advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Dec 18, 2008 -- New credit card rules a mixed bag for consumers

There are new rules coming concerning credit cards that are both a win and a loss for consumers.

First, the good news: The rules will ensure that banks can't retroactively raise the rate on existing balances you carry. They can still, however, do so if you stopping paying, as well as on all future purchases. Meanwhile, the banks will also be required to give 45 days of notice -- up from 15 days -- whenever they want to change your terms.

Now, the not-so-good news: These rules won't go into effect until July 2010! As Clark quips, that gives the banks plenty of time to buy off members of Congress and get these rules overturned!

In related news, CNN reports that Citibank is one of the worst offenders when it comes to what they're calling "rate jacking." Rate jacking is where the banks raise your interest rate even if you pay on time -- simply because you run a balance. So pay those balances off!

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • citi lied
    Ipaid off my cit balance of 15K...they then offered a balance transfer @3.99% for 15 months ...so I did it and now they say it is only for 6 months...
    What can I do?
  • mysterious notification letter
    In recent days I have noticed that my interest rates on some of my credit cards are being increased over 4 times there current rate . When I call the credit card company's they tell me that I was mailed a letter with a deadline that has allready passed that would have enabled me to lock in the interest rate at the low rate that I was promised for the life of the loan if I had called before the cut off date and opted to close my account . It seems that no one at the credit card company's can even give me a date that they supposedly sent this letter . I was told by the credit card company that it was not there responsibility to make sure the United States Postal Service delivered the mail . I'm not sure what legal stand I have on this matter, can anyone give me advice on what to do ?
  • Opting Out
    I just found out that you have the option to Opt Out of your new rates. Unfortunately, this closes the account, but should not affect your credit as long as you continue to make your monthly payments. I just did this with Home Depot, which is run by Citibank.
  • Chase Visa
    Clark wouldn't like it.. but I paid my Chase Visa..as a deduction from my checking account for four years..never late..never missed a payment.. My rate recently went from 5.99% to something like 12.43%.. with the prime of 3.25% and some greed cushion..piled on.. I called Case..with controlled fury.. for a few minutes..I knew they raised it because of other people defaulting..What made me more angry..were the lies to hid the real reason.."due to market changes"..blah..blah..blah.." "bull crap..you are reading from a script!"..I said.. with some anger."You are not citing the real reason !" I threatened to file a complaint.. with the FTC and with my Congresswoman..who has yet to get back to me..The silver linning was.. it made me angry enough to pay off the account..instead of managing the payments..with some adjustments.. to my spending.. the $9k debt.. should be gone in six months..Also..I did not expect..but did get a letter from Chase..restoring my old interest rate with no reduction in my credit line..But..it's too late..I am now bent on firing Chase..once and for all..
  • Fico/Rate Increase
    Karen, Fico scores are going down just because...I heard they are dropping on people in good standing and mine is dropping too. This whole system is more corrupt than I ever thought possible.

    Hilarious: Yes, when you use a credit card, you enter a mutual agreement. They give you money you don't have so you can buy what you need, or want. Then you pay it back, and there is a fee. But my agreement was no annual fee and 13% interest. Now from one month to the next it's 23% interest and a $ 120 maintenance fee. I have held my end of the bargain, now I expect them to hold theirs.
  • In response to the "PEOPLE" post
    You know, the problem is that some people (like HA on 2/19/09)can't or don't want to see the big picture. It's so much simplier to just blame the whole econmoic mess on "people living beyond their means". Is that part of it, yes, but a small part. The Federal Reserve created and flooded the market with cheap money, creating the credit bubble. This was done on behalf of Wall Street, Investment Banking Corporate America and Banks. Compounding this was Congress removing every safe guard (Glass-Segile Act) that was put in place during the last Depression. Congress allowed these regulations to be removed because of the huge sums of money they were taking from the banking lobby. The entire system is corrupt, they allowed banking to be turned into a loan shark operation. Should people not have over spent? Yes, but, again the whole consumer economy was created by the Feds to keep a bankrupt economy going. There still doing it, by proping up every bankrupt financial insitution on the grounds their to big to fail. Ha, I'm glad you can live within your means, but remember the average working person has not seen their wages increase (against inflation) for over 30 years, Expenses kept going up and they borrowed against their homes. Not saying it was a good idea, but, they followed the advise of the financial industry. Not everyone who is in debt, bought more home than they could afford, or borrowed againsted it to pay for vacations and cars. You say your only 25 yrs old, great, learn about the monetary system and how it really works. You still have time.
  • People!
    I saw a posting that Banks ruined the Economy? Please, give it a rest already. People always want to point the finger at others. Maybe you should take a look in the mirror. The REAL reason our economy is the way it is, well that's because US as Americans think we can have EVERYTHING in our sight. But cry when the bill comes rolling in, and don't have the funds to cover it. Try doing that around oh lets say..... 10 million households... and what do you get?

    ANSWER! A RECESSION! POOR ECONOMY! PEOPLE CANT PAY BECAUSE THEY LIVE BEYOND THEIR MEANS. :)

    Take responsibility for your own actions, instead of pointing the finger. I have 4 credit and store cards... All my accounts are paid off. Never use them unless I NEED to, NOT WANT to. I'm 25 and responsible with my credit, for my childs sake.
  • Complaining people!
    I find it funny when people get upset when their interest rates go up and want to complain about it. DONT USE CREDIT CARDS THEN! And furthermore your interest on other "loans" probably went up too, but you're too busy fussing about a credit card, that you BORROWED money from a bank and they are charging a fee to do so. Get over it. It's life.
  • FICO scores
    I have always paid my bills on time and I pa more than the minimums. I checked my FICO score the other day and it has gone down 63 points since August of 2008. What is going on????? I have no nw debt and I'm paying off existing debt. Isn't that supposed to help your FICO score???
  • rate hike
    Citibank raised my rate from 12.9% to 24.9% recently. I called to find out why and they said they needed to make more money to offset their issues with the poor economy. Luckily, they put my rate back where it was and adjusted my payment/interest accrued for the duration of my membership till my current card expires in 2010. After that my account will close but I can still pay off at my current interest rate. Make the phone call-it's worth it.
  • Citi-Bank and Credit Score
    I had two cards with no balance, Wells Fargo and Bank of America. They close out these account because I did not use them when requested. My credit score was reduced by more than 40 to 60 points due to these cards being closed. Citi just increased my interest rate by 7 points on a Sears card, I've had their card since 1971. I always pay on time and more than the minimum. I will be notifying my senator and representative concerning the credit agencies and the banks. Is nationalization the only answer to the greed and corruption.
  • Citibank Rate Jacking
    Citibank is one of the worse offenders for rate jacking. My card is going from 6.99% to 14.99%. I have been a good customer for a number of years, this is how they thank me. I had my college aged daughter get a student card from Citibank last year. They had been dropping her rate since she got the card, now they have almost doubled her rate. I am shopping for a new card with a better institution!
  • Banks
    Glen is absolutely 100% correct. When is our President and lawmakers going to step in stop the banking industry for totally destroying this country. They keep saying that they have this "right" to manage their "risk" by increasing interest rates ect. They lost all their rights once they accepted the first dollar of bailout money. They can't have it both ways. We the taxpayers are keeping them from going bankrupt (do to there previous mis-management) and they turn around and beg for bailout money, then double dip us by increasing fees and interest rates.

    The bankers and wall street can say what they want, they tried in the begining of this crisses by blameing us, and the subprime mortages for "buying homes" we could afford ect. If that was the only problem, the bailout money would easily take care of that. Interesting stat I heard on Mike Huckabey last night. One trillion dollars would buy all the stock in Walmart, Mircrosoft, Coke, Pepsi, and a few other well know corporations. This mess was caused purely and simply by the banking industry and now they want to fix it with our money. They should all be in jail.
  • Hardship Plan
    Brian - What are the typical terms for a hardship plan and how do I qualify? I haven't missed payments but have a lot of outstanding credit card debt, all of which is now at a much higher interest rate. We have our own company and only have a contract until May. Thanks.
  • MR.PRESIDENT
    Mr. President what are your thoughts about this?
    When are we going to see some oversight committee on these banks? We bailed them out with our Tax payers money and now this is what we get in return. I think we should let them go bankrupt. They are bankrupting everyone by jacking up their rates. Mr. President you should put a stop to this and put a cap on the interest rate they can charged on every consumer of this country. Please conduct and investigation on all of the politician who is taking some contributions from all these banks. This is one of the CHANGE WE NEED!!!
  • Credit Card Rates
    I have a 3.99% rate until the balance is paid off, never been late. I just got a statement that raised my minimun to $463.00 a month. There offer is to raise my rate to 7% for a year at $180.00 a month. If I'm ever late, interest goes to 29.9%.
    Can't we do something ??!!!!!
  • YOUR BAILOUT
    I just got ratejacked by those **ers at Chase. NEVER A LATE PAYMENT. GUESS WHAT, CHASE? YOU'LL GET 1/2 YOUR MONEY WHEN I FILE CHAPTER 13!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Banks
    I can certainly understand why Citibank needs to raise their interest rates. After all they have to buy a new Jet to fly their incompedent CEO and Board of Directors around. Same with B.O.A. their VP "couldn't" live with the office he inheritied, so they just had to spend a few million on getting it fixed up. Gee, if the office had a desk, chair and phone what else could he possible need. Yep a $65,000 toliet bowl. The funny thing is that these same bank executives go in front of Congress and tell them they have to raise interest rates to manage their "risk". The only risk is their mis-management. No insurance against that? Sad time in America. The bankers have sold us all out.
  • Citibank Raises Rates
    After bailing them out, I just received a notice that my card rate is being raised to 19.99%. When I called they explained that they were raising rates, despite the fact that I have been with them for 11 years and have been a great customer.

    I also read that opting out lowers your credit score. I would love to pay off the balance, but my husband just got laid off.

    So much for change we can believe in. I guess that change is allowing the banks to bankrupt the middle class.
  • Thieves at Chase
    Just received a notice from Chase that they're raising our current interest rate of 8.99% to 12.99% starting March 2009! Options are to accept or opt-out and have our account closed! What these credit card companies/banks are really doing is double-dipping; i.e. gov't bailout money thanks to the tax-payers and rate-jacking! What are the politians doing to protect us?! NOTHING! THANKS FOR LETTING US GET HOSED!
  • Chase Reneging on Offer
    Just received my January bill from Chase and noted my minimum payment had gone from 2% to 5% of my outsatnding balance, plus a $10 service charge. I have had this card for years and had an outstanding balance locked in at 3.99%. When Customer No Service was called they said a notice was sent in November and they could offer 3 options, make the new payment (which would help me pay off the card sooner and keep the 3.99%), pay off the card entirely, or move the debt to a higher rate and pay the 2% minimum with no $10 service charge. When asked why the change I was told they had to do it to keep my account viable, meaning they were loosing money and had to find a way to jack my rates. I have already started closing my accounts with Chase and will never do business with them again.
  • Rate Jacking
    I just got my notice from Chase on one of my 2 cards with them jacking the rate to 14.99%. It's outrageous. They also state that I may have to forfeit my mileage award if I opt out of the increase. Doesn't that get regulated by United instead of Chase? Now I'm waiting for the other shoe to drop for the 2nd account. These new rules need to go into effect immediately. The banks are just making use of this lead time to rate jack everyone before it goes into effect - and then who is it protecting? They should at least freeze any changes that are not a result of late or missed payments until the rule is in effect.
  • Rate Jacking-
    Regarding the previous post from David, here is part B to your question of "What if we all payoff our credit cards and go to a cash only basis.

    Part B is what if everyone gets tired of getting ripped off by our financial system and "everyone just stops paying"? Thats the next banking crisis when, the banks are getting bailout money (our money) and then turning around and sticking it to us with late fees, bank charges, increased interested ect. They better hope that everyone doesn't just get sick of the whole thing.
  • Rate Jacking "Chase"
    I thought I would pass along that I just got a rate jacking notice from Chase on my 2 credit cards with them. Although it is not a huge increase (prime plus 7.99%) I was at 7.99% before this so it is jacking non the less. The scary part of the notice was "They will apply to current and future balances on your account" Another laughable statment that was made, "The principal factor we considered in amending your account is maintaining profitability on your account". I carry a number of cards from different issuers so I believe I may just decline these changes. What will these banks do if we all pay off our cards and go to a cash only basis? They may have their money back but if we don't borrow it again how will they make more? I know that's nearly impossible but one can dream.
  • Banks
    The major banks (B.O.A. Citibank ect.) were a major cause of the financial disaster. They got a so called "bailout" (our money) to help "jump start" the flow of credit.
    All they did was hold the money, raise our rates and fee on everything they could and as a result, they "locked" up the economy again. Consumers are not going to be confident in this type of environment and just won't spend. Congress needs to mandate some rules to these bank/bankers. If we wait for the banks to "do the right thing" we will be bankrupt and only the banks will have money (that will be worthless)

    Just like the "frist" great depression, it was the bankers and Fed Reverse that not only caused it, but kept it going.

    Lack of leadership in politics, Wall Street and the Corporate World got us into this mess. They are all trying to blame the consumers (good offense if the best defense?)
  • CitiBank's Unfair Rate Jacking Practices
    I have been an excellent paying customer with CitiBank for over 6 years!I have "never" been late on a payment, always pay over my minimum payment and keep my balance below my credit limit. I opened my account with CitiBank by transferring my balance from a competitor, and was "promised" that my interest rate would remain at 7.99% unless I exceeded my balance or made late payments. I just received my January bill that showed a rate increase from 7.99% to a whopping 14.99%, and I was "never" notified by the bank that the rate would be increased! I called the bank, and pulled the statement that they "claimed" included a notice of the increase, and there was no such notation provided. I advised the same to the "Customer Jacking" Manager, who expressed no empathy at all, and basically explained that either A)I accept the increase as is and keep the account, or B)Decline the increase, keep the lower rate and "not" expect to have another card issued after the card expires in September 2009. My job requires that I travel! I use my card, then submit my expenses to be reimbursed, so I NEED MY CARD!! CitiBank is unfair and has proven to be a very dishonest company! They are taking advantage of good paying customers by "forcing" us to pay the balances of others! If anyone has any suggestions of any actions that can be taken against CitiBank "please" pass on to Clark Howard or notify the news media! Broomhilda the so called Customer Service Manager at CitiBank informed me that I only have until January 31st to make my decision. The government has helped these con-artist banks with major bailouts, and in return CitiBanks account holders are being royally screwed!!! We need a BAILOUT NOW!!!!!
  • Chase is Blackmailing
    Even if you have perfect credit history, Chase is making you choose between two options:
    1) Pay a minimum payment of 5% of balance plus a $10 monthly service fee, or
    2) Accept a higher rate.
    Never mind the fact that they advertised a balance transfer at a fixed rate for the life of the loan. They are now blackmailing you into a higher rate because they no longer want to honor their past agreement.
    I will never do business with Chase again. I will also make sure all my friends, children, and children friends know how Chase treats their best customers.
  • Discover rate jacking, too
    hey Clark,
    I just got a notice in the mail from Discover doing just this. They are raising my rate on ne purchases and on my existing balance. Now we were planning to payoff this card but now are even more determined to do so. Wanted to comment since I didn't see anyone else mention Discover.
  • Raising credit card rates without cause
    Wachovia Bank just raised my interest rate from 7.9% to 15.99% and I've never missed a payment EVER on any item on my credit report. I don't see how doubling someone's interest rate is supposed to help anyone involved. While I recognize I've been only treading water and mainly paying minimum payments, doubling the interest rate will definitely cause me to have financial problems and likely fall behind. Way to go Wachovia...guess you have to offset all of those real estate losses that you had from those option ARM's with causing more debt to go bad! Where is George Bailey when you need him? Is Wachovia's new CEO named Potter?
  • Banks are holding back our economy.
    If the banks would stop raising rates arbitrarily and punishing good customers, people might lose some of the fear and start spending again. Wouldn't that be better for our economy? I don't want to use my cards at all now that I see how unscrupulous the banks are. It's no wonder everyone is just hunkering down and paying off existing debt, instead of buying anything new on credit. Congress should put these laws into place immediately to protect the consumers.
  • Chase jacked my rate!
    Chase just raised my interest rate from 8.9 to 15.9% for no apparent reason. I have the same question as Lisa. I can opt-out of the rate increase, but my card will be terminated. It seems like opting out will hurt my credit score.
  • Citbank Interest Changes
    If I opt out, the card will expire on my next renewal rate. Will this hurt my FICO score?
  • HSBC is jacking rates
    I got suckered into a no fees, 2.9% 1 year APR card fom HSBC 2 years ago. At the one year mark it went 9.9, then at the next 6 month it went to 19.99, and last month it went to 24.99. All they keep telling me is that is in accordance with the card holder agreement. I have never been late or over the limit. It is a 2000 limit card and I ran it up to 1800, bought a house and used it to purchase stuff to fix it up.
    I was listining to Clark say to pay half the bill every 2 weeks so they couldn't charge the full intrest for the month. I started paying all my credit cards that way. What is funny is after a couple of months of doing this my rates got jacked, even though tere is no late payments or over limit and my credit score has risen.
  • Credit Card Interest
    It seems from the posts that Citicard is the worst offender of the "ratejacking". That's kind of ironic since they just borrowed $25 billion dollars from us the taxpaper. Form Citibank the new rules should of went into effect immediately.

    I agree that this long delay in implementing the new rule (July 2010) is just one more example of the average consumer getting the shaft. There isn't any logical explaination that they could give that would justify 189 months to get the new rules put into place. If they can change our rates in 15 days, they can certainly incorporate the new rules with 30-60. It's just giving the banking lobby time to buy off Congress.
  • Double standard
    I find it very unfair that just when Americans need relief, and reform in these areas is overdue, the changes are not effective until 2010. Why is it that when the credit card company wants to change the terms of the cardholder agreement, they only have to give 15 days, but in this case Congress has given them 18 months. Why not give them 15 days to implement the new rules. If it's a matter of software and procedural changes, surely 30-60 days would be enough time for implementation. Why the double-standard?
  • Citibank is raising my rates WITHOUT a balance
    I use my card but don't carry a balance (maybe a few hundred at a time, and it gets paid off within 45 days.)I am never late, and have a good credit score. yet Citibank is raising my rate by 10 percentage points! I am canceling my cards.
  • Creditor removing interest from default rate
    I heard the caller say he missed payments due to job layoff and missed payments. His rate went to 32% default rate. I used to be a debt collector. There is an unwritten rule, customer can ask for a "hardship plan" due to change in finacial condition, usually 6 months to a year. Creditor will reduce interest to 0, no finance charges.
  • Credit Cards
    I'm not an advocate for carrying balances on CC. Granted it's a poor financial choice. But, let look at the big picture as there is enough blame to go around. The Federal Reserve and Gov. created a cheap money supply in an effort to encourage "consumer spending" in hopes of keeping the economic wheels turning. Without the consumer spending on "trinket" and "vacations" ect. The U.S. economy would of collapsed 15 years ago. Again, I'm not advocating the CC balances, but this behavior was encouraged by our gov. and financial insitutions.

    I really don't understand Brian's position. While I agree that people shouldn't carry balances, the reality is that they do. Most do responsiblily. Just because they do, doesn't/shouldn't give the CC companies the right (regardless of "the agreement") to impose "usery" interst fees. I don't have a problem with CC raising interest on new charges, but, I do have an issue with this "retro active" charges on existing balances. Most states had laws to protect consumers against these practices until the banking lobby bought off Congress (What's moral about that Brian?)and had them over turned. Why don't you look into the facts surrounding why a company like Citibank would moved it's credit card division to South Dakota? Their corporate headquarters is in NY.

    I agree in principle with all the posts about not getting into debt, paying the cards off ect., but not all of us are in the same financial position. I realize that people like Brian are just smarter than us all and I hope for your sake that you are never faced with a true emergency. Just like AIG, Citicorp, Lehman's, sometimes all the money in the world can't cover the bill.
  • say no to credit cards.......
    using a credit card is not a good idea, period. look at how many of our parents and grandparents used credit cards. Hardly any. Live well below your means and pay for things in cash and you won't have to be concerned when those notices go out in the mail saying your rate went up because the credit card companies or banks are getting a just deserved smack in the face.
  • credit cards
    The very best way to handle these credit card companies, is to use your credit card as a charge card and pay the balance off each month. If you start this habit your life will be so free from the hold these companies have on you, and want to keep you there.So do yourself a favor and get yourself there.
  • foreign transaction fees
    get a capital one credit card. zero foreign transaction fees and they even eat the 1% visa/mastercard fee.
  • credit cards
    sorry fellas. only idiots don't know or want to know that 99+% of all credit cards have interest rates that can be set by the cardholder at their whim. credit card issuers and holders both have a legal and moral obligation to follow the terms of the agreement you signed. nothing more, nothing less. The vast majority of those with credit cards who carry balances carry virtually all of their debt not for huge emergency medical procedures, but for consumer trinkets, vacations, dining out, trips to the mall and other totally discretionary expenditures. Again, it really does not matter why you carry credit card debt. The fact is that merely having credit card debt is an indication that you are living beyond your means. What happened to actually saving money for that "emergency" like the car broke down, i broke my leg, the furnace needs replacing, etc, etc, etc? Most people with credit card debt have zero savings and have spent their paycheck by the day they get it. For these people every expenditure beyond normal recurring expenses is an emergency that goes on the card. So what do you expect to happen? Stop blaming the credit card issuers for your failure at self control.

    The days of cheap money and credit to anyone who fogs a mirror are gone. So wise up and become a saver. Living beneath your means is the only way. Anyone at any income strata can do it if they set their mind to it.
  • "Consumer Trinkets"
    Not everyone who finds themself in this situation got there by "living beyond their means" and "buying consumer trinkets. People face real life emergencies and at times have no choice but to try and use their credit lines responsibly. Most do. That doesn't or shouldn't make it okay for a CC company just to go out and triple their interest rate. "just read your agreement"?? Don't you think these banks should have some kind of moral or social responsibility. Or is it just okay to let them ruin our enonomy the way they already have.

    There was a recent article that told of a story where a College Professer had an MBA class fill out a mortgage and Credit Card application, read the terms and explain back what they thought those terms actually meant. Guess what? They all failed the test. The entire class. The terms are intentionally written to be vague and misleading. Sorry Brian, that should be a crime.
  • Citibank Rate-Jacking
    I've recently become a "victim" of Citibank rate jacking. A lot of people seem to be under the misconception that this is only an issue IF you carry a balance. That's not quite true.

    I do a lot of international business travel and used my card for it's favorable 1% Foreign Transaction Fee. Citibank sent me new terms that they would be raising this to 3%. I opted out, and can now keep my current rate until 2010 when my card expires. Upon expiration, they will close my account and I will take my business elsewhere.

    If you ask me, I think Citibank is making a big mistake by letting a customer go that routinely charges 25K a year on their card, but that's their business.
  • credit card balances
    only complete fools borrow money where the creditor can under the terms of the loan change the interest rate at will to whatever they want it to be. How about just reading the terms of the agreement before you go head over heals into debt for consumer trinkets by living beyond your means.
  • New Credit Card Rules
    Why wait 18 month before these new rules go into affect? Other than what Clark mentioned about given them time to get the rules overturned, it also gives them time to raise the rates. Or is there a freeze in effect? Probably not, so I would anticipate that a lot more people will be getting ratejacked. You know, one rule that should of have gone into effect immediately was that if you were a financial insitution (like Citicorp) that got a "bailout", you shouldn't be able to raise the rates until you pay back the $25 billion you "borrowed" -Like we will ever see a payback on that. It's funny how the worst offenders of a rule or law are always the one crying the loudest for help when the tables get turned. Citibank gave their customers 21 day notice on ratejacks and they get 18 months advance notice from the Feds. Just great. It's easy to say "get the cards paid down", but we're in a terrible cycle of bad economy, home devaluation, loss of savings/investment, job loss.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement