advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Jun 27, 2008 -- The 10 cheapest cars to own and operate

While the price of oil has our attention, there's a renewed focus on finding cars that have the best fuel economy. Yet such vehicles are not necessarily the cheapest to own and operate.

For example, hybrids are hot right now. But they're not cheap to own. In fact, Edmunds.com has only 1 hybrid in the Top Ten on a new tally of truly cheap cars. (Editor's note: All picks are 2008 models.)

In addition to standard fuel costs, Edmunds looked at the purchase price; the rate of depreciation; the cost of insurance and more in making its selections. One word of warning: You can't draw any inferences about quality from this list; it only pertains to the raw costs associated with cars.

Without further ado, here are the 10 cheapest cars to own and operate:

1. Chevy Aveo
2. Hyundai Accent
3. Honda Fit
4. Toyota Yaris
5. Honda Civic
6. Nissan Versa
7. Kia Rio
8. Mazda 3
9. Toyota Corolla
10. Honda Civic Hybrid

As you can see, these are all smaller cars. They all get around 30 mpg (composite) for average fuel economy. But their true cost is so much cheaper than most of the hybrids.

Out of this list, several cars also come highly recommended by Consumer Reports. They include the Fit, the Mazda 3, the Versa and the Honda Civic/Honda Civic Hybrid.


Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • Matrix type
    I like the matrix for versatility. What other cars should I check out? I like something around 30 mpg.
  • Home made Biodiesel
    I have a used 2004 VW Golf TDI. I drive 100 miles per day[on my carpool days to drive], and get about 45mpg combined driving. I am interested in making my own fuel. Has anyone tried the method for making biodiesel as advertised at DieselSecret.com ?
  • I bought a Toyota Camry 93 with 81.5k
    3 day ago, but i spend 650 for air cond, I need it a compressor, i paid 2050 for the car, I sold my 2005 ford hybrid, because of the 400.00monthly payment, I lost my job, but at least i sold my car and paid off the car loan, i really hope this car is good for me, i really need a car this one is paid for...and it looks like a 2002 car not a 1993...
  • Chevy Aveo
    Can't say enough great things about this little gem. Great mileage, runs like a dream, and when you fold down the backseat, you have a TON of cargo room.

    Highly recommend!
  • Homesteading
    What are the Pros and Cons to Homesteading ones home.
  • 2008 impala
    I purchased a 08 impala in Dec 07, very happy love the car,lots of room,smooth ride, getting 23 mpg with v6 haven't taken highway trip yet.7500 miles on it.
  • Pontiac G6 gets 40.5 mpg
    No one talks about the Pontiac G6, however, my husband drives his 100 miles each day on I-40 commuting to work and gets 38-41 mpg doing the speed limit. This American car should get more attention. He's had it for 2 years and it hasn't returned to the dealer for any problems. He gets his routine oil changes only.
    Thanks!
  • Cheap and Reliable Cars
    We purchased a new Honda Accord in 1992. 4 cyl 5 speed manual transmission. The car now has approx 140k miles and is now owned by the 3rd generation of our family. We owned it and then one daughter gave it to the other and is now being held for our oldest granddaughter to turn 16. It is good shape mechanically and physicaly.
  • Saturn
    I have a 1996 Saturn SL2 with 145k miles on it. It still get 34 MPG on the highway and 27 City. Great little plastic car. Never have to worry about rust or door dings either!
  • cars
    We bought a used 1990 LS 400 Lexus that had about 50k miles on it. It never gave us any problems. We gave it to our son and before it was totaled in an accident, it had about 400,000 miles on it.
    We bought another 1995 model and we are still driving it. No problems at all with it. These are the most smooth driving trouble free cars! The gas mileage isn't too bad on the road. (It may get close to 30 mpg)
  • Cheapest car to run
    My 2005 Honda Insight - hybrid -
    purchased in 2006 for $17,000
    is getting 48.6 mpg. I like that.
    Ethanol has lowered mileage about 2mpg
    from 50.1 Don't forget the 1985 Chev
    Sprint with its 54 mpg. Loved it.
    I wish I could get another. Three over
    sized cylinders. Quick pick up.
    No problems ever.
  • Kia Spectra
    I travel over the Rockies and through Colorado once or twice a year and never know what rental car I'm getting from the company. Recently I got a Kia Spectra. Not a bad car and was floored by the economy. 41mpg both ways over the mountains and never less than 36 combination in town and interstate mix. Odometer accuracy matched my GPS. I was impressed!
  • Cheapest cars to own
    I was looking over yur list of cheapest cars to own and noticed you don't list any that would be good for a family with a newborn in a carseat or for someone my size of 6'5" and 260 lbs. Do you have some advice for someone like me in this predicament?
  • Looking to purchase a new car.
    My daughter has a 2008 Malibu, loves it, we need a bigger car, thinkging about the Impala, can you tell me what kind of mileage I can expect on this car. thanks, tom leblanc
  • Automobiles
    I recently bought a Ford Fusion. Just went to GA from OK. I got 28mpg and around town I get 24-25mpg. I certainly do not think this is bad considering the price and size of the vehicle.
  • good gas mileage
    Just drove a 2003 Hyundai Elantra GT, automatic trans from Ca. to N.D. total miles round trip 3544. We ave. overall 35.55 miles per gal. Two people with truck full of luggage. Air conditioner working part of the time. We are 68 yrs. old and it was very comfortable. Love my red Hyundai. Its been to N.D. 2 times.
  • fuel mileage, cheap to own cars
    I have a Jeep Liberty diesel. These were only made in 2005-6. I have 70000 problem free miles. I average 26 mpg with loads of power in a safe vehicle. Wish I could buy a Mini Cooper diesel. These cars get 65mpg(US). Diesel is the answer until we are driving with hydrogen,but that is 20 years away!
  • diesels that run on straight vegetable oil
    i have a Mercedes 78 300D diesel that gets 40 mph have been thinking of converting to run on vegetable oil. please look at the web site greasecar.com your view would be greatly valued
  • Honda Cars
    I have owned a Honda vehicle since I bought a 1990 Honda Accord in Feb 1990.
    My son John still drives it in Hagerstown, Md.--it has about 130K on it now.
    We now have a 2000 Honda Oddesey and am now wanting to buy a Honda CRV 2008 with leather,etc. I know that this vehicle is not a particularly gas saving vehicle, but it has HEATED seats, among other amentities.
    You see,I am 85 and my wife is 78 so why not be a little comfortable in our waning years!
    Thanks, Clark for your talk show on radio---I listen all I can.
  • JEEP - it's Cheap
    I own a 1996 Jeep Cherokee Sport - In line 6 engine, stick shift / original clutch - gets 19- 21 miles per gallon- I brought it fairly new and it now has 233,000 miles on it with no rust (had it removed). It runs great (serviced regularly / very low cost maintenance) and I go 25,000 miles per year. Goal is to get 300,000 miles. When you look at real cost of driving (gas, ins, repairs, original cost of car, depre., etc.) I am WAY AHEAD. Hybrid, NO THANKS. Love your show Clark.
  • Back to John
    If I had your car here and plugged it into my house, the electricity would cost the equivalent of $4.27/gal. That is at my current electrical rate. It seems you will be paying less for electricity but what will it cost to pay less. I bought an 04 Prius in 03 an still have it. I have gotten up to 58 mpg during my commute of 40 miles one way. Generally, because of the speed of traffic I get 51 to 53 on the summer blend and down to 44 to 46 on the winter blend. I could purchase a plug in battery for the car thereby fueling the car with approximately 49% coal and 49% oil (yes, throw in about 2% for hydro, wind, stc.) This would save no money since the elect. and the gas cost about the same. Now look up the price of one or both of the plug in Prius batteries I have found so far and tell how much money I have wasted. I would have also cancelled my waranty. I have the feeling that if your new car were to be powered by solar and wind alone, you would need to add bicycle pedals. In any case I would like to hear more about your project.
  • Small cars not that great
    small cars get in wreck, people get killed. Yes you save on gas, so what. I drive a Honda Odyssey and it gets 30mpg hwy and 22 in town.
  • Pick Ups
    Hi there, Any recommendations on an affordable {cheap} pickup. That also gives good gas milage? Thank you.
  • Cheap Cars
    The Japanese car that operates on water was mentioned. It isn't cheap.
    It does, however, run on water catalytically separated into H and O that is recombined in a fuel cell to produce electric power. It does appear to work, but the catalyst has a limited life and could be costly to replace. Bottom line, it aint cheap.
  • Response to Bruce (2)
    I plan to buy a Chevy Volt whenever it is available in 2009 or 2010. This car will operate for at least 40 miles on a plug-in charge. Ninety percent of my daily driving is under 40 miles. Also I have established a company which will supply solar panels & wind turbines to Oklahoma & Oklahoma City homes & businesses. I just received my domain name yesterday. This means I will be able to use sun power & wind power to recharge my car. I will also heat & air condition my home using renewable energy. -- John
  • NOT 10 BEST IF YOU WANT Auto Trans
    The entire Edmunds Report ASSUMES that you'd buy a manual transmission car. This is unfair to some cars (like MOST hybrids) that only come as auto transmission. Edmunds and Clark should do a similar study of cheapest auto transmission cars to operate. Hybrids would do MUCH better.
  • matrix vibe
    Both the toyota matrix and the pontiac vibe are corollas...identical running gear add them to the list
  • Honda Accord Hybrid
    My 2005 V-6 Honda Accord Hybrid gets an overall fuel consumption rate of 30 mpg. That is, from mile 1 to the current mileage of just under 27000 miles, the car averages 30 mpg. The mileage was accrued in highway and local driving, with one to four passengers - mostly two. Comfortable ride; no maintenance problems; great fuel economy. A very satisfied consumer!
  • 10 best autos
    I drive a Chevy HHR. Not only am I getting 30MPG, it is one of the most versitile cars for its size.
  • Honda CR-V
    i GET 15-19 mpg in the city;29mpg on the highway in my 4-cyl small Suv.
    Is this mileage what others get, or did
    I buy a fuel-guzzler? I like the car.
  • Gas efficient trucks
    Anyone know what the cheapest truck is to own & operate? I'm in the market for a 4 seater that will primarily be used for trips in town to work & to sometimes haul small loads.
  • Toyota Avalon
    I have a 2005 Toyota Avalon and get 26 to 29mpg city and 29 to 33mpg on the highway depending how fast I drive. My first foreign car purchase and I love it!
  • water car
    how about running a story on the car the japanese are developing that runs on water???
  • Cheap cars
    Had a 2003 Accent - drove 78 miles one way to work, averaged between 30 - 35 mph depending on speed which was never under 70 and most of the time between 75 and up to 80. Loved it. Sold it to a guy who works with my wife, bought our daughters 2003 prius, the guy and his wife love the accent, he drives that instead of his pickup. My daughter got her 2007 Prius for around $21000. My wife want a new one now, they are fun to drive. Saw a Smart car for sale (Private Party) for $24,000. Why would a person want to squeeze into something like that for 44 mph when they can own a Prius for a lot less, plus have more room and I would think a little safer.
  • 2001 FORD FOCUS
    I bought this car new and have never had a major problem. I get 28 mpg city, and 34 on the highway! It is also fun to drive and seats 4 with comfort.
    Ford Focus should be on this list Clark!
  • Kia Rondo
    For economy (30 mpg on the road - V6 engine), dependability, and (most important to an old lady!) ease of entry, you cannot beat the Kia Rondo. No climbing up to get out (as in those little cars) and no climbing up to get in (as in the SUV's). This car has it all - highly recommended!
  • Chevy Aveo
    I love my 2006 chevy aveo! You know that car commercial where people at the gas station forget which side their gas tank is on? I'm now one
    of those people. When I first bought
    the car, I was concerned about driving around in what I thought was a "cheap looking car" but now i'm driving with confidence knowing I made a smart decision. My opinion is, people should focus less on luxury and more on money. We all know we could use more of it!
  • response to John
    Neither of us will live long enough. I just listened to one of our senators say that oil and coal is making us sick. I live in the north east and dread the cost of heat next winter. I expect many others in my state will suffer house fires, smoke inhalatiion and other serious problems as they attempt to heat their houses by some alternate means. Solar, wind and other new technologies add up to zero right now and will not be heating my house next winter.
  • Honda Fit
    I bought a 2007 Honda Fit last July to replace a gas-guzzling and unreliable Chrysler PT Cruiser. I now have 13,000 miles on it and still absolutely LOVE my Honda Fit!!! I just got back from vacation and I got 42 mpg on the trip! That is phenomenal to me. (I usually average around 30 mpg in city driving, which is also quite good). I highly recommend the Fit for price, reliabilty, comfort and economical upkeep.
  • Cheap Cars
    I drive a 2001 Ford Escape (A first year model that has about 148K miles on it -- Hybrid wasn't available then). I'ts an automatic with a V-6 and 4WD. On a road trip recently I got 37 MPG by driving consistently at 55 mph instead of my usual 65-70. I paid attention and didn't use Overdrive mode as much and kept it in cruise control on long straight stretches, but not in the hills and mountains. Smart driving counts for a lot. However, I'd like to keep "Essie" for trips and get a smaller car for my 30 mile daily round trip commute. However, I'm "one of those" that just hates to buy an obvious made in Japan/Korea car even though I know that most of the parts for my "American" model come from overseas. Essie's been the best car I've ever owned. I get 24-27 mpg on my daily commute.
  • cars
    how about the toyota metric.
  • 10 Cheapest Cars
    I bought my Toyota Camry Hybrid Jan. 2007. While it was an expensive car, I got an exceptional trade in deal and a few dealership benefits thrown in as well. With 34-35 MPG and very low mantenance, I love this car!
  • 2000 Toyota Avalon
    My Avalon has been getting 26 in town and more on the road. However, I was rear-ended last Feb. 2008 by a BMW. My bumper was cracked and scuffed. The BMW front end was crushed. It destroyed the BMW grill, radiator, battery and messed up his air conditioner. He told me it took $4,500 to repair. Safety means a lot to me and I have the pictures to prove my point. So I feel I have both safety and good mileage.
  • 10 cheapest Cars
    You missed the Pontiac Vibe and the Toyota Matrix - same car- 30-31 miles to the gallon on both of them. Have on of each.
  • Cheap Transportation
    Mopeds won't keep you dry and they have a tendency to get squishy under an F150. An Aveo will keep you dry but will break down before you get there...
  • Economy Cars
    Any data for a recommended economical mini suv? I drive a Honda CR-V for the seat comfort...can't handle the low down cars.
  • fuel efficient cars
    I own a 2005 Mercury Montego (large car by today's standards). I get 21 to 23 MPG in town and 31 on road trips. Sure don't have to sacrifice safety in this car to get decent MPG.
  • gas mileage
    I have a 1999 Chevy Venture. It was used when i bought it with 70,000 miles. It has been the best car for me, easy to get into for me and kids. It gets about 20 mpg over all. I drove 1200 miles on vacation,traveled about 58 mph and got a whopping 30.8 mpg (mostly 4-lane).It has 175,000 miles now. It is clean and looks great. I cant see buying a newer car,just for gas mileage.
  • 2007 Aura XR
    Drove this car 3500 miles on vacation last summer. Normal speed from 70 to 75, and the car averaged 27 miles per gallon. Totally loaded car with a great engine, and fun to drive. I will gladly pay the little extra for gas to drive this car. The six speed with manual shift option was great in mountian driving.
  • Mazda 3
    I've owned a Mazda 3 for (exactly) 3 years now and I LOVE it! It's so fun to drive and I'm happy to hear that it's one of the cheapest cars out there. We've not had any maintenance issues with it, gas mileage is very good and the insurance is really cheap. I'd recommend this car to anyone!
  • Response to Bruce
    Bruce wrote: "Electric cars do not run on electricity as a fuel. The electricity is generated almost entirely by burning oil and/or coal. We do not drill into the ground for hydrogen we have to make it by using some other source of enery. Remember cooking water to produce hydrogen and oxygen in high school? Think about this when considering fuels. We also cook oil to make gasoline. It takes energy to produce energy. Even if you are pedalling a bicycle, how many miles do you get per hamburger?"

    My response: Bruce - It is true that currently much of the nation's electrical energy is generated from burning coal. However, hydroelectric power and nuclear power have generated a significant portion of our nation's power for 50+ years. We now have new power sources of solar & wind that are getting more cost competitive. New technologies like mag-lev wind turbines and far more efficient solar panels will make these technologies very competitive at consumer's homes. Imagine refueling your car and air conditioning your home by solar panels on or over your roof and mag-lev wind turbines charging your car at night.

    I think it is OUR collective responsibility to make this happen in our lifetime.
    --- John M Hite, Oklahoma City
  • Cheap Transportation
    Why don't we concentrate on cheap transportation not just cheap cars. I would just as soon ride a moped as a Kia Rio, Chevy Aveo, etc. What America wants is a Suburban that gets 40mpg. I think we can come closer than the above to a compromise of efficiency and comfort.
  • Cars
    For those who are history buffs, they know one of the main reasons why the Japanese are ruling the world in the automotive and electronic fields is due to the treaty they were forced to sign at the end of WW II when they surrendered which limited them in how much money they could spend on defense. Many people in the U.S.A. are lazy and have a backwards attitude when it comes to designing, producing, and selling products. Example: american car manufacturers mentality is short term thinking. They have always thought it to be smarter to produce a cheap quality car that is less expensive which will be more affordable but will mean the car will not hold up as long so that people will buy a new car more often. This thinking though has proven to be faulty. Most americans prefer to own a Japanese car because they are better quality with less mechanical problems and hold their value much longer. The Japanese however have a completely different mentality when it comes to designing and making things. Hence that is why they rule the world in the automotive and electronics world; they make high quality vehicles that last many, many years and charge more for them..but they end up being a better value. Recently Consumer Reports rated the top three cars in the world: #1 was Lexus, #2 was Honda, and #3 was Toyota. When will the American Auto Manufacturers learn their lesson?
  • cheap on gas
    I bought a Ford Escape SUV that gets 25/29. The trick is that my 2008 Escape has a 4 cyl engine and is not 4 wheel drive.

    It is underpowered for interstate speeds and will struggle to maintain 70 mph with 2 adults and cargo on uphill grades.

    But, most of my driving is in and around a semi urban setting and I have plenty of legroom. So. I'm happy with it.
  • Do your homework
    I bought a Chevy Impala-the best I got was 31 MPH. Plenty of room,power,comfort and SAFETY. If I get hit by someone, most likely I will walk away from it.The foriegn cars simply are not what the media, including you, make them out to be.
  • If you think of this countries problems,they began w/ foriegn cars, increased as the car sales increased. Boy, how could we ever turn things around?????duhhhhhh
  • New Car
    Thanks, to Clark and the Team! I'm in the market for a new "cheap" car b/c of a new job that is farther away. So, thanks again for the info.
    P.S. I had already come up with the Yaris as a possibility so it is nice to have some confirmation.
  • Your workplace clothing poll
    Clark! That poll was a little sexist. Inappropriate doesn't just mean too much skin which would relate to female dressing. Male dress problems include - wrinkled clothes, dirty clothes and too casual clothing as well. Love your show but was suprised by that poll ;)
  • Best car deal
    Not everyone can use such a small car. I bought a Chevy Impala, a large car by govt stds, for $16,356 using GM card rewards. This car averages over 20 mpg, near 30 on the highway, has everything power, including power seats and cruise and cost me less than a Toyota Corolla. Clark never mentions the GM card. No annual fee and I have received over $9000 from them for car purchases since 1996.
  • Wanna really be cheap - buy used!
    It was said downthread but is worth repeating - if you really want a cheap to own car, buy used and run them into the ground. Chances are you can do better paying for small repairs than making monthly payments (which is no guarentee of more repairs you'll have to shell out for out of warranty.)
  • VW TDI or Harley
    I moved to the 2006.5 TDI 2 Auto from a Lexus 450. I have a great ride, 45-50 MPG. This beats my 2004 Harley by 3+ MPG. I don't even get wet in Seattle. Oh ya no helmet to boot.
  • Cheap on gas is not always best
    I just bought my friends 05 4dr Toyota Tundra with 28000 miles it gets so far about 24 combined. I stole it from him for 15,500 and it is loaded. Being 6'4 and have 2 kids under 7 a small car is just not practical. BOTTOM LINE DUE THE MATH. I can drive it for 4 years and break even if I had purchased a Camary or Accord and would not have been as comfortable.
  • Vibe
    Hi bought the Pontica Vibe (the Toyota Matrix's twin) because it was less expensive. I get about 28mpg in town and 32mpg on the road. I expected better.
  • Safety
    Hi: I understand our gas problem but my family's safety comes first. Go with a larger car with a little less gas mileage. The middle path might bring them home alive. To many crazy people driving the big cars.
  • recommended cars
    I bought a Toyota Matrix (really a Corolla) and love it! Easily get 30mpg in town, more on hwy. It's comfortable and a pleasure to drive. Fold down the backseat and carry almost anything.
  • Truly Cheap Cars
    Thank you for telling me, this. I do need to, eventually get antoher car. Is it possible to get a maadsa 3 with automatic transmission, second hand?
  • Crown Vic
    I have a 2002 Crown Victoria V-8 that gets 15 mpg in town and 23 on the highway. I find that hard to beat. I have never had any major repairs needed, and I admit I'm not very good at routine maintanence. I am very tall with long legs and I've never been more comfortable. I fill my tank about every 2 weeks. Let's see you beat that. Oh, and no payments for the last 3 years. I plan on keeping it as long as possible. I wouldn't get any value as a trade-in now anyway.So Ill drive it til it falls apart and see what's around then.
  • Trust
    Hi Clark,
    Although I don't listen to your show as often as I would like to, the one thing I like about you is that I trust you. I really feel like you are on my side. Thanks for being there.
    God Bless
    John
  • Minivan
    My wife has a 1999 Dodge Caravan. I took it on a trip last month and got 28 mpg highway. She is wanting another vehicle so I will probably keep hers.
  • My 1995 Grand AM
    My car has 176,000 and still runs great. My friends get mad at me when I tell them by little 13 year old car is paid for and gets 26-32 mpg and thier new ones get only 15-24mpg. You could not pay me to take another car. the thing that gets me is that some younger folks today don't relize that a little oil and time not will save you thouhsands down the road. I have riden in a Malibu and will probably get one for my next car.
  • ML320
    My wife's ML320 has 185,000 miles on it and runs like a dream. Gets 21 mpg on the hwy and 18 in town. As long as this keeps on humming, we won't be changing cars.
  • fuel mileage and alternate fuels
    Electric cars do not run on electricity as a fuel. The electricity is generated almost entirely by burning oil and/or coal. We do not drill into the ground for hydrogen we have to make it by using some other source of enery. Remember cooking water to produce hydrogen and oxygen in high school? Think about this when considering fuels. We also cook oil to make gasoline. It takes energy to produce energy. Even if you are pedalling a bicycle, how many miles do you get per hamburger?
  • Ford Fusion
    Ford's best kept secret. I own a 2008 Ford Fusion and have been getting 29 mpg combined mileage. It's a solid car, rides great, and fits four comfortably.

    It also gets a top rating from Consumer Reports. If you are looking for a solid vehicle consider the fusion!
  • Cheap Cars to own and run
    Add the Toyota Scion -- mine averages 33 mpg, sometimes up to 37 - tho occasionally only 30. Pretty good for a boxy but surprisingly roomy small car.
  • Honda Civic
    A friend's grandson has the Civic (a couple of years old) and gets 47-49mpg.He drives alot for his job and used the time to discover the best mph for max mpg.He drives 62mph on the highway while others pass him by he puts money in the bank.
  • Ford Focus
    I bought my 08 focus for 12,600 after rebates. On edmunds they use price of $17000. I get 35 mpg consistantly and am very happy with the focus. I think it would be high on this list if they figured in a sale price in the 12k's
  • Pontiac Vibe
    My vibe (a standard, not an automatic) I bought for about 18k... I get over 30mpg in the city with it.

    I found it on www.fueleconomy.gov (where they list the best and worst of each class of car.

    People need to get over the jap car thing... If they vote with their dollars, maybe American Auto manufacturers will start producing good, efficient cars for a change.
  • Malibu - A car never mentioned
    I am on my 2nd Chevrolet Malibu. It is a 2005 with 37k miles on it. On a level freeway at 70-75 mph this car gets 35 mpg. It has a V-6 engine. It was cheaper to buy than those listed here and requires only routine maint. It is also larger than the Civics, Corollas etc. Why this car is rarely mentioned in reviews is a mystery to me. I love it. A much better car than some of the sardine cans on wheels.
  • 10 Cheapest cars
    The cars on the list are truly cheap to
    purchase and fuel effecient but putting
    a 6 foot 70+ year old frame into one for an hour long drive defeats the cheap. Those cracer boxes are a no-no for seniors.
  • Ford Escape
    You are "hung up", and have wasted a lot of time pushing those Jap cars. Have you ever sat in a Ford Focus or a
    Ford Escape or the Hybrid. Did you know FORD has an operational Hydrogen
    Car and Truck? Why do you think that for the past Thirty Years that the Ford F150 is the largest selling vehicle in the world. You should get out of that shell or closet you are hiding in. One reason Ford Trucks sell
    is GM trucks have the highest frequency of repairs, although some improvement has been in effect the past Three Years. Toyota truck has already had Three major recalls.
  • AUTOS
    First of all I will not own a Jap auto
    My daughter has a 2002 FORD FOCUS 137,543 original engine we spent $212.66 on air condition, brakes tires
    and notmal routine maintainence costs
    the car gets 27 mpg in town. I have a
    Town Car 2002 105,234 miles on the Intrstates I ca get 27+ miles per gallon, with all the luxury and comfort
    Ford provides road aervice at no cost, of course I have never needed it. you get involved in a wreck with one of your little Jap cars, have your aid call me I will send you a symphany card in the Hospital. You have never been more wrong. I am over Eighty, WW1
    vet, Never a Jap car if it get 200 MPG
  • Need a bit bigger car but quality at a good price
    Try the Honda Element - fantastic storage capacity, seats 4 comfortably, can get one for $20K and runs about 26 MPG. Also, the Honda CRV, is very comparable to the Honda Element.
  • hybrids
    we are on our 3rd hybrid.started with a honda insightwhich average 66mpg (amazing in hilly vermont). was hit at 50mph by a corolla and totally protected the driver. our 1st civic hybid met the same fate with the same results and average mgp of 46. our current civic hybrid also average 46mph and we love it. we have 150,000 miles of hybrid experience and are strong believers. I don't understand how consumer reports managed to get such poor mileage in their tests when we do so well in a hilly state like ours.
  • hot cars
    We bought a 2008 Civic in March (not a hybrid) MGP ranged from 32-39 so far!!! Very pleased. Replaced a 2004 Matrix that was getting 26 mpg.
  • small "light duty trucks"
    When is an auto maker going to figure the average home owner DOSEN'T need a gas guzzling truck? my 'little' `96 Nissan gets a mere 18 mpg and rarely gets driven. I want a truck to take light loads to the dump or recycling center, not made to haul a ton of junk!
  • Prius
    I would like to know in what city the THIEF is that charges a premium for a Prius. And it's wrong to compare a Prius cost with a non-hybrid. My 2004 Prius was purchased, new, for $19995 (base sticker)
  • A new car every 3 years or every 10 years.
    Buying a new car about every three years will cost you even more. Buying a car about every ten years will save you about $500,000 in interest over your life time.
  • KIA Rondo
    Rented a KIA Rondo for a trip Averaged 31 MPG, V6 Auto, it comes in a 4 Cyl. 100,000 mile warranty, Low price. I have owned 3 KIA's no problems wit any one of them.
  • prius real costs
    friend bought a Prius, selling price was $7500 above M.S.R.P. not negotable. have to factor that in
  • VW Jetta TDI
    It seems that the diesel vehicles are left out of the MPG lists, and I don't understand why. I bought a 2000 VW TDI in 2004 for $9,000 with 85,000 miles. It runs like a dream, the seating is comfortable, has plenty of pep, with the folding rear seat I can carry more than a dozen 2X4X8 studs with the trunk lid closed. With 5 speed stick shift I consistently average 50 MPG, and on long highway trips have averaged 53 MPG. I do almost all of my own mechanical work and it is not a difficult vehicle to work on. Very little has had to be done outside regular oil changes (3,000 miles). This same engine was used in the Golf and the Passat. While the cost of diesel is higher than regular gas, the fuel mileage of the diesel more than offsets the cost difference, and the expected life of the engine is probably twice that of a gas engine. The VW diesel is an overlooked engine in the U.S. market. In Europe almost 50% of the cars on the road are diesel.
  • Mini Van
    I drive a 1997 V6 Plymouth Voyager I bought new. It has maintained a 24 to 27 mpg, and has never caused any problems and has 130K miles. Only on the second set of tires, with only preventive maintenance costs for upkeep. My point, if I buy a new car with less room and get only 5 to 10 mpg more, how long will it take for me to break even after a purchase price at around $12000? Someday I will be forced to make a change, but hope things will improve. It is a helpless feelings to fuel my van at today's costs. I have cut back on travel as much as possible and did cancel my trip for this year.
  • Operating cost for Hybrid Autos
    In addition to hybrid autos costing more to purchase, I have not heard or seen anybody address the cost of replacing the batteries down the road. At some point they are going to ware out and I don't think they are going to cheap to replace. Nobody seems to be factoring in this cost.
  • My Acura Integra
    Talking about champion cheapskates: How about me and my 1990 Acura Integra. At first I was using to the tune of 20000 miles per year. I have averaged down to a point where I now have 194000 miles on it. And all the time I have averaged 26-31 miles per hour, more in the summer of course. I would take the Acura over even the Mercedes (which I had two of for 9 years each) 300SD and 280E. The cost of service is so much less than Mercedes. And less frequently.
  • Fuel economy
    Here is a proposal that might solve the world's oil crisis and the U.S. balance of trade & balance of payment deficits.

    Two of the world's biggest battery companies (one being Toshiba & the other being one of the 2 companies GM is evaluating for the battery of the Chevy Volt, I think I read it was CPI/LG Chemical) are now claiming that they can produce batteries with 5 minute recharge time using 110 volt/240 volt standard electricity that can allow a car to travel 300 miles on a single charge (such a distance probably would require several batteries).

    If this is true, the world needs to mandate that EVERY GASOLINE powered car & truck built from now on be plug-in vehicles capable of at least 40 miles on a plug in charge. (If batteries can go 300 miles on a 5 minute plug in, we really don't need the gasoline engine at all.) The fuel cost of electric vehicles are 2 cents per mile versus 17 cents a mile for cars powered by gasoline at $3.00 per gallon. (I got that price per mile info from a Congressional energy crisis hearing chaired by Rep Markey of Massachusetts on June 12th, 2008 that was aired on CNN's live daily internet video feeds).

    We need to require all future vehicles to list on the EPA sticker both the distance the vehicle can travel on a single plug-in battery charge and also the life expectancy of the car's battery. We probably should also make battery replacement easy enough for customers to do it (like a tire change).

    There are 4 technologies I can think of that don't require ANY imported oil: all electric vehicles, compressed air vehicles, CNG vehicles, and hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. All are viable alternatives to gasoline powered vehicles.

    Hopefully what I have read is true & the entire world acts on mandating plug-in hybrids or other alternative fuel cars & trucks immediately!
  • VW disel
    I now own my 4 th VW diesel ( a used `06 Jetta ). Great performance , high 40 MPG in Atlanta traffic, 50 on the highway ( 54+ on atrip to Iowa ), all have been exceedingly reliable, and I expect to drive it for the next 300,000 miles. Hybrids - why?
  • Toyota Carolla
    Back around Christmas time my old car blew up and I was forced to get a new one before I was psychologically ready. I wanted to bo used. My wife knew a guy at the Toyota dealer. They had a pretty good deal going on Carollas and, against my better (?) judgment we bought an '08. I was sure it would be too small for me. But after 7 months I now know why this is th most popular car in the world. With a 50 mile daily commute in mixed driving, I consistently get 32 miles. Still haven't got it on the highway yet and I can't wait. The ride is good. Seating is comfortable. I love the elegant simplicity of the controls and the car in general. Morale of this story - I need to listen to my wife more.
  • Jetta TDI
    I have an '04 VW Jetta TDI. Even with the AT (the manual gets better mileage) I get 36-38 mpg in the city and 52 on the hwy (if I keep it at 65). I bought it new, and, other than having the oil changed (religiously every 5,000 miles), I have only had to have 1 circuit replaced (about $200). Insurance cost is inexpensive, and depreciation is nominal on this car (it has only depreciated about $5,000 since I bought it almost 5 years ago). I find it extremely hard to believe that the TDI did not make the list.....maybe they didn't look at diesels. Like the previous Jetta owner, I also have a motorcycle - it's of the larger variety (1584 cc) and it still gets roughly the same mileage as my Jetta.
  • Honda Fit
    I've had my Fit for two years now and am extremely happy with it. Overall mileage is 37. It is the Sport with automatic. Paid 15750 including taxes and prep. Fun to drive, very quick and comfortable with plenty of room. The back seats fold down flat, both or either one. Has a great sound system and plug-in for your Ipod and will play MP-3's. I think they are a bit hard to find however.I had to wait 6 weeks to find one and took a color other than my desired one.
  • a cheap family car
    In response to Nancy~I'm with you! I have an 89 volvo wagon and with the little jump seats in the back I can seat 7 although two of my passengers need to be little guys. It has been cheap to operate and even though it is a big boat I average 35 mpg. I have had Toyota's also and love them but needed more space than the little wagon I had provided.
  • Toyota Corolla
    So glad to see the Corolla in the top ten. I have a 1994 model that, in addition to gas (very good milage), has only cost an average of about $ 400.00 per year for maintenance, repairs, tires and upkeep for the 14 years that I have owned it. And it is still a good looking car!!
  • Honda Civic Hybrid
    Goodafternoon Clark, Thank you for confirming my purchase of a new Honda Civic Hybrid in 2005. I enjoy between 38-48 MPG depending on highway/in town. I ride my bike or walk to work as I only live approx 1 mile from my workplace. Thank you for all you do, Clark.
  • VW diesel or motorcycle
    We have an '04 VW Jetta diesel and we average 43mpg. I commute to work by motorcycle. My 1995 Suzuki DR350 gets up to 64mpg. We own 6 motorcycles which range between 40-74mpg.
  • 2000 Avalon XLS
    Bought it brand new. Best car I have ever own. No troubles since I got it.
  • 10 Cheapest Cars to Own and Operate
    Gas mileage sounds good, but as you say they are all smaller cars, and not practical if you have several children. How about listing the 10 Cheapest Cars for Families to Own and Operate?
  • Civic Hybrid
    My husband and I both drive over 100 miles a day each, and we share our civic hybridand use it 7 days a week.
    Between the obvious gas savings, the savings on depreciation on our other cars is tremendous. I wish we had more than one Civic hybrid.
  • Buick Park Ave
    My wife has a 1996 Park Ave with 167,000 miles. It has consistantly gotten between 29 & 31 mpg on the interstate depending on speed, AC, terrain, etc. Got 33 mpg one trip. Gets between 18 & 21 mpg in town. Even spending a $1,000 a year on repairs makes it still cheaper than a new one. as long as it gets those mpg I will keep repairing and maintaining it.
  • Economics 101
    I agree with Clark most of the time. I bought my last new car, a Rabbit, in 1982. I now buy used cars from individuals. I have owned some outstanding vehicles, mainly because I didn't go looking for a certian car, but for a deal. I have owned a 74 AMC Ambassador, 76 & 83 Rabbits, 88 Bonneville V6 (oustanding!), 90 & 96 cavaliers (at the bottom of the reliability scale), 95 & 98 Civics and 88 & 96 Caravans. Overall I would say, if your car still runs good, keep it. Some people are caught up in a car being a status symbol and not transportation.
  • Daimler's smart car
    The smart car from Daimler is the most fuel efficient gasoline engine automobile available in the U.S.
  • economical and very comfortable
    We own a 2002 Toyota Camry XLS (4 cyl). It is the most comfortable car we have ever had and we get 37 mpg on the highway and about 30 in town. How can you beat that? It has great get-up-and-go. We have had no repairs. And we have heard that at the time we bought it, it was the most "American" made car on the market. We are amazed when other cars advertise that they get 30 mpg. on highway. We laugh at that.
    We have owned Japanese or German cars for the last 28 years, but this is the best car we have ever owned. When we rent "American" cars on vacation, we are always amazed at some of the "stupid" features on them.
  • Cheap Car
    Bought 09 Hyundai Sonata was cheaper than Civic EXL plus Has power seat VSC, Sat Radio can't even get on a Honda
  • 1998 Nissan Sentra
    I have a 10-year old Nissan Sentra with 135k miles that gets about 38 mpg. It's plenty comfortable for me, accelerates quickly and smoothly and has given me almost no problems throughout its life. It amazes me that today's economy cars and even some hybrids can't get the same fuel mileage as my 10 year old $13,000 car does. I hope it lasts me another 10+ years.
  • chevy impala
    we just drove a new chevy impala across country and got 30 mpg !!
    a little more spacious than these models!
  • Camry still great!
    My '97 Camry 4-banger consistently gets 31 mpg on my 76-mile daily commute and has had no serious malfunctions.
  • "american" cars
    American technology is way behind. You should also know that "american" doesn't necessarily mean "american" and vice versa. Do some checking. A great deal of so-called "american" vehicles come down the same assembly line as the "foreign" models. Example: Toyota Matrix and Pontiac Vibe. Several GM models are manufactured alongside Suzuki in Canada. More "american made" are manufactured in Mexico. Meanwhile, many of the "foreign" models are manufactured right here! Alabama has the Hyundai Santa Fe and Sonata in Montgomery; also a Mercedes and Toyota plant. I had a Lincoln LS - what a pain it was! When something broke, it cost way too much to repair. No more GM/Ford/Chysler products for me!
  • Depreciation
    I see a lot of people posting here who have driven their current cars into the ground. By doing this, they have eliminated the importance of the depreciation component. I wonder what this list would look like without depreciation as a factor.
  • Cars
    I have a Nissan Altama with the 2.5 engine and it get 28 to 30 and is full size, rides smooth, is very comfortable.
  • Hybrid
    Clark, when you buy a hybrid that gets better gas mileage, you might pay more initially to Honda, Toyota or Ford but that is better than paying that money to foreign countries that hate America. Every dollar that leaves the USA and goes to the Middle East or Venezuala is a dollar that could potentially used to harm Americans and finance their hate of the West. I would rather put an extra $3000 into Ford today and get my payback over the next 10 years than to buy a cheaper car and put money into OPEC for the next 10 years.
  • comfort
    I own a 2003 Buick century and get about 28 mpg city and 33 mpg highway and don't have to drive 500 miles and be carried out of the car when I get there. Buicks offer great comfort and dependability. I have over 150,000 miles and have only had 1 head gasket replaced $500 dollars and have had no other expenses. I do change the oil every 3,000 miles.
  • Cheapest to own
    I agree. The Checy Aveo has been the cheapest car to own. I've owned one for over 2.5 years and haven't spent a dime on it except for oil & filter changes changes and a new set of tires.

    The only thing that's been wrong from the beginning is the speedometer which reads about 10% too fast until about 50, then stays about 5 MPH fast. Fuel economy went from an astounding 36.7 mpg on the hwy to 28.9 with 10% ethanol (which is all I can get now)
  • buy a bug!!!
    I drive a turbo diesel and get 60 miles to the gallon - why drive a hybrid when the diesel has been a proven engine forever...
  • S -10 Pick-up
    We have a 1989 S-10 pick-up that has been running fine until lately. It has a rear main seal leak. We are going to sale. We feel we got our money's worth.
  • Best cars for under $20000
    the mazda 3 is a phenomenal 4dr sedan, with a great track record, great looks!!!
  • Lots of room
    Also wanted to add. I am 6'5" and fit very comfortably in the Versa and there is room for someone my size to sit behind my seat.
  • Versa
    I just bought a Versa, this is my second Nissan, my first being a 2003 Altima. When I traded it in with 153k miles on it, it was going strong. So far the Versa has been right at 25mpg city and I am getting ready to do the highway test to see if it gets the 30mpg advertised.
  • Best Way to Save on Gas
    If you really want to save, buy a 4-7 yr old economical used car for under 4000 cash. Drive it till it dies.
  • Corolla
    Corolla is not cheap on gas as advertised, I have two, 2005 and 2007. You will be lucky to get 26 MPG unless you are on the hwyway or in Florida. If gas stays around $4 the cheap cost of the corolla would still be economical to drive. Around $5 a gal buy a previa.
  • 30 mpg in a 1993 v6
    i have a 1993 olds cutlass ciera with a v6 and get an average of 30mpg (best ever was nearly 33mpg). my recommendation to someone looking for a car that gets better gas mileage is to do some research and get an older used car. even if the old clunker needs some major repairs, it's not going to set you back $12,000+.
  • Cheap to own cars
    It's no wonder the Smart 4-2 does not make the list. I'm not sure why anyone would want one. The Honda Fit is, cheaper, gets better gas mileage, and has room for passengers and stuff that the 4-2 does not.
  • 1995 Ford Escort
    With my small 1.9 Liter standard (manual) transmission 4-cylinder engine I average 33 MPG in the city and 45 mpg on the highway. I paid $600 for this car and have placed another $2,000 in repairs (including a new transmission and 4 tires)and upgrades over the last year. Haven't seen a reason cost-wise to want to trade my Ugly Duckling in (needs a serious paint job. Low insurance costs ($35 a month), low personal property taxes ($25 annually)and great gas mileage.
  • Used Buick Le Sabres & Park Ave's
    Clark, you should do a cheap to own, used car segment. A Buick Le Sabre or Park Ave, with low miles can be bought for 1/3 rd of the price of any of the cars listed above, and will average 32+ mpg!
  • Mazda 5
    Clark, I just bought a Mazda 5. I think this is the most overlooked car around. It sells for around $20,000; and we got 30 miles per gallon when we rented one last summer. Most of all, it has a third row of seats. I don't know of any other small, and cheap, car that has this. I call it a mini mini-van. A lot of people can no longer afford a full size mini-van.
  • Not a comfortable car among these
    A couple of years ago we were looking for a car and looked at each and every one of these cars on the list of top 10 and not one was comfortable for tall people. I am 6'2 and wanted something with room in the back seat as well as the front and none of these cars fit the bill barring the Scion XB(now #8 on new list) which drove like a bus(could be better now). Possibly the Honda Civic just bareeely fit the bill but being a long time Honda fan I truely couldn't believe how much I hated their redesign.
    We finally wound up with the Toyota Prius just based on love it factor which had plenty of room up front and in back and drives like a absolute dream(I swear test drive one). We got it when there still eligible for the full $3400 tax credit witch brings the cost per mile way down and got it when the demand was not so high at a much lower price.
    We think we have the best car on the road and driving is never boring.
    Take what you want from this I'm just saying you want to be comfortable driving as well as get low OO cost whichever car that may be.
  • To me 30mpg is not that great for those small cars. My 2004 Monte Carlo SS, 3.8 v-6 gets 27mpg. Those little four bangers have to work harder to go 55 to 65 mph when a V-6 isn't even trying hard.
  • economy cars
    i have gone round and round with my brother on this subject. he crows about getting about 32 mpg with his overpriced hybrid ford escape. if he had calculated the true cost of ownership including depreciation, loan interest, insurance and fuel economy he would have been far ahead keeping his paid off 4 year old 18mpg ford explorer. hybrids sell for list or more. non-hybrids sell for huge discounts to list and many have rebates to boot. but who am i to say this? oh!, just a millionaire, much in the flavor of your humble clark. Current hybrid technology is a joke.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement