Clarkhoward Home

Mon-Fri 1-4pm ET
Stations near you | help

Video Minute Archives
Daily Audio Archives
Rip-off Alerts
Call of the Week

Today's Show Notes
Previous Show Notes
Clark's Greatest Hits
Free and Cheap

Ask Team Clark
Call 10am-7pm ET
(404) 892-8227

Member Center
Blogs
Newsletters
Message boards
Meet the Team

Appearances
Books
Photos
TV
Talk to Clark 1-4pm ET:
(877) 87-CLARK or
(404) 872-0750

Advertisement
Ask Clark  Looking for something on the site? Search for it here!  Also see Clark's Greatest Hits
help

May 29, 2008 -- Debating the role of Big Apple food police

The city of New York requires chain restaurants to post calorie counts by every item on their menus. Recently, it was big news when 5 restaurants were cited for not following this protocol.

This is one issue that galvanizes people to no end.

On the one hand, Clark applauds restaurateurs for having the marketing savvy to spotlight healthy choices on their menu. But if someone orders fettucini alfredo, isn't it self-evident that the meal will be a heart attack on a plate, as some cardiologists might say?

Meanwhile, there's a disturbing connection between education level and weight issues. The less education you have, the heavier you'll tend to be. Yet if you go back to the Renaissance, the wealthy (and educated) were the ones who grew fat, as we can see from portraits of the period. The poor, meanwhile, had to deal with the possibility of starvation and famine.

Today, access to food is not an issue; it's the quality of what we eat that's become the concern. Go in to any convenience store in a lower-income area and you'll see a variety of unhealthy food choices available.

This, unfortunately, is not a problem that can be addressed by putting calorie counts on menus.


Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Add your comment

Security Image * Please enter the code shown at left
what's this?

What others are saying

  • I HATE THIS IDEA
    When I go to a resturant, I do not want to know how many calories I am eating. That would ruin the whole dining experience. Horrible idea!!
  • Cook at home
    If you are so concerned about your weight and calories, cook at home. You will know what exactly went into it. I do not want the government to step in to tell me how good/bad the food I am eating is. I go to a restaurant for a change from home cooked food and I want it to be tasty and I don't care too much about how healthy it is.
  • Eat what you want
    If caloric intake is an issue for you then know what you are eating. If you are concerned then it is your responsibility to know or find out and not the city/state to regulate. Sorry but this is NOT an area that government is needed.
  • Food Police
    I too love that the City of New York requires chain restaurants to post calorie counts next to items on the menu. I think this is a great idea because sometimes the calories in a food are not that evident as in fettucine alfredo. I recently ate at a popular sandwich/soup/salad chain and was astonished after reading in a small pamphlet that the store had about the nutritional value of their foods. The basic turkey sandwich without cheese I was about to order had a ton of calories, mainly from the chipotle mayo that it comes with! The calorie count was 970 for a simple sandwich! I would have never thought that it would have that many calories, even with mayo accounted for.
  • Food Police
    I LOVE that they are doing this. I wish they would do that here in Wisconsin!
    So many people come to the doctor's office I work at complaining about their weight and not understanding why they just can't take it off. We need to help them wake up and see why.

    I am very concious of what I eat and I don't always know how much something is 'good' for me or not. Especially at a new resturant. I would love for the calories to be posted for everyone to wake up and make educated choices, stop buying 'junk' just becasue it is what they are used to.
    Just like I compare foods at the store, thanks to that handy nutrition label on the box/bag.
  • food police
    For people who care about their health (and weight), they don't need the calorie values on the menus, because they already know what is healthy. The others will not pay attention to the calorie values anyway, so in the end it helps no one. I don't think less education leads to being overweight. I think both lower education and higher weight is due to some people's lack of motivation/hard work/discipline to improve their lives.

Advertisement


This week's poll
Do you like the idea of auto insurers switching to a pay-as-you-drive model -- where how, when and where you drive may be monitored?
Yes, I'm all for any approach that can save me money.
No, it's too much like having Big Brother in the back seat.
I'm not sure. I'd like the savings, but I don't know if I'd feel comfortable being monitored.
see previous polls


Advertisement