Clarkhoward Home

Mon-Fri 1-4pm ET
Stations near you | help

Video Minute Archives
Daily Audio Archives
Rip-off Alerts
Call of the Week

Today's Show Notes
Previous Show Notes
Clark's Greatest Hits
Free and Cheap

Ask Team Clark
Call 10am-7pm ET
(404) 892-8227

Member Center
Blogs
Newsletters
Message boards
Meet the Team

Appearances
Books
Photos
TV
Talk to Clark 1-4pm ET:
(877) 87-CLARK or
(404) 872-0750

Advertisement
Ask Clark  Looking for something on the site? Search for it here!  Also see Clark's Greatest Hits
help

Just say no to 401(k) debit cards

Clark often promises to help you avoid getting ripped off. But what happens when you rip yourself off? Clark is very upset about a report he read on TheStreet.com talking about employers offering 401(k) debit cards! Employers don't like the paperwork hassle of employees taking loans against their 401(k), but this type of debit card offers a way around the paperwork. 401(k) debit cards have been around for about 5 years and they're gaining in popularity. Clark wants you to know that they're a horrible idea. People are being told it's such a great deal to borrow from yourself -- because you pay yourself back instead of a bank. But this is a fallacy. Here's why: Money in a 401(k) is pre-tax dollars, while you have to use after-tax dollars to pay yourself back. So you might pay $1.50 in real money to pay back $1 to your 401(k).

But wait, it gets worse. If you lose your job, the money is due back in the plan right away. If you can't pay back the loan, you trigger a huge tax burden and penalty because the borrowed money is treated as a premature distribution from your 401(k). You'll incur around 40 percent tax and penalty. So say you borrowed $10K from your 401(k). You will now owe the IRS around $4K you may not have because of your job loss. There are some desperate situations where borrowing against your 401(k) may work, but Clark says you must exhaust all other possibilities first. The feds should have never approved this 401(k) debit card. Clark believes 401(k) contributions should be mandatory and withdrawals should be banned.

Unfortunately, Clark won't be able to answer any questions submitted via commenting. If you have a question, please try posting it to our message boards.

Add your comment

Security Image * Please enter the code shown at left
what's this?

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post one!


Advertisement


This week's poll
Which of these recent rip-off alerts shocked you the most?
Campuses taking kickbacks from health insurers.
AT&T settling a lawsuit over 3rd party billing charges.
Online loans coming with interest rates as high as 2,000%.
Scamsters pretending to collect funds for flood-relief charities.
All of the above.
None of the above.
see previous polls


Advertisement