advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Nov 07, 2008 -- Single-brand mechanics favored by Clark

Americans are keeping cars longer these days out of economic necessity. Many of us are in the 10-year club with our new cars, though owning a used car for 4 years will have the same boon for your wallet.

Of course, with increased vehicle age comes responsibility. Clark is particularly fond of having his used cars serviced at single-brand shops. These kinds of shops only service one brand of vehicle, such as Honda or Toyota. By doing maintenance on a regular schedule, you avoid bigger problems. The most basic thing to do is change your oil every 3,000 or 5,000 miles.

Developing a relationship with a mechanic is one of those important intangibles of car ownership. Single-brand shops have in-depth experience and are familiar with older out-of-warranty cars. Contrast that with the experience of bringing your car to a traditional dealer's service facility: You typically don't get to see the mechanic who worked on your car; you instead have to deal with a commissioned service rep.

New Jersey wants to ensure that auto manufacturers share diagnostic codes with independent single-brand shops. Some manufacturers have been keeping them secret to ensure that car owners could only go to licensed dealers for service. But that's as bad as price-fixing, according to Clark. The "Right to Repair Act" now moves to the N.J. Senate for approval.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • Blanket 3,000 mile oil changes are NOT necessary
    I have to disagree with Sean about his recomendation for changing oil every 3-4,000 miles or 3-4 months. It is simply unnecessary and wasteful. I have a university degree in Engineering and 9 years experience as a test engineer at a major vehicle manufacturer. My advice to car owners is to read carefully what the manufacturer has stated in the driver's handbook and follow that instruction. My own everyday car is 15 years old and gets quality fresh oil every 10,000 miles or one year, whichever is sooner. Same applies to my 1967 Triumph sports car which I have had for 25 years.
  • Oil changes
    The two people who are suggesting that 3,000 mile oil changes are unnecessary and "modern" oil will "last longer" are completely wrong and should not ever give any automotive advice again. Ever. I've worked in the auto repair industry for over 15 years and prolonged oil change intervals are the NUMBER ONE CAUSE OF ENGINE DAMAGE!!!! It's cheap, it's easy, change your oil every 3-4,000 miles or 3-4 months. Once a year in NOT enough. The best insurance ever is an oil change. Done.
  • Un-needed Recommendations! BEWARE!
    I work in a large automotive dealership and see first hand how people are taken for a ride everyday.They do not make a great deal when they sell you the car but after the sale comes the fleecing.Beware of the delivery cordinators that try and sell you undercoating and interior and paint protection items etc. after the inital sale.They come undercoated from the factory,and as for paint and interior protectants.Use a compatiable wax and wax your car every now and then.Then buy some scotchguard and spray it on your interior as per directions.That is what they do.You will save a few hundred dollars right there.
    Beware of the up sell of everything imaginable when you take your car in for anything.Use your owners service manual supplied with your car or go to the brand specific website for your make car and see what they recommend and at what intervals or milage.All of the dealerships will always make additional recommendations well above what is neccessary when it comes to your vehicle.There are several things that have become real money makers for dealerships and the main item would be flushes.They recommend flushing everything,engine-brakes-power steering-transmission-coolant.These things need to be changed at certain intervals but not flushed.If you have a Toyota,go to the Toyota website and see what they say about flushes.You will not see one thing about flushing anything only changing at certain intervals and other than oil,most are at very high milage intervals.BEWARE of flushes they are expensive an un-needed.Be aware of air filter or cabin filter changes,most of these are over recommended and you can do them yourself when needed instead of paying the high price of them doing it for you.When they try and sell you a fuel injection cleaning service for 100.00 just say NO.And then go to the auto parts store and buy your self a can of fuel injection cleaner and add to your tank of gas and go.That is what they do.The auto manufactures give the dealers an open door to all these extras by stating in fine print in the service manuals that your dealer may make additional recommendations depending on driving habits and conditions.Unless you are driving in the desert in very hot,dusty conditions or towing something very heavy for many miles per week,do not get suckered into these extra recommendations.The service writers in these dealerships make their living and are able to keep their jobs by producing numbers and even the most honset appearing ones will sell you plenty you do not need,they are forced to!
  • 1995 Honda Civic 215,000 Miles
    I began using a Honda-only mechanic as soon as my warranty was through. Whenever I try to skimp on the price and elsewhere, I regret it. It is SO WORTH IT to have a specialist look at your car. Hedricks in Lawrenceville GA is the BEST for my car!
  • Toyota PU 261,000 miles
    Change the oil every 3-5000 miles and its still going strong. No major engine repairs. Changed the timing belt 4 times every 80,000 miles
  • don't let them over service
    you need an air filter, you need a gas filter, you need windshild wipers, you need a tune up, you need your valves cleaned,blah blah blah---tell them you don't have the money--and that solves the problem
  • Oil Change
    I have a 1991 Nissan 300zx, with 83 grand on it. I use a good 100% synthethic with a wix filter and change it once a year or 25,000 which ever comes first, myself. They would have you change it every 2 weeks if they can get away with it, With todays oils, you can go out further than 3000 miles with no harm at all.
  • service manager commission hustlers
    ....look, if you go to your local independent mechanics....you eliminate the bloodsucking service manager on commission...steer clear of greedy dealerships! And you save maybe 50% on all car services.
  • Oil change intervals
    Please don't recommend 3,000 mile oil changes. It is an unnecessary added expense and is ecologically unsound. Just read your owner's manual and ignore your dealer's recommendations (they would be glad to change it every 1,000 miles if you would let them). They would love the additional revenue. Most folks without an "oil minder" computer will find that 6,000 to 7,500 is acceptable with modern oils. My '06 Honda Civic oil minder tells me to change my oil at about 6,000 nearly every time and I drive it pretty hard.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement