advertisement
Looking for something on the site? Search for it here! Also see Clark's Greatest Hits

May 22, 2008 -- Test your tap water on the cheap

After years of Clark's prodding, Christa has finally made the switch from bottled water to tap water. What finally made her cross over from the dark side? She got hold of the Watersafe All-In-One Test Kit at Whole Foods.

For just about $20, she was able to test her family's tap water for bacteria, lead, pesticides, nitrates, nitrites, chlorine, pH and hardness. Well, the water passed with flying colors, and her brood has been drinking from the tap ever since.

Bottled water will run you about $1,400/year, not to mention that it's an environmental disaster because of all the plastic. That price alone is about 1,000 times what tap water costs! Meanwhile, 1 in 3 brands are just filtered municipal water, which is essentially glorified tap water. So why pay all the extra dough? Try a home-testing kit if you're still concerned about safety.


Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • Not a secure site
    I went to this webpage and was going to order a kit but saw that there was no lock on the page indicating that the site was secure so I did not order. Is this a safe place to order from? Why do they not have a secure site?
  • Bottled Water
    You complain about the cost of gas which runs your car, but no one complains about the cost of bottled water which you can get free from your tap!
  • Test your tap water on the cheap
    Cheap is right! Don't expect anything you will learn something about. Instead contact your wAter supplier who does in depth testing and is scrutinized by the FDA and your local and State governments. Check their web site too.
    If you have a Well, look up your State's or County's Agricultral Experimental Station's phone or address in your Phone Book, or call 411 (1411) and ask for it there. Also, you can check the Internet, your Local Library, or call your Local Government Authorities, for your local A.I.S.
  • Water Filters
    HOT OFF THE PRESS!! Consumer Reports May 2008 issue gives test results and ratings for 27 different water filters of various types. You can usually find a copy at your local public library.
  • Tap water is yucky
    I’ve heard Clark praise how the fluoridation of tap water has reduced cavities in the overall population.

    Trace D. Farley, in "Distilled Water" below, talks about the favorable correlation between "hardest water" (in tap water) and lowest rates of heart attack.

    "The problem is that it will actually act like a magnet and leach minerals out of your body and cause sever mineral depletion over many years." OK. Which spring water company do you work for? Do you ever do any research beyond your company’s promotional materials?

    The reason these additives cause the improvements that they do is because there are so many children and adults who are just not brushing their teeth, especially at night. And our diets are overall so bad. Make your kids and yourself brush their/your teeth at least a couple of times a day and eat a few more fresh and lightly cooked vegetables and the minerals in your tap water will probably have little extra measurable benefit.

    Christa! Christa! Rethink your choice!

    Did Farley read the sites he/she linked?
    The first article discussed the possibility of an effect given “the average North American diet”, which is pretty obviously vitamin and mineral deficient.
    The second link’s official summary is “Hard water is not a health hazard, but dealing with hard water in the home can be a nuisance…..Water hardness can be managed with powdered or liquid water softeners or….”
    The third link includes the lukewarm “Couple this with the fact that many of today’s refined foods are low in magnesium, that many people in developed countries either do not cover or only barely cover their magnesium needs…..and you can see how [even the relatively small] extra supply of this mineral to people in hard-water areas COULD be beneficial”, and “The available evidence suggests these ranges could be beneficial, and….there is no evidence that harder water causes any harm,”

    The minerals that are available, especially in "hard" tapwater, might be poorly absorbed, or rejected by cellular tissue sites. Even if the human tissue suddenly developed the ability to absorb inorganic minerals from tap water, it would take an enormous amount of tap water to supply the bare minimal mineral quantities for human life functions.

    I was never anything close to a water connoisseur. Until I started drinking distilled water years ago when I started running. Now I think Gainesville, FL tap water tastes like medicine. I don’t know if that’s the chlorine or has to do with the way pharmaceuticals are being found in the water supply in some cities. It’s horrible. I’ve lived in 5 different places with white tubs since I moved here and in every single house or apartment, the water is outright aqua colored. Fill the tub up with plain tap water when a hurricane is coming and see the color.
  • Tap water is yucky (con't)
    Clark, what kind of writing is this? “Meanwhile, 1 in 3 brands are just filtered municipal water, which is essentially glorified tap water.” That’s some hard-hitting reporting. There are two problematic qualifiers in that sentence. Just “filtered”: then it is not just muni water or just tap water. It’s been filtered to some unknown amount. This sounds like County-talk fed to news sources in press releases. How well or how poorly is it filtered?
    The second problem word in that statement is “essentially”. So then, bottled water is NOT the same thing as tap water. How dissimilar is it? What are the essential factors that are not different?

    When I lived in Washington, DC, once in a while I’d come home from work and the water running into a white sink was anywhere from light yellow to brownish. Any time you heard on the evening news about a possible water problem somewhere in the metro area, you were always reassured that it was just particulate from sewer work and the tap water was fine for your health. So what do you do about the times when the color change was too subtle to notice, or your first water use of the evening was in a stainless steel sink?

    I’ll stick with my distilled water though. Yes, it’s cheap at Publix (grocery) and the discount stores. When I move into my own house soon, I’ll get a good system for the house water.
  • Bottled water vs. tap water
    The reason I drink bottled water is that chlorine (a chemical) is bad for you and has been linked to cancers, plus I HATE the taste of it. My tastebuds are so sensitive, I can tell when soup from a restaurant has been made with tap water.
  • water
    It's not just the use of plastic that makes bottled water costly. The actual cost is greater than the price on the bottle. With diesel fuel getting close to $5/gal., (not to mention increases in air pollution and global warming issues) any benefit from drinking water that has been trucked to your local store from across the country or overseas is more than offset by the many costs involved.
  • Tap Water
    While adding chlorine to tap water is necessary to for the water to get to my house bacteria free, I am not interested in drinking or showering with chlorine. All the water I drink at my home is filtered. I do buy bottled water to keep in the car particularly in the summer.
  • Price / Safety
    Where did Clark get his prices from? You don't buy bottled water from a vending machine. Go to Sam's Club. It cost about $5 a case. I figured we use about $600/yrat mostfor two of us, and we recycle the bottles. As for bottled water just being cheap tap water. We had a top notch quality engineer where I worked that came from a bottled water plant and the filtering was extremly complex and highly controled. They used the reverse osmosis process. Sounds better than the $20 carbon filter under the sink to me. Also, I highly doubt that the $20 test is a really good indicator of the water quality.
  • Tap Water
    Ha, a $20 test that tests water? The REAL test for water costs $3500.00. Under sink and faucet attached filters take out the chunky stuff. Filters need to be replaced. Government regulations control what is chemically allowed/not-allowed in tap water which has nothing to do with taste or odor.

    The best non-tap alternative is the 5-gallon bottles and your own mason jar or reusable bottle.

    The media (and Clark) never mention the effectiveness of the 5-gallon bottles (100% re-used) since they always focus on the small bottles.

    MosesSpringWater.com
  • tap water
    right now it's just not fair in Atlanta, we got our water bill on friday, the cities water becomes quickly contaminated and then by sunday and monday my husband and i are sick (vomit & diarrhea). so now we're Also having to buy bottled water just to keep hydrated and healthy. WHY!? it's so expensive, we're paying more for water than gas!
  • Drink Drain Water
    I drink lots of Drain water!!!!

    The water comes from my tap in Drain Oregon!

    It has chlorine but has a somewhat sweet taste probably due to mineral content.
  • NEELY
    Save money and environment by drinking filtered tap water with your own house treatment system. It will ensure you're not consuming any of the 600 chemicals municipal water treatment facilities need to use. THE VERY BEST CHOICES FOR CLEAN WATER ARE REVERSE OSMOSIS AND DISTILLATION. ASK ANY DOCTOR.
  • water testing kit http://www.discovertesting.com/
    Discover Testing does not offer anything even near $20. Cheapest one is 50 bucks!!!
  • fluoride in water
    Many people want to avoid tap water because of fluoride and chlorine, not because of the other contaminates that you mentioned. Many people believe fluoride in the drinking water is terrible for you. Applying it topically via toothpaste is one thing, but ingesting it with every sip of water is another.

    Yes, bottled water is an environmental disaster. But, using a water filter can be a great way to get water that tastes better and has no chlorine and fluoride. Either a re-usable pitcher or whole house water filter fit the bill nicely.
  • Rainwater
    We've been living on rainwater for the past 4 years and I wouldn't trade it for anything - tastes great, less filling.
  • Water Filters
    Regarding distilled water: If there are any children in the household, I also encourage our Customers to tell their pediatrician. They may prescribe a fluoride or other mineral supplement to make up for the minerals that have been removed from the water.

    I'm the Customer Service Manager over at www.fridgefilters.com and can help you with any questions!

    support@fridgefilters.com
  • Re: Distilled water
    Distilled water is a pure source of water. That's true. The problem is that it will actually act like a magnet and leach minerals out of your body and cause sever mineral depletion over many years. At the very least you should be taking a good multi mineral product from the health food store to prevent this from happening. The other option I use it to have the large 5 gallon bottles of water delivered to your house/business. This is a clean source of sprint water w/all the minerals. Studies show that the areas
    that have the hardest water (richest in minerals) have the lowest rates of heart attack because of the higher magnesium content. Take a look. http://www.mgwater.com/anderson.shtml

    http://www.ianrpubs.unl.edu/epublic/live/g1274/build/g1274.pdf

    http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=2265038

    Best,
    Trace D. Farley
  • Placebo response
    Marketing to fears has been a great strategy for filter and bottled water purveyors. Tap water is tap water, even when sold by a large corporation as bottled water. Save your resources and go green with the good stuff from your tap.
  • Distilled Water
    I recently began drinking distilled water from Publix at 77 cents a gallon. The taste is spectacular and it is convenient to purchase and drink the water from the same container at less than the cost of a small bottle of water or soda. Then just recycle the plastic bottle. No Problem, what convenience!
  • water
    i buy distilled water .67 cents/gal.
    my body is a chemical machine and water H2O is a base componient. my body requires water not the calcium ladent sludge that the city pumps out to line there water pipes with lime!
    wise up, plastic is recycled and provide green jobs for unsckilled workers.
    thanks for all/most that you do.
    sincerely
  • Water
    We believe our municipal tap water is safe, but we don't like its taste. We are concerned about bacteria growing in charcoal filters. We also are concerned about wasted water when flushing undersink treatment units. So, we are distilling our tap water. Research tells us that nutritionally we don't get that many minerals from drinking water. We like the taste of the distilled water. The process uses very little electricity.
  • Water
    Clark, how about Brita and Puree filters that are put on the faucet. Are they worth having?? Also the filter in the freezer?
  • Water Tests &Filters
    The Watersafe Company also sells the Brita Water Filter which only filters out a few contaminants. Amway sells a water treatment system that "...has been thoroughly tested and documented for reduction of..." (over 130 contaminants).
  • tap drinking water
    The water test mentioned here is insufficient. It only tests for a few contaminants. Has anyone heard about the pharmasuedicals in our drinking water? There is a difference between safe and pure. I work in the water treatment industry and have replaced enough water exhausted water filters to understand that our tap water is not nearly as pure as it can be with proper filtration.
  • Tap Drinking Water
    many times water can be super safe and still not smell or taste right. We installed a $50 carbon filter une the sink a couple of years ago. It costs us about $25/year and we thik it taste better. At least it removes some of the chlorine.
advertisement
THIS WEEK'S POLL
advertisement
advertisement