop Land Line; Add Cell Phone?
    Clark forgot the biggest objection of them all: Holding a cell phone next to your brain leads to brain damage. It's like holding microwave next to it. The reason that there is little evidence of this in the research is that the government and the corporations have refused to fund research here in the USA. However, they can't stop the research from Europe. Clark should read more about it. Remember, once upon a time not too long ago, they said cigarettes, cars that were unsafe at any speed, toys from China, and x-ray machines were not dangerous too.
  • Do you REALLY need the convenience of answering your phone immediately, every time? You can't call someone right back 5 seconds later if you're downstairs?

    And many (most?) cell phones have a speaker phone option so you can have as many people on the line as you want. Or, instead of $600, you can pay a few cents to do a 3-way call (assuming it's not already included in your calling plan) to your wife's cell phone when it's that important to have more than 1 person on the line.

    DSL can be priced separately.
  • Security Systems
    You know, I've been listening to Clark for a long time, and have saved a lot of money as a result of his advice over the years. However, at times, he'll look at short term savings vs. helping consumers to find the best overall answer. For example, this discussion about dropping a landline has finally caused me to reply.

    For as long as I can recall, Clark has been advocating paying as little as possible for a monitored security system and provider (as long it goes through a UL listed monitoring center). Now, under separate cover, he recommends dropping your land line to save money, and dismisses the security system question by saying that one should be using wireless monitoring.

    What he fails to mention is that wireless monitoring costs money too, especially if you've been following his advice by going with a less expensive security provider all along (hardware modifications, etc.).

    This, to me, points to Clark's sometimes simplistic view of saving money.

    I know it's not cool to criticize Clark, especially in these forums, but I just wanted to add my two cents.
  • cell phone only
    You also have a problem with 911 calls. With a landline , the info is sent to 911 center, not so with a cell phone
  • Drop the landline
    I have been using magic jack for 6 months without a single problem. You do need to have 5mbps or faster on a cable internet hook-up. I have 5 years of pre-paid service for 60 bucks Yep, 5 years. It has e-911 with my exact address for emergency. magicjack.com. The worst you'll lose is 2 months worth of landline.
  • dropping land line
    We don't have a cell phone, they work poorly in many areas in Wa State.
  • Cost, etc
    Okay, some people still want their landline, good for them. We have gone without it for 3 years now, in a large house.

    As to $185 month for cell phone. Something is wrong. We have 4 phones, pretty much unlimited calls, and long distance, data on two of them, and the total is $140 a month. Think rollover.
  • I dropped my land line and use T mobile Home
    We dropped our land line but ported our home number to a VOIP with TMobile.Called TMobile Home. It is 10.00 a month and we can use 2 phones in the house that are connected wirelessly. Works great!
  • response to what about faxes?
    Use eFax - they will assign you a number and then you can send any document on your machine as a fax and receive faxes via your email in pdf format. There is free eFax lite to try out and then you can upgrade. It rocks!
  • Can't drop landline
    Anyone, like me, who has DSL internet service requires that landline. The RBOC's don't all sell "naked" DSL where you don't need the telephone number and associated expense.
  • Cell phone Docking to Convert to Land Line
    There are some devices available that provide a cellphone docking station connected to your land line phone. e.g.
    RCA Cell Phone Docking System
    http://reviews.cnet.com/cordless-phones/rca-cell-phone-docking/4505-3499_7-31450241.html?tag=mncol;lst
    OR
    Phone Labs Dock-N-Talk
    http://reviews.cnet.com/cell-phone-and-smart/phone-labs-dock-n/4505-6448_7-30974588.html?tag=mncol;lst
    The issues of cellphone coverage is not solved by this.
  • Landline
    I have DSL so I need a phone line. If I switch to cable internet it will cost over twice as much as what I'm paying for my DSL so doing away with my phone at home would not be an option for me
  • Dropping Landline
    My husband and I dropped our land line over 7 years ago and have used strictly cellular since. For internet we use cable for broadband. We've never had any problem with phones not working at difficult times. Never have to rush up or down stairs for ringing cell phones either as we each keep our phones with us at all times. I even purchased a headset for my cell phone for times when I am working in the kitchen or doing laundry and of course for the obvious driving. One recent instance made us quite happy to have celluar and that was when our power was out for 37 hours due to an ice storm. We were able to call for assistance and inform family members of our situation because we had working cell phones. We figure we save $300 a year by not having a landline.
  • Pacemaker Requires Land Line
    My husband requires a land line when his pacemaker is periodically monitored. Otherwise, we would drop the land line.
  • Land line
    I keep my landline for FAX service and for my computer internet access. Any help on those 2 matters? Does the cost of a land line outweigh the cost for wireless computer??
  • Dropping landline
    I use a fax machine (not everyone uses Efax or similar), and reverse 911 is part of our emergency services. How can I still have those without a landline?
  • magic jack?
    what is magic jack?
  • Reasons to not drop a land line
    With a land line you can have multiple phones, all on the same circuit, which means convenience in the house and also the ability to have more than one person on the phone to listen or talk at the same time. With a cell phone, only one person at a time can be on a time to listen or talk. Plus with a cell phone you have to remember where you left it in the house and rush to it if it rings, even if you are downstairs and the phone is upstairs. With a land line just pickup the closest phone.

    Also my DSL is tied to having a land line. If I get rid of the land line, I loose my high speed internet.

    While some people can do without the land line, others can't, so Clark you need to get real.
  • fax
    What do you do about faxes?
  • Dropped Land Line
    I have just dropped my landline and switched to OOMA, an outstanding VoIP device/service. Incredible clarity, and the service offers every feature I had on my landline--voicemail, blocked calls, call waiting, and even multiple phone lines/numbers at no additional cost.
  • Dropping landline Phone
    When Directv gets with the real world and allows their DVR to connect via the inet then I will not need for a landline. I use vonage right now to call brother in Paris for free, when he comes home, there will be no need for it, until both these happen, must keep a land line
  • Drop Land line Phone
    What if this is your only "known" way to have a computer line? Can't get DSL in my area, can't get AT&T Dish for their hook-up..any other options? Also, is privacy/security still a concern with cell phones?
  • We recently disconnected our land line and started saving ALOT of money every month. We have magic jack as our land line/home phone utilizing our internet, and it was one of the smartest decisions we have made about our phones. In addition you can solve the 911 issue by registering your address with magic jack.
  • I disagree
    I have a landline and would never give it up.

    I pay $52./mo. for my landline and internet service combined. Do you pay $52/mo. with a cell phone and the internet combined? Moreover, my phone reception is never bad.

    I get frustrated with other people's cell phone calls because half of the time the reception is awful or their battery goes dead in the middle of the call.

    Also, I never have to re-charge my landline, and I never lose it then have to worry about others making expensive calls at my expense.

    I also don't have to worry about being locked into some awful contract forever.

    If I drop my phone, it doesn't cost me $$$$ to replace it either, and I can see the numbers on my phone easily when I dial.

    Finally, it would drive me nuts to have people call me while driving or in the grocery store and I'm irritated when I am forced to listen to others private calls in public.

    I can afford a cell phone, but I'd never have one. EVER. You'd have to pay ME to get one.
  • Still need it for dialup
    My old computer can't utilize high-speed internet, so I'm stuck with both dialup and a landline bill. Finances being what they are now, I can't afford a new computer, so AT&T will enjoy that monthly income...for a little while longer. They will definitely get the ax next though --they just raised rates on home phones! What nerve! Watch them cry like pups when LL's fade into history altogether. They killed the golden goose and have no one else to blame.
  • Land Line vs. other
    I have had skype, no problem. but I just dropped my cable phone service (have not had a land line since Vonage first came out). I got the MagicJack internet phone. Gives me a number I can use for $20/yr, without giving my cell phone number to the world.
  • VOIP via cable
    ....may not be a reliable alternative either. Between your house and the cable office may be a powered repeater.....with NO battery backup. I would say "Ask the cable company" but I doubt you can trust them to give you the right answer.
  • overseas calls
    Grady, if your overseas contacts have computer you each should download Skype. My daughter lives in Japan and we love talking and seeing each other at no charge.Clark promoted Skype and we adopted it.
  • Phone Service
    I haven't had one of those land line phones since Metro PCS came to Atlanta. It is hard to imagine why anyone would pay for a phone that is tied to one place and costs a fortune. For $50 a month I get unlimited everything.
  • no cell signal
    I live in the suburbs, but at the bottom of a hill and we have NO cell signal at all. Some better carriers have 1 bar. I know there are cell signal boosters, but if the power goes out, so does the booster. The land line works if there is no power
  • Cell reception and safety
    When we moved into our new home last March we went 6 months with just our cell phones. We live in a slightly rural area and I found that when I really needed to make a lot of calls, my reception wasn't what I needed. Also we have 2 young children (1 and 3), there was one instance where my father-in-law was watching the oldest and I found out later he didn't have a cell phone on him. I wanted the peace of mind knowing that there was a home phone for emergencies.
    We would feel comfortable with an internet provider for our phone service if we had a reliable internet connection. We have a wireless service that while faster than dial-up isnt' the quality of high speed. Add to the scenario that we only have 1 phone provider and live in an area where free local calls are very limited area. It has become costly for our home phone.
  • Dropping Landline
    I actually DID drop my landline for several months, but recently added it back (through AT&T Uverse). The reason is that the local police department came to our crime watch meeting and said that in the event of dialing "911" from a landline, the caller's exact address would show up on the computer screen. The best that would happen with a cell phone is the nearest tower. Since I live alone, I decided I wanted that extra measure of security (that I could pick up a phone, dial "911"..and not even have to say anything).
  • Cell phone reception
    I would be happy to drop my land line, but the reception on cell phone isn't good enough to be reliable at all times. I think it could be good, but for some reason the companies won't spend the money to make it as good as land line reception.
  • Unfortunately, I live in an area where my phone company requires me to have the landline so I can have the DSL. I really dont want to leave the company and go to Comcast. I hate having the landline; however, I was able to reduce my cell phone bill by $20 since I have to have the landline.
  • overseas call
    If I get my landline phone removed, whats the best was to make cheap calls to overseas area like the Philippines, Thailand and japan,
  • dropping land lines for cell phones
    It makes me sick that my cell phone bill is $185 for mine and 2 children's cell coverage. we need to get back to basics and have a $30 - $ 50 a month phone bill.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement