advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

Jun 10, 2008 -- Scandinavia's vouchers for education, elder care

Clark recently created a stir when he spoke about the Finnish educational system. Finland has the world's highest achieving students. Teachers are treated as entrepreneurs in the classroom and can teach whatever they want. There's little emphasis on standardized testing, and there's no state-controlled curriculum.

In fact, they're a great example of free enterprise in the education field. What makes it odd, however, is that Finland has a long socialist background!

The equally socialist Sweden is also letting the free market work in their schools. They've adopted vouchers. Sweden's voucher system allows parents to opt out of the public schools and send their kids to private school regardless of family income.

The Financial Times of London reports Sweden is now planning to institute a voucher system for the elderly seeking nursing homes. Once again, the elderly will be able to shop for basic long-term care regardless of income.

The United States is supposed to be a beacon for free enterprise. Yet free enterprise stops at the door whenever it comes to something that government gets involved in -- like education and healthcare.

We need to reinvigorate how we spend our tax dollars. It doesn't matter if you don't have children or elders; it's still coming out of every paycheck. Clark is a dyed-in-the-wool capitalist, but he thinks we need to follow the lead of socialist Sweden and Finland on these points.


Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

Add your comment

Security Image * Please enter the code shown at left
what's this?

What others are saying

  • Public Schools are Best
    Clark,

    I love you, but I heard your rant about our Soviet-style education system...just now. I got so upset I almost had to pull over.

    I'm not a teacher. I taught for two years and it didn't suit me. However, the experience made me respect and value U.S. public schools and teachers. I attended public school... as most of us do. No one in my immediate family attended a particularly good public school but our rural Missouri schools got us launched o.k.

    I think you are not taking into account huge factors that set our U.S. culture apart from many other modern countries. The U.S. has ghettos, non-English speakers, barely English speakers, and rural poor... a lot of uneducated people. I don't think our culture can be compared to Scandinavian cultures. Sure those kids can stay home and "be kids" 'til they're seven... and benefit from it! I'm certain that a huge percent of them have well-educated parents... also their parents have a lot more benefits, of many kinds, to help with raising a family.

    There are many problems in the U.S. culture. Poverty is the biggest one.

    I've met home-schooled people. Sometimes every other sentence is we need to "pray" about this, "we need your prayers" about that... Prayer is fine but the real world requires a problem-solving attitude. Home schooling is often about indoctrination and control, and not about inspiring creativity.

    I don't think charter schools are bad, and I don't necessarily want home schooling to be outlawed. (I just heard about the CA ruling today... listening to the repeat of your March show.) Vouchers may be the answer for nursing home choice and to address other problems, but they won't help the typical American child who happens to live in one of our less-than-great public school districts.

    It's going to take more attention to the poor-performing schools... and not One Child Left Behind-type attention.

    For one thing, it's going to take elimination of the U.S. culture of poverty, crime, drug abuse, and ignorance. People who are in the nice neighborhoods with good schools need to help their fellow Americans. Lift them up. Improve the public schools.

    Education vouchers will make American education about religion.. and about business... and that's not good either... because American corporations have gone haywire. I don't want greedy, unscrupulous people in charge of U.S. education. We don't need it outsourced. We need it improved.

    I have a LOT more to say on this topic, but my lunch hour is over so I must end my rant.

    I still love you...

    Please, leave the dark side and become part of the solution...

    Gail Howell
    Greensboro, NC
  • Scandinavia taxes
    After adding up taxes we pay and getting to over 40% w/o even finishing, I think I would rather pay the 40% to 60% they pay, get all the services they do and lead the carefree, happy life that they enjoy. There are so many hidden taxes we pay--w/o much service--mostly going to our greedy gov't. that it would be a relief to enjoy their carefree lifestyle. No wonder Denmark is the happiest country in the world!
  • vouchers
    I wonder if the vouchers in Sweden and Finland apply only to variable cost savings per child (e.g. desk, paper)or if fixed costs (e.g. building maintenance, staff) are taken from the school and included in the amount of the vouchers as well?
  • no true competition
    the main problem with k-12 education is the lack of competition. give every parent vouchers to send their kids to virtually any school they want. and then our current soviet style monopoly, union dominated public school systems will have to compete.

    on healthcare. allow anyone to buy into medicare at cost. mandate everyone has to have at minimum a catastrophic policy. those with no coverage for themselves or their dependents on their own or thru their employer would be subject to a mandatory payroll tax to pay for it. This would require all u.s. citizens to have a tamperproof medical i.d. card from birth tied to a national realtime data base that employers would be required to register their employees to and health insurance companies required to report active/inactive status to this database. It could work if done right.
  • college student loan
    i been in school 24yrs. ago and i paid my loan in full after all this years now they find out my loan was,t paid i do have proof with all my payments in copies but they said they not acceptable,can you please give some advise what to do?
    thanks
    sincerly ,,Mariana Dumitriu
  • Children and bearing the cost of raising them
    Here's a radical idea: Parents should bear the costs of feeding, clothing, sheltering, and educating their own children. If families, friends, and private charities choose to help them voluntarily, no problem. But using the "government as middleman/thug" to force others to fund the costs of your bringing children into the world? *That* is selfish.
  • "free" education
    In a "free" country, taxpayers wouldn't be forced to pay for everyone else's education and healthcare, vouchers or not, to buy votes from gullible parasites for socialist politicians. Can't pay? No problem - that's what voluntary charity and help from extended families is for, right? Check your copy of U.S. Constitution.
  • Finland's education system
    You neglect to mention that Finland has free education for all its students, including college, as well as a health system for its citizens that is not dependent on the greedy insurance companies and pharmaceutical
    companies which control and siphon off their profits from the system here.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement